10Best.Guide

Baking Sheets

Top Picks

Last Updated: October, 2023
Pros
  • Saves time on clean-up
  • Perfect size for baking pans
  • Thick and high-quality paper
  • Food doesn't stick to it
  • Easy to make custom cuts
Cons
  • Comes folded in quarters, not flat
  • Some found it too small
Bottom Line
Reynolds pre-cut parchment paper is a high-quality product that saves time on clean-up and fits perfectly in baking pans. However, it comes folded in quarters and may be too small for some users.
Pros
  • Convenient and easy to use
  • Perfect size for most sheet pans
  • Easy to dispense and store
  • Makes clean-up a breeze
  • Cheaper than other pre-cut parchment paper options
Cons
  • Texture is waxier than other parchment paper
  • Wetness from baked goods can seep through
Bottom Line
This pre-cut parchment paper is a convenient and easy-to-use option for baking and cooking. It makes clean-up a breeze and is cheaper than other pre-cut options. However, the texture may not be ideal for everyone, and the packaging and sheet size can be a bit of a hassle.
Pros
  • Good quality pan
  • Sturdy
  • Heat distribution is perfect
  • Best baking sheets ever bought
  • Delivered quickly
Cons
  • Delicate
  • Hard to clean
Bottom Line
Nordic Ware baking sheets are a good quality, sturdy option for baking, with excellent heat distribution. However, they can be delicate and difficult to clean, and some customers have experienced issues with warping, discoloration, and quality control.
Pros
  • Large size for batch cooking and baking
  • Durable and withstands high temperature cooking
  • Easy to clean
  • Fits in standard ovens with good air flow
  • Good for cooking large cuts of meat and fish
Cons
  • Not dishwasher safe
  • May develop stains over time
Bottom Line
The Nordicware Big Sheet is a durable and versatile baking pan that is perfect for batch cooking and baking. It is easy to clean and fits in standard ovens, but may develop stains over time and is not dishwasher safe.
Pros
  • Fits perfectly in convection oven
  • High quality and even heat distribution
  • Affordable price
  • Sturdy and nonstick surface
  • Practical and ergonomic design
Cons
  • Confusing instructions regarding dishwasher safety
  • Damaged corners upon delivery
Bottom Line
This baking sheet offers even heat distribution, a nonstick surface, and practical design, but it may have issues with size, durability, and odor.

The Ultimate Buying Guide for Baking Sheets

Overview

In the world of baking, having the right tools is essential for achieving perfect results. One such tool is the baking sheet, a versatile kitchen essential that is used for a variety of baking tasks. Whether you're baking cookies, roasting vegetables, or making sheet cakes, a good baking sheet can make all the difference. This comprehensive buying guide will help you navigate through the different types of baking sheets, understand key considerations, explore various features, compare prices, and provide expert tips to help you make an informed decision.

Types

1. Non-Stick Baking Sheets: These sheets feature a non-stick coating that prevents food from sticking, making them ideal for baking delicate cookies and pastries.

2. Stainless Steel Baking Sheets: Known for their durability and even heat distribution, stainless steel baking sheets are perfect for achieving crispy results.

3. Aluminum Baking Sheets: Lightweight and affordable, aluminum baking sheets are a popular choice for everyday baking tasks.

4. Silicone Baking Sheets: These flexible and non-stick sheets are great for baking sticky or gooey foods, and they also eliminate the need for parchment paper.

Key Considerations

1. Size: Consider the dimensions of the baking sheet to ensure it fits your oven and meets your baking needs.

2. Material: Different materials offer varying heat conductivity, durability, and maintenance requirements. Choose a material that suits your preferences and cooking style.

3. Rimmed vs. Rimless: Rimmed baking sheets are ideal for containing juices and preventing spills, while rimless sheets allow for easy sliding of baked goods.

