10Best.Guide

Brow Mascara

Top Picks

Last Updated: June, 2023
Pros
  • Keeps eyebrows in place
  • Affordable
  • Dries clear
  • Lasts all day
  • Natural looking
Cons
  • May leave yellowish residue
  • May flake off in dry white pieces
Bottom Line
NYX Control Freak Eyebrow Gel is an affordable and effective option for keeping eyebrows in place all day. However, it may not work for everyone and may require multiple layers to hold hairs in place. It may also leave yellowish residue and flake off in dry white pieces.
Pros
  • Covers gray hairs
  • Matches natural hair color
  • Easy to apply
  • Long-lasting
  • Defines and tames unruly eyebrows
Cons
  • Inconsistent quality between versions
  • New brush design is not as good
Bottom Line
Maybelline New York Eyestudio Brow Drama Tinted Gel Mousse is an affordable and effective product for covering gray hairs, defining and taming unruly eyebrows, and matching natural hair color. However, the quality and brush design may vary between versions, and it may not work well for those with thick eyebrows or those who need to pencil in blanks.
Pros
  • Provides natural-looking results
  • Long-lasting
  • Affordable
  • Easy to use
  • Covers grey hairs
Cons
  • Fragile packaging
  • Learning curve for application
Bottom Line
This brow mascara is an affordable and easy-to-use option that provides natural-looking and long-lasting results. However, the packaging is fragile and there is a learning curve for application. Additionally, the product may dry out quickly and smear on rainy days. The color range is also limited.
Pros
  • Creates full, natural-looking brows
  • Easy to use
  • Good for thinning brows
  • Maximum control with tiny wand
  • Good for covering scars and gray hairs
Cons
  • Gets clumpy and dries out quickly
  • Color may not match what was ordered
Bottom Line
This eyebrow gel is easy to use and great for creating full, natural-looking brows. However, it may dry out quickly and the color may not match what was ordered. It is also quite small for the price.
Pros
  • True brown color
  • Fast delivery and nice packaging
  • Thicken existing hairs
  • Best brow product
  • Natural looking brows
Cons
  • Applicator sucks
  • Clumpy and fake-looking
Bottom Line
This brow volumizer is a great product that fills in brows and thickens existing hairs. It has a true brown color and is cheap. However, the applicator can be clumpy and fake-looking, and the Auburn color is too red and light.

The Ultimate Buying Guide for Brow Mascara: Types, Key Considerations, Features, Prices, Tips, and FAQs

Overview

Brow mascara is a popular beauty product that can help you achieve fuller, more defined eyebrows. With so many options available, it can be difficult to choose the right one for your needs. In this buying guide, we'll cover the different types of brow mascara, key considerations to keep in mind when shopping, features to look for, prices, tips for applying and maintaining your brow mascara, and frequently asked questions.

Types

- Tinted Brow Mascara: This type of brow mascara comes in a variety of shades and is designed to add color and definition to your eyebrows.

- Clear Brow Mascara: Clear brow mascara is a transparent gel that can help tame unruly brows and keep them in place throughout the day.

- Fiber Brow Mascara: Fiber brow mascara contains tiny fibers that adhere to your brow hairs, making them appear fuller and thicker.

- Waterproof Brow Mascara: If you're looking for a long-lasting option, waterproof brow mascara is a great choice. It's designed to be sweat-proof and water-resistant, so it won't smudge or smear.

Key Considerations

- Shade: When choosing a tinted brow mascara, make sure to select a shade that matches your natural hair color.

- Formula: Consider your skin type and any allergies you may have when selecting a brow mascara formula. Some formulas may be too harsh for sensitive skin or contain ingredients that you're allergic to.

- Hold: If you have unruly brows, look for a brow mascara with a strong hold to keep them in place.

- Brush: The brush size and shape can make a big difference in the application of your brow mascara. Consider the shape of your eyebrows and choose a brush that will help you achieve your desired look.

