10Best.Guide

Black Licorice

Top Picks

Last Updated: November, 2023
Pros
  • Delicious flavor
  • High quality
  • Clean and portable
  • Gluten-free option available
  • Cute and appealing design
Cons
  • Hard texture
  • Stickiness can be an issue
Bottom Line
Gimbal's Scotty Dogs offer a delicious and high-quality licorice option, with a clean and portable design. However, the texture can be hard and the stickiness may be a concern for some. Overall, it is a great choice for licorice lovers, especially those with gluten intolerance.
Pros
  • Good taste
  • Convenient size
  • Affordable price
  • Good for digestion
  • Original recipe
Cons
  • Smaller size than expected
  • Mild flavor
Bottom Line
Twizzlers Nibs are a good option for those who enjoy black licorice, with a convenient size and affordable price. However, the flavor may be too mild or artificial for some, and it contains an ingredient that can be harmful to some people.
Pros
  • Intense flavors (cherry, apple, lemon, raspberry)
  • Authentic flavor (horehound, licorice)
  • Great for dry mouth, cough, and scratchy throat
  • Nostalgic candy for some buyers
  • Good for licorice lovers
Cons
  • Weak flavor (root beer)
  • Air bubbles can create sharp edges
Bottom Line
Claey's Old Fashioned Hard Candies offer intense and authentic flavors that are great for dry mouth, cough, and scratchy throat. However, some flavors may be weak or boring, and some candies may have air bubbles that can hurt your tongue. Additionally, buyers may need to purchase too many bags in one purchase.
Pros
  • Delicious taste
  • Soft candy shell
  • Great for licorice lovers
  • Better than Good-n-Plenty
  • Incredibly soft and delicious
Cons
  • Candy coating is chalky
  • Smaller and sweeter than previous version
Bottom Line
Wiley Wallaby Licorice Beans are a great choice for licorice lovers who want a soft candy shell and delicious taste. However, some customers have complained about the chalky candy coating and the wrong candy being received.
Pros
  • Fresh and good taste
  • Great for licorice lovers
  • Convenient multipack
  • Affordable price
  • Strong licorice flavor
Cons
  • Stale or hard candy
  • Inconsistent quality
Bottom Line
Good & Plenty candy is a great choice for licorice lovers who want a convenient and affordable multipack. However, be aware that the quality can be inconsistent and some people may not enjoy the black licorice flavor. It's important to check the freshness of the candy before purchasing, as it may be stale or hard.

The Ultimate Buying Guide for Black Licorice

Overview

Are you a black licorice enthusiast looking for the best options on the market? Look no further! In this comprehensive buying guide, we'll explore the various types of black licorice, key considerations when making a purchase, important features to look for, pricing information, helpful tips, and frequently asked questions. Whether you prefer soft or hard black licorice, gourmet or organic options, we've got you covered.

Types

1. Soft Black Licorice: Indulge in the chewy texture and rich flavor of soft black licorice, which is often made with natural ingredients and offers a delightful taste experience.

2. Hard Black Licorice: Enjoy the satisfying crunch of hard black licorice, perfect for those who prefer a firmer texture and longer-lasting treat.

3. Gourmet Black Licorice: Elevate your licorice experience with gourmet options that feature unique flavors, premium ingredients, and artisanal craftsmanship.

4. Organic Black Licorice: For health-conscious consumers, organic black licorice offers a guilt-free option made without synthetic additives or pesticides.

5. Sugar-Free Black Licorice: Individuals with dietary restrictions or those watching their sugar intake can still enjoy the distinct flavor of black licorice with sugar-free alternatives.

Key Considerations

- Flavor preferences: Determine whether you prefer traditional black licorice or explore variations like strawberry, cherry, or salty licorice.

- Allergies and dietary restrictions: Check ingredient lists for potential allergens or ensure the licorice is suitable for specific dietary needs.

- Texture: Decide between soft or hard licorice based on personal preference.

- Brand reputation: Consider purchasing from reputable brands known for their high-quality licorice products.

- Packaging: Choose between individually wrapped pieces or bulk packaging based on your consumption habits.

Features

- Intense licorice flavor: Look for licorice that offers a bold and authentic taste.

- Freshness and shelf life: Opt for licorice that remains fresh for a longer period, ensuring optimal enjoyment.

- Texture and chewiness: Determine the desired texture, whether you prefer a soft, chewy licorice or a harder, more substantial bite.

