10Best.Guide

Cheddar Cheese

Top Picks

Last Updated: April, 2023
Pros
  • Great taste and flavor
  • Ideal for charcuterie and pairing with fruits and proteins
  • Good melting consistency
  • Lactose intolerant friendly
  • Creamy taste
Cons
  • Packaging issues
  • Not as sharp as expected
Bottom Line
Cabot's Extra Sharp White Cheddar is a delicious cheese with a creamy taste that is ideal for charcuterie and pairing with fruits and proteins. It has good melting consistency and is lactose intolerant friendly. However, some customers have experienced packaging issues and find it not as sharp as expected, while others find it bland.
Pros
  • Delicious flavor and texture
  • Great for pairing with other foods
  • Amazing flavor and quality
  • Nice texture with a bit of crunch
  • Well-balanced and not too sharp or salty
Cons
  • Flavors may not be for everyone
  • Barely tastes like cheddar cheese
Bottom Line
This cheddar cheese has a delicious flavor and texture that pairs well with other foods. While some may not enjoy the flavors or texture, it is a great option for those looking for a well-balanced and high-quality cheese.
Pros
  • Creamy and buttery flavor
  • Goes well with a variety of dishes
  • High-quality and consistent
  • Great for melting
  • Made from grass-fed dairy
Cons
  • Mild flavor may not be suitable for those looking for a strong, sharp cheddar
  • Some blocks may have mold spots
Bottom Line
Kerrygold cheddar cheese is a high-quality, creamy and buttery cheese that goes well with a variety of dishes. While it may be mild for some, it is a great option for those looking for a smooth and consistent cheddar. However, buyers should be aware of potential mold spots and the higher price point compared to other cheddar options.
Pros
  • Great taste and flavor
  • Good for lactose-free diets
  • Slices well and easy to handle
  • Goes well with fruit, crackers, and in recipes
  • Hard cheese that melts well
Cons
  • Texture can be unpleasant and plastic-like
  • Not as sharp as advertised
Bottom Line
Cabot Seriously Sharp cheddar cheese has a great taste and flavor, is lactose-free, and slices well. However, the texture can be unpleasant, it may not be as sharp as advertised, and it is overpriced. It is a good choice for those who like strong cheeses and are looking for a lactose-free option.
Pros
  • Healthy food choices
  • Delicious taste
  • Fresh and convenient
  • Good addition to food items
  • Bold and pleasant flavor
Cons
  • Cheese molds quickly after opening
  • Mild flavor compared to other sharp cheddars
Bottom Line
This cheese has a delicious taste and is a great addition to food items. However, it molds quickly after opening, which can be frustrating. It has a reasonable price and good quality packaging.

The Ultimate Buying Guide for Cheddar Cheese: Types, Key Considerations, Features, Prices, Tips, and FAQs

Overview

Cheddar cheese is one of the most popular types of cheese in the world. It's versatile, delicious, and can be enjoyed on its own or used in a variety of dishes. But with so many different types of cheddar cheese available, it can be difficult to know which one to choose. In this buying guide, we'll take a closer look at the different types of cheddar cheese, key considerations when buying cheddar cheese, features to look for, prices, tips, and FAQs.

Types

1. Aged Cheddar Cheese: Aged cheddar cheese is aged for at least 12 months, giving it a sharper, more complex flavor. It's perfect for adding depth to dishes like mac and cheese or grilled cheese sandwiches.

2. Sharp Cheddar Cheese: Sharp cheddar cheese has been aged for 6 to 12 months, giving it a tangy, bold flavor. It's great for snacking or adding to burgers and sandwiches.

3. Mild Cheddar Cheese: Mild cheddar cheese is aged for only a few months, giving it a milder, creamier flavor. It's perfect for melting in dishes like quesadillas or omelets.

4. White Cheddar Cheese: White cheddar cheese is made without the addition of annatto, which gives it a natural white color. It has a slightly different flavor profile than yellow cheddar cheese.

5. Yellow Cheddar Cheese: Yellow cheddar cheese is made with the addition of annatto, which gives it a yellow color. It has a slightly different flavor profile than white cheddar cheese.

6. Artisanal Cheddar Cheese: Artisanal cheddar cheese is made in small batches using traditional methods. It's often more expensive than mass-produced cheddar cheese but has a unique flavor and texture.

7. Mass-Produced Cheddar Cheese: Mass-produced cheddar cheese is made in large quantities using modern methods. It's often less expensive than artisanal cheddar cheese but may not have the same depth of flavor.

8. Organic Cheddar Cheese: Organic cheddar cheese is made from milk produced without the use of antibiotics or hormones. It's often more expensive than non-organic cheddar cheese but may be a better choice for those concerned about the environment or animal welfare.

9. Grass-Fed Cheddar Cheese: Grass-fed cheddar cheese is made from milk produced by cows that have been fed a diet of grass rather than grain. It's often more expensive than non-grass-fed cheddar cheese but may have a richer flavor.

10. Pasteurized Cheddar Cheese: Pasteurized cheddar cheese has been heated to kill any harmful bacteria. It's often more widely available than unpasteurized cheddar cheese but may have a slightly different flavor.

