10Best.Guide

Charcoal

Top Picks

Last Updated: May, 2023
Pros
  • Lights easily in a chimney
  • Burns cleanly with little ash or creosote build-up
  • Imparts a mild smoky flavor
  • Good quality at a fair price
  • Neutral flavor in food
Cons
  • Poorly taped bag with a tear
  • Box not sufficient for the weight of the bag
Bottom Line
Jealous Devil charcoal is a high-quality product that burns cleanly, imparts a mild smoky flavor, and has good temperature control. It is a bit more expensive than other brands, but it lasts longer and can be reused. However, buyers should be aware of the packaging issues and potential for smaller pieces in the paper bag.
Pros
  • Longevity of burn
  • Mild smoky flavor
  • Excellent burn
  • Big ol' chunks
  • No foreign debris mixed in
Cons
  • Small to almost chip size pieces
  • Bag may break open during shipping
Bottom Line
Kamado Joe Big Block XL Lump Charcoal is a high-quality product with excellent burn and flavor. However, buyers should be aware of the potential for small or large pieces, broken bags during shipping, and varying quality due to transportation and handling.
Pros
  • Burns clean and efficiently.
  • Gives good flavors and great heat.
  • Maintains heat and is quite long-lasting.
  • Becomes hot quickly and cooks well.
  • Comparatively cheaper than pretty much everything else.
Cons
  • Inconsistent size of the pieces.
  • Some bags have inconsistencies.
Bottom Line
This lump charcoal is a good option for those who want a cheaper alternative that burns clean and efficiently, but it may have some inconsistencies in size and quality. It is recommended to use wood chips to enhance the flavor.
Pros
  • Burns much hotter than standard coal.
  • Good burning time.
  • Easy to light up.
  • Truly burn longer, hotter, and more even.
Cons
  • Inconsistent quality.
  • Price increase from last year.
Bottom Line
These coals are great for hot, searing grilling and have a good burning time. They are easy to light up and burn longer, hotter, and more even than standard coal. However, there have been some complaints about inconsistent quality, a bit of smokiness, and a price increase from last year.
Pros
  • Great sustained quality
  • Long-lasting heat
  • Minimal ash production
  • Burns cleaner than other brands
  • Good flavor for most things
Cons
  • Smells like asphalt
  • Some large logs that are too big to be useful
Bottom Line
Cowboy lump charcoal is a good option for those who want a long-lasting and clean-burning fuel source for their smoker or grill. However, it may have some issues with smell, ash production, and difficulty in lighting.

The Ultimate Guide to Buying Charcoal: Types, Features, Prices, and Tips

Overview

Charcoal is a popular fuel source for outdoor cooking enthusiasts. It provides a unique smoky flavor to grilled and smoked meats, making it a favorite among barbecue lovers. However, with so many different types and brands of charcoal available, it can be challenging to choose the right one for your needs. In this guide, we'll cover everything you need to know about buying charcoal, including types, features, prices, and tips.

Types

There are several types of charcoal available on the market, each with its unique characteristics. Here are some of the most common ones:

1. Lump Charcoal: This type of charcoal is made by burning natural hardwood without any additives. It produces less ash and provides a smokier flavor than briquettes.

2. Briquettes: Briquettes are made by compressing charcoal dust and other ingredients, such as sawdust and starch, into uniform shapes. They are easier to light and burn longer than lump charcoal.

3. Natural Charcoal: Natural charcoal is made from sustainable sources and doesn't contain any chemicals or additives. It's an excellent option for those who are concerned about the environment.

4. Hardwood Charcoal: Hardwood charcoal is made from dense hardwoods, such as oak, hickory, and maple. It burns hotter and longer than other types of charcoal and produces a unique flavor.

5. Coconut Charcoal: Coconut charcoal is made from coconut shells and burns hotter and longer than other types of charcoal. It's also eco-friendly and sustainable.

Key Considerations

When choosing charcoal, there are several key considerations to keep in mind. Here are some factors to consider:

1. Flavor: Different types of charcoal produce different flavors. Consider the flavor you want to achieve when selecting your charcoal.

2. Burn Time: Briquettes burn longer than lump charcoal. If you're planning a long cook, briquettes may be the better option.

3. Ash Production: Lump charcoal produces less ash than briquettes. If you don't want to deal with a lot of ash, consider using lump charcoal.