- Natural ingredients: Consider licorice made with natural flavors and colors for a more wholesome treat.

- Variety of shapes and sizes: Some licorice brands offer a range of shapes and sizes, adding to the visual appeal of the candy.

Prices

Black licorice prices can vary depending on the brand, type, and packaging size. Generally, gourmet and organic options tend to be slightly more expensive than traditional brands. It's advisable to compare prices across different retailers or online platforms to find the best deal that suits your budget.

Tips

1. Store licorice properly: To maintain freshness, store licorice in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight.

2. Experiment with flavors: Don't be afraid to try different flavors and brands to find your favorite black licorice variety.

3. Read customer reviews: Check out online reviews to get insights into the taste, texture, and overall quality of different black licorice products.

4. Consider gifting options: Black licorice can make for a unique and delicious gift for licorice lovers or candy enthusiasts.

FAQs

Q: Is black licorice suitable for vegetarians or vegans?

A: While most black licorice is vegetarian-friendly, it's essential to check the ingredient list for any animal-derived ingredients. Some brands offer vegan options as well.

Q: Can black licorice be used in baking?

A: Yes, black licorice can be used in baking to add a distinct flavor to cookies, cakes, or other sweet treats. Look for licorice specifically labeled for baking purposes.

Q: Does black licorice have any health benefits?

A: Black licorice has been associated with potential health benefits, including digestive aid and potential anti-inflammatory properties. However, it's important to consume licorice in moderation and consult with a healthcare professional if you have any underlying health conditions.

In addition to the above sections, you can consider adding a section on "Where to Buy Black Licorice" to provide readers with information on reputable retailers or online platforms that offer a wide selection of black licorice products.

Runner-Ups

Pros
  • Rich full flavor of the licorice
  • Contains real licorice root extract
  • Non-GMO
  • Excellent licorice flavor
  • Fresh and soft
Cons
  • Horrible packaging
  • Too soft and sticky
Bottom Line
This licorice has a rich full flavor and contains real licorice root extract. It is fresh and soft, but the packaging is a problem. It is too soft and sticky, and some bags won't open properly. It also tastes more like anise than licorice. However, it is non-GMO and jammed with flavor.
Pros
  • Intense, dark solid licorice flavor
  • Chewy and soft texture
  • Not overly sweet
  • Strong licorice taste that lingers pleasantly
  • True strong licorice flavor
Cons
  • Some batches may be slightly stale or hard
  • May not be as soft as expected
Bottom Line
This Finnish licorice offers an intense, chewy, and true licorice flavor that is not overly sweet. It may have some inconsistencies in texture and taste, but overall it is a great choice for licorice lovers looking for a high-quality product.
Pros
  • Delicious taste
  • Great price per pound
  • Good alternative for those who can't have licorice
  • Better than other brands like Brach's
  • Perfect for black licorice lovers
Cons
  • Some people may find them too large
  • Not intensely flavored
Bottom Line
These SweetGourmet Jelly Beans are a great option for black licorice lovers looking for a delicious and affordable treat. While some may find them too large, they are full of flavor and a good alternative for those who can't have licorice. However, be aware of inconsistent quality between bags and the taste of the jelly bean itself may not be to everyone's liking.
Pros
  • Superior freshness compared to boxed packaging.
  • Classic candy-coated licorice with outstanding flavor.
  • Small packaging with plenty of treats.
  • Tasted fresh and soft-ish.
  • Great value compared to other sales.
Cons
  • Candy is hard and difficult to chew.
  • Some packages seem old and not as fresh.
Bottom Line
Good & Plenty is a classic candy with a great flavor, but it may not always be fresh and can be expensive. It is recommended for licorice lovers who don't mind the chewiness and are willing to pay a higher price.
Pros
  • Good deal for black licorice lovers
  • Soft texture and full of flavor
  • True licorice taste
  • Hard to find in stores
  • Addictive and delicious
Cons
  • Contains high fructose corn syrup
  • Not very chewy
Bottom Line
Red Vines Black Licorice is a great option for those who love the true taste of licorice and are looking for a soft and flavorful candy. However, it contains high fructose corn syrup and may not be very chewy. It may also arrive stale or disintegrate easily. It is a good deal for black licorice lovers but may not be suitable for diabetics due to its high sugar content.
Please add more products to compare
You can compare up to four products at once
{{compareData.brand}}