11. Unpasteurized Cheddar Cheese: Unpasteurized cheddar cheese has not been heated to kill any harmful bacteria. It's often more difficult to find than pasteurized cheddar cheese but may have a more complex flavor profile.

Key Considerations

1. Flavor Profile: Consider the flavor profile you're looking for when choosing a cheddar cheese. Aged cheddar cheese has a sharper, more complex flavor, while mild cheddar cheese has a milder, creamier flavor.

2. Texture: Cheddar cheese can have a range of textures, from crumbly to smooth. Consider the texture you prefer when choosing a cheddar cheese.

3. Pairings: Think about what you'll be pairing the cheddar cheese with. Some cheddar cheeses are better for snacking, while others are better for cooking.

4. Storage: Consider how you'll be storing the cheddar cheese. Some cheddar cheeses need to be stored in the refrigerator, while others can be stored at room temperature.

Features

1. Flavor: Look for a cheddar cheese with a flavor profile that matches your preferences.

2. Texture: Look for a cheddar cheese with a texture that matches your preferences.

3. Pairings: Look for a cheddar cheese that pairs well with the foods you'll be eating it with.

4. Storage: Look for a cheddar cheese that can be stored in a way that's convenient for you.

Prices

The price of cheddar cheese can vary depending on the type and brand. Generally, artisanal and organic cheddar cheeses tend to be more expensive than mass-produced cheddar cheeses. Prices can range from a few dollars per pound to over $20 per pound for some artisanal varieties.

Tips

1. Try Before You Buy: If possible, try a small amount of the cheddar cheese before buying a large quantity.

2. Store Properly: Store cheddar cheese in the refrigerator or at room temperature as recommended on the packaging.

3. Pairing Suggestions: Experiment with different pairings to find the perfect match for your cheddar cheese.

FAQs

Q: How long does cheddar cheese last?

A: Cheddar cheese can last for several weeks in the refrigerator if stored properly.

Q: Can cheddar cheese be frozen?

A: Yes, cheddar cheese can be frozen, but it may affect the texture.

Q: Is cheddar cheese gluten-free?

A: Yes, cheddar cheese is typically gluten-free.

Q: Can cheddar cheese be used in cooking?

A: Yes, cheddar cheese is a popular ingredient in many dishes, including mac and cheese, grilled cheese sandwiches, and omelets.

Q: What are some popular brands of cheddar cheese?

A: Some popular brands of cheddar cheese include Cabot, Tillamook, and Kraft.

Q: What is the difference between white and yellow cheddar cheese?

A: White cheddar cheese is made without the addition of annatto, which gives it a natural white color. Yellow cheddar cheese is made with the addition of annatto, which gives it a yellow color. They have slightly different flavor profiles.

Q: What is the difference between mild and sharp cheddar cheese?

A: Mild cheddar cheese is aged for only a few months, giving it a milder, creamier flavor. Sharp cheddar cheese has been aged for 6 to 12 months, giving it a tangy, bold flavor.

Q: What is the best way to serve cheddar cheese?

A: Cheddar cheese can be served on its own as a snack or used as an ingredient in a variety of dishes. It pairs well with crackers, bread, and fruit.

Runner-Ups

Pros
  • Great flavor
  • Fresh
  • Great value for money
  • Comparable with other big brands
  • Reasonably priced
Cons
  • Moldy cheese
  • Inconsistent quality
Bottom Line
The 365 brand shredded cheese from Whole Foods/Amazon is a good value for money and comparable to other big brands. However, there have been some issues with moldy cheese and inconsistent quality.
Pros
  • Cheesy and does the job
  • Good for tacos and au gratin potatoes
  • Mild flavor
  • It's cheese and tastes like cheese
Cons
  • No flavor
  • Overpriced
Bottom Line
This cheese is a decent option for those looking for a mild, basic cheese for cooking or snacking. However, it may not be worth the higher price point compared to other options on the market. Buyers should also be aware of potential shipping and pricing issues.
Pros
  • Excellent sharp flavor
  • Tastes delicious
  • Best sliced cheese for sandwiches
  • Cheese has a snap and not a bend
Cons
  • Slices crumble easily
  • Poor quality control
Bottom Line
This sharp cheddar cheese has a great flavor and snap, but the slices tend to crumble easily and there have been issues with quality control and moldy packages.
Pros
  • Good taste
  • Bigger shreds for better flavor
  • Excellent taste and texture
  • Versatile for different dishes
  • It's cheese, so if you like cheese, you'll like this
Cons
  • Small size for the cost
  • Dryness and minimal fat content
Bottom Line
This cheese has good taste and texture, but it may be too dry and have a short shelf life. It's versatile for different dishes, but may not be worth the cost for the small size.
Pros
  • Good value for the price
  • Fresh and has a long expiration date
  • Easy to use and pack
  • Salty and tangy taste
  • Same day delivery
Cons
  • Not sharp enough for some customers
  • Rubber-like texture
Bottom Line
This cheese is a good value for the price and has a long expiration date. However, some customers find it not sharp enough and have issues with its texture and melting properties. The packaging can also be deceptive.
Please add more products to compare
You can compare up to four products at once
{{compareData.brand}}