4. Sustainability: If you're concerned about the environment, look for charcoal made from sustainable sources.

Features

Here are some features to consider when buying charcoal:

1. Size: Charcoal comes in different sizes, from small pieces to large chunks. Consider the size you need for your cooking needs.

2. Additives: Some charcoal contains additives, such as lighter fluid or chemicals. Look for charcoal without additives if you're concerned about the environment or your health.

3. Brand: Different brands of charcoal have different qualities. Look for a reputable brand that produces high-quality charcoal.

Prices

Charcoal prices vary depending on the type and brand. Lump charcoal is generally more expensive than briquettes. Natural and sustainable charcoal may also be more expensive. Consider your budget when selecting your charcoal.

Tips

Here are some tips to help you get the most out of your charcoal:

1. Store your charcoal in a dry place to prevent moisture buildup.

2. Use a chimney starter to light your charcoal instead of lighter fluid.

3. Mix different types of charcoal to achieve a unique flavor.

4. Use a grill thermometer to monitor the temperature of your grill.

FAQs

Q: How do I light charcoal without lighter fluid?

A: You can use a chimney starter or an electric charcoal starter to light your charcoal without lighter fluid.

Q: How do I store my charcoal?

A: Store your charcoal in a dry place, away from moisture and humidity.

Q: Can I mix different types of charcoal?

A: Yes, you can mix different types of charcoal to achieve a unique flavor.

Q: Is charcoal eco-friendly?

A: Some types of charcoal, such as natural and sustainable charcoal, are eco-friendly. Look for charcoal made from sustainable sources to reduce your environmental impact.

Conclusion:

Choosing the right charcoal can make all the difference in the flavor and quality of your outdoor cooking. Consider the types, key considerations, features, prices, and tips covered in this guide to make an informed decision. With the right charcoal, you'll be well on your way to creating delicious grilled and smoked meats.

Runner-Ups

Pros
  • Burns hot and consistent temperature
  • Great for getting pellet grill up to temp
  • Water-resistant and cool-looking
  • Good at holding heat and cutting back on pellet use
Cons
  • Shipping can be poor
  • Does not work with all pellet grills
Bottom Line
These charcoal pellets are great for getting your pellet grill up to temperature quickly and holding heat well, but they do not add much smoke or charcoal flavor and may not work with all pellet grills.
Pros
  • Sustainable and organic.
  • Low smoke and good heat.
  • Long-lasting burn.
  • Secure packaging.
  • Easy to ignite and consistent burn.
Cons
  • Pricey for heavy use.
  • Harder to get to white than other brands.
Bottom Line
OLIVETTE Organic Charcoal Briquettes are a great option for those who prioritize sustainability and organic products. They offer a low-smoke, long-lasting burn and are easy to ignite. However, they may be pricey for heavy use and have a rounded shape that can be difficult to position.
Pros
  • Burns longer than traditional briquettes or lump charcoal.
  • Burns hot with clean combustion.
  • Consistent sticks make it easy to maintain even heat.
  • Great for long, slow smoking.
Cons
  • Takes longer to light than conventional briquettes or lump charcoal.
  • Difficult to light.
Bottom Line
Charblox Dragon Fire Bamboo Grilling Charcoal Logs are a great option for those who want to smoke their food for a long time. It burns hot with clean combustion and lasts longer than traditional briquettes or lump charcoal. However, it takes longer to light and may not be suitable for grilling a quick meal.
Pros
  • Fast lighting
  • Long burning time
  • Easy to light
  • Good for incense and hookah
  • Great packaging
Cons
  • Strong chemical smell
  • Burns too quickly
Bottom Line
These coals are great for burning incense and have a fast lighting time, but they have a strong chemical smell and burn too quickly. They are not recommended for hookah use.
Pros
  • Reliable charcoal for grilling and smoking.
  • Good price for two large bags.
  • Nice hot coals for hours.
  • Fast delivery.
  • Identical pieces with no surprise flavor.
Cons
  • Package may arrive damaged with broken briquettes.
  • Difficulty getting briquettes out of the bag.
Bottom Line
Kingsford Original Charcoal is a reliable and affordable option for grilling and smoking. While there may be some issues with packaging and lighting, the majority of customers are satisfied with the quality and performance of this product.
Please add more products to compare
You can compare up to four products at once
{{compareData.brand}}