10Best.Guide

American Girl Dolls

Top Picks

Last Updated: April, 2023
Pros
  • Cute and not creepy.
  • Beautiful and well-made.
  • Smaller size compared to standard AG dolls.
  • Comes with cute and well-made clothes.
  • Giftable and comes in a nice package.
Cons
  • Made of hard plastic.
  • Legs and other parts can break easily.
Bottom Line
The Wellie Wishers Camille doll is a cute and well-made addition to a collection, but it is made of hard plastic and can break easily. It is also expensive for the quality. However, the company backs up their products and it comes with cute clothes and a nice package.
Pros
  • Perfect size and price for younger children
  • New 2021 version has a sturdy vinyl body
  • Silky hair that is easy to maintain
  • Well-made and durable
  • Cute princess outfit with metallic Mary-Jane wellies
Cons
  • Eyes do not close for sleeping
  • Leg broke off easily after one day of play
Bottom Line
The WellieWishers Ashlyn doll is a great option for younger children who want their own American Girl doll at a more affordable price. The new 2021 version has a sturdy body and comes with a cute princess outfit. However, the eyes do not close for sleeping and there have been reports of the leg breaking off easily.
Pros
  • + High quality and well-made dolls
  • + Interchangeable outfits with other 18 inch dolls
  • + Diverse range of skin tones, face shapes, and hair and eye colors
  • + Sturdy and not easy to tear apart
  • + Beautiful and stylish dolls
Cons
  • Expensive
  • Some dolls come in cheap packaging
Bottom Line
American Girl dolls are high quality and well-made, with a diverse range of options for customers to choose from. However, they come with a high price tag and some customers have received dolls in cheap packaging. The included outfits may not be up to par with the price, but the dolls themselves are beautiful and stylish.
Pros
  • Beautiful doll
  • Inclusive representation
  • Cheaper price than in-person
  • Well-made and durable
  • Foam packaging
Cons
  • Wrong doll received
  • Damaged box
Bottom Line
The American Girl Truly Me Doll is a beautiful and well-made doll that offers inclusive representation. It comes with stylish outfits and shoes, a cute journal, and durable foam packaging. However, some customers have received the wrong doll or a damaged box, and the wig may shed. The outfit is also limited to a long tee-shirt, nightgown type.
Pros
  • High quality and retains resale value.
  • Diverse and modern style.
  • Comes with a cute story book.
  • Moveable limbs and eyes.
  • Soft body and hair.
Cons
  • Loose limbs on some dolls.
  • Overpriced.
Bottom Line
American Girl dolls are high-quality, diverse, and modern dolls that come with cute story books and moveable limbs and eyes. While some dolls may have loose limbs and the price may be high, they are well-made with beautiful details and vibrant hair colors.

The Ultimate Buying Guide for American Girl Dolls: Types, Features, Prices, and More

Overview

American Girl dolls have been popular among girls of all ages for decades. These dolls are known for their high quality, attention to detail, and inspiring stories that teach valuable life lessons. If you're looking to buy an American Girl doll, this buying guide will provide you with all the information you need to make an informed purchase decision.

Types

American Girl dolls come in a variety of types, each with its own unique features and characteristics. Here are some of the most popular types of American Girl dolls:

1. Historical Characters: These dolls represent important periods in American history, such as the Revolutionary War, Civil War, and World War II. Each doll comes with a book that tells her story and teaches girls about the historical period she represents.

2. Girl of the Year: These dolls represent modern-day girls who are making a positive difference in their communities. Each doll comes with a book that tells her story and teaches girls about important issues like bullying, environmentalism, and diversity.

3. Truly Me: These dolls are customizable and allow girls to create a doll that looks like them. They come with a variety of hair, eye, and skin color options, as well as different outfits and accessories.

4. Bitty Baby: These dolls are designed for younger children and come with a variety of accessories like strollers, cribs, and high chairs.

Key Considerations

When buying an American Girl doll, there are a few key considerations to keep in mind:

1. Age: Consider the age of the child who will be playing with the doll. Some dolls, like the Bitty Baby, are designed for younger children, while others, like the historical characters, are better suited for older children.

2. Interests: Consider the child's interests when choosing a doll. If she loves history, a historical character might be a good choice. If she's interested in modern issues, a Girl of the Year doll might be a better fit.