Features

- Long-lasting wear

- Smudge-proof and water-resistant formula

- Nourishing ingredients like vitamins and antioxidants

- Easy-to-use applicator brush

- Buildable coverage for a natural or dramatic look

Prices

Brow mascaras come in a wide range of prices, from drugstore options to high-end luxury brands. You can expect to pay anywhere from $5 to $50 for a quality brow mascara.

Tips

- Brush your eyebrows upward before applying the mascara to help shape them.

- Use a light hand when applying the mascara to avoid clumping or over-applying.

- Remove excess product from the brush before applying to avoid making a mess.

- Apply the mascara in short, upward strokes to mimic the natural growth of your eyebrows.

- Use a spoolie brush to blend the product and create a more natural look.

FAQs

Q: How do I choose the right shade of brow mascara?

A: Look for a shade that matches your natural hair color. If you have blonde hair, choose a light brown or blonde shade. If you have brown or black hair, choose a darker shade.

Q: Can I use brow mascara if I have sparse brows?

A: Yes, brow mascara can help fill in sparse areas and make your brows appear fuller.

Q: How do I remove brow mascara?

A: Use a makeup remover or micellar water to gently remove the mascara from your eyebrows.

Q: How often should I replace my brow mascara?

A: It's recommended to replace your brow mascara every 3-6 months to prevent bacteria growth and ensure optimal performance.

Q: Can I use brow mascara if I have sensitive skin?

A: Yes, just make sure to choose a formula that is specifically designed for sensitive skin and doesn't contain harsh ingredients.

Runner-Ups

Pros
  • Lasts all day
  • Easy to use and apply
  • Fills in eyebrows and sculpts them
  • Keeps brows in place
  • Goes on with full color
Cons
  • Color description is vague
  • Shade may be too dark for some
Bottom Line
Maybelline TattooStudio Brow Tint Pen is a long-lasting, easy-to-use product that fills in and sculpts eyebrows while keeping them in place. It covers gray and white hairs, matches brow color well, and tames unruly hairs for a natural look. However, the color description is vague, the shade may be too dark for some, and the brush could be improved.
Pros
  • Thin brush for precise application
  • Long-wearing
  • Natural-looking shades
  • Easy to use
  • Affordable
Cons
  • Difficult to apply neatly
  • Thick formula can cause uneven application
Bottom Line
Almay Brow Styler is an affordable and easy-to-use product with a thin brush for precise application and natural-looking shades. However, it may not work for those with wild or thick eyebrows and can be difficult to apply neatly.
Pros
  • Holds brows in place all day
  • Defines brows without feeling like glue
  • Subtle tint for natural look
  • Easy to remove
  • Good for on-the-go touch-ups
Cons
  • Spoolie is too small
  • Dries too quickly
Bottom Line
This brow glue is a good option for those looking for a natural-looking hold for their brows. It is easy to use and blends well with makeup, but can dry too quickly and become goopy/clumpy over time.
Pros
  • Perfect color match for blonde/white hair
  • Fibrous consistency builds well without looking cakey
  • Defines brows nicely with just enough color
  • Affordable
  • Good for filling in sparse areas
Cons
  • Product can be old or dried up
  • Comes out clumpy and dries flaky
Bottom Line
Revlon ColorStay Brow Fiber Filler is a good option for those looking for an affordable, long-lasting, and waterproof eyebrow gel that can fill in sparse areas and define brows with just enough color. However, the product can be old or dried up, and the packaging can be defective. Some users have also reported clumpy and flaky application, short brush bristles, and low pigment.
Pros
  • Makes brows look fuller and natural
  • Stays in place all day
  • Easy to use
  • Great price
  • Compressible tube allows for easy access to product
Cons
  • Brush it comes with is not great
  • Can leave brows looking messy
Bottom Line
NYX Thick It. Stick It. Brow Gel is a great affordable option for those looking to fill in their brows and keep them in place all day. However, it may not replace the need for a brow pencil and some shades may not match well.
Please add more products to compare
You can compare up to four products at once
{{compareData.brand}}