4. Heat Resistance: Ensure the baking sheet can withstand high temperatures without warping or discoloration.

5. Cleaning and Maintenance: Consider the ease of cleaning and whether the baking sheet is dishwasher-safe.

Features

1. Non-Stick Coating: Look for a high-quality non-stick coating that ensures easy food release and effortless cleaning.

2. Heat Distribution: Opt for baking sheets with even heat distribution to promote consistent baking results.

3. Warp Resistance: Choose baking sheets that are warp-resistant, ensuring they maintain their shape even under high temperatures.

4. Grips or Handles: Baking sheets with grips or handles make it easier to transfer them in and out of the oven safely.

5. Compatibility: Check if the baking sheet is compatible with other kitchen tools like cooling racks or silicone mats.

Prices

Baking sheet prices vary based on material, size, and brand. Prices typically range from $10 to $50, with stainless steel and silicone baking sheets often being on the higher end of the price spectrum.

Tips

1. Preheating: Always preheat your baking sheet before adding the food to ensure even baking.

2. Cleaning: Avoid using abrasive materials or metal utensils that can damage the non-stick coating.

3. Storage: Store baking sheets in a cool and dry place to prevent warping.

4. Multiple Sheets: Consider purchasing multiple baking sheets to accommodate larger baking projects or when baking multiple items simultaneously.

5. Use Parchment Paper or Silicone Mats: Using parchment paper or silicone mats can prolong the lifespan of your baking sheets and make cleaning easier.

FAQs

Q: Are baking sheets and cookie sheets the same?

Q: Can I use a baking sheet for roasting vegetables?

Q: How do I clean a baking sheet with burnt-on food?

Q: Can I use a baking sheet without parchment paper or silicone mats?

Q: How often should I replace my baking sheets?

A: By following this comprehensive buying guide, you'll be equipped with the knowledge to choose the perfect baking sheet that meets your needs and elevates your baking game. Happy baking!

Runner-Ups

Pros
  • Sturdy and thick
  • Non-warping
  • Easy to clean
  • Good value for the price
  • Versatile sizes provided in the set
Cons
  • Warps slightly in the oven
  • Not dishwasher safe
Bottom Line
These baking sheets are a great value for the price, offering sturdy construction and easy cleaning. However, they may warp slightly in the oven and require handwashing. The dark finish may also cause faster browning on the bottom.
Pros
  • Heavy and sturdy
  • Nice non-stick surface
  • Good quality
  • Standard size
  • Easy to clean
Cons
  • Warps easily
  • Leaves a gap for water to collect
Bottom Line
These baking sheets are heavy and sturdy with a nice non-stick surface, but they tend to warp easily and have some issues with staining and rusting. They are a good choice for baking cookies and crackers, but may not be the best option for other uses.
Pros
  • Easy to clean
  • Silicone mats are helpful
  • Different sizes are useful
  • Non-stick pads work well
  • Lightweight
Cons
  • Warps easily
  • Stains easily
Bottom Line
These baking sheet pans are a good value for the price, but they have some durability issues and may not be suitable for high-temperature cooking. The silicone mats are a helpful addition, but the pans may stain and warp easily.
Pros
  • Non-stick surface works well
  • Easy to clean
  • Multiple sizes available
  • Lip around the edge makes it easy to handle
  • Wide grips on the sides make it easier to hold
Cons
  • May rust easily
  • May stain easily
Bottom Line
These baking pans are a good choice for those looking for non-stick, easy-to-clean pans at a reasonable price. However, they may rust and stain easily, and may arrive with small dents. Additionally, they may emit fumes that are harmful to birds.
Pros
  • Non-stick surface
  • Easy to clean
  • Durable and sturdy
  • Good quality for the price
  • Versatile size for small items
Cons
  • Rusting issues
  • Smaller than expected
Bottom Line
The Wilton Easy Layers Sheet Cake Pan set is a good choice for those looking for non-stick, easy to clean, and durable baking sheets at an affordable price. However, buyers should be aware of potential rusting issues and the smaller than expected size.
Please add more products to compare
You can compare up to four products at once
{{compareData.brand}}