3. Budget: American Girl dolls can be expensive, so it's important to consider your budget when making a purchase decision.

Features

American Girl dolls come with a variety of features and accessories. Here are some of the most popular features:

1. Clothes: American Girl dolls come with a variety of outfits and accessories, including dresses, pants, shoes, and hats.

2. Furniture: Many American Girl dolls come with furniture and accessories like beds, chairs, and desks.

3. Books: Each American Girl doll comes with a book that tells her story and teaches girls about important issues.

Prices

American Girl dolls can be expensive, with prices ranging from $60 to $200 or more. Here are some of the factors that can affect the price:

1. Type of doll: Historical characters and Girl of the Year dolls tend to be more expensive than Truly Me and Bitty Baby dolls.

2. Accessories: Dolls that come with more accessories, like furniture and clothing, tend to be more expensive.

Tips

Here are some tips to help you choose the right American Girl doll:

1. Do your research: Read reviews and do some research to find the doll that's right for you.

2. Consider your child's interests: Choose a doll that aligns with your child's interests and personality.

3. Set a budget: Consider your budget when making a purchase decision.

FAQs

Q: Are American Girl dolls worth the price?

A: American Girl dolls are known for their high quality and attention to detail, which can justify the higher price tag. However, it's important to consider your budget and the child's interests before making a purchase decision.

Q: Can American Girl dolls be customized?

A: Yes, Truly Me dolls can be customized with different hair, eye, and skin color options.

Q: Do American Girl dolls come with books?

A: Yes, each American Girl doll comes with a book that tells her story and teaches girls about important issues.

Q: Are American Girl dolls appropriate for all ages?

A: Some American Girl dolls, like the Bitty Baby, are designed for younger children, while others, like the historical characters, are better suited for older children. It's important to consider the age of the child when choosing a doll.

Runner-Ups

Pros
  • Good quality and well-made.
  • Shipping and packaging were great.
  • Loved by granddaughters.
  • Perfect gift for young girls.
  • Great products and quality dolls.
Cons
  • Expensive.
  • Late delivery.
Bottom Line
American Girl Dolls are high-quality and loved by many, but they can be expensive. Some customers have raised concerns about the brand's involvement in controversial topics.
Pros
  • Beautiful and high-quality doll
  • Cute and well-made clothes and accessories
  • Great value compared to buying from American Girl website
  • Finally a Hispanic American Girl doll with curly hair
  • Soft and high-quality hair with lots of curls
Cons
  • Expensive compared to other dolls
  • Thin and cheap underwear
Bottom Line
This American Girl doll is a beautiful and high-quality toy that is perfect for imaginative play and makes a great gift for Christmas or birthdays. However, it is expensive compared to other dolls and some customers have reported issues with the hair and eyes. Overall, it is a great purchase for those who value quality and brand recognition.
Pros
  • Well-made outfit
  • Attention to detail
  • Diverse range of skin tones, face shapes, hair, and eye colors
  • High-quality hair
  • Inclusion and empowerment foundation
Cons
  • Expensive
  • Hair gets out of control quickly
Bottom Line
The American Girl Truly Me dolls are well-made with attention to detail and a diverse range of options. However, they are expensive and the hair can be difficult to maintain.
Pros
  • Cute set for dolls
  • Perfect gift for 10-year-old granddaughter
  • Great accessories for playing dress-up
  • Good quality, comparable to American Girl dolls
  • 5-year-old granddaughter loved it
Cons
  • Misleading advertising with doll shown in picture
  • Missing some accessories
Bottom Line
This is a cute set of doll accessories that is comparable in quality to American Girl dolls. However, the advertising can be misleading and some customers have received damaged or incomplete products. Make sure to read the fine print and understand that the doll is not included for the price.
Pros
  • Adorable and cute doll
  • Great attention to detail
  • Perfect for younger children
  • Bendable arms and legs
  • Lower cost than original American Girl Dolls
Cons
  • Not comparable to the authentic American Doll
  • Not worth the high price
Bottom Line
The American Girl WellieWisher Willa Doll is an adorable and well-made doll that is perfect for younger children. However, it lacks interactive features and is not worth the high price. It is a good alternative to the more expensive American Girl Dolls, but keep in mind that it is smaller and clothes may not fit properly.
Please add more products to compare
You can compare up to four products at once
{{compareData.brand}}