10Best.Guide

Eye Makeup Remover

Top Picks

Last Updated: May, 2023
Pros
  • Effective in removing makeup, even waterproof mascara.
  • Soft and gentle on the skin.
  • Good for sensitive skin.
  • Resealable packaging keeps wipes from drying out.
  • Easy to use and store.
Cons
  • Chemicals in the wipes may cause a strong scent or burn the eyes.
  • Preservatives in the wipes may cause skin problems.
Bottom Line
Neutrogena makeup wipes are effective and gentle on the skin, making them a great choice for those with sensitive skin. However, some users may experience a strong scent or eye irritation due to the chemicals in the wipes, and the preservatives may cause skin problems.
Pros
  • Individually wrapped for convenience and travel
  • Great for sensitive skin
  • Pleasant scent
  • Effective at removing makeup and refreshing skin
  • Compact and easy to carry
Cons
  • Some find the scent overpowering
  • Packaging can be difficult to open
Bottom Line
Neutrogena Makeup Remover Cleansing Towelettes Singles are a great option for those who need a convenient and effective makeup remover on the go. They are gentle on sensitive skin and come in compact, individually wrapped packets. However, the scent may be too strong for some and the packaging can be challenging to open.
Pros
  • Works well with waterproof mascara and eyelash glue.
  • Leaves eyes feeling soft and makeup-free.
  • Cleans nicely and doesn't irritate or burn.
  • Can last a long time due to the bottle's design.
  • Makes eyelashes stronger and grow faster.
Cons
  • Advertised as oil-free when it's not.
  • False advertisement.
Bottom Line
Mary Kay Eye Makeup Remover is a high-quality product that effectively removes makeup without irritating or burning the eyes. It works well with waterproof mascara and eyelash glue and can last a long time due to the bottle's design. However, some customers have reported false advertisement and changes in the formula.
Pros
  • Effective in removing waterproof makeup
  • Gentle on sensitive skin and eyes
  • No strong smell
  • Doesn't leave eyes oily or glassy
  • Doesn't require pulling or tugging to remove makeup
Cons
  • Some received a separated and frothy product
  • Short half-life
Bottom Line
Lancome Bi-Facil Eye Makeup Remover is an effective and gentle product that removes waterproof makeup easily. However, some customers received a separated product and the bottle may tip over easily. It may not work as well as other makeup removers, but it is a good option for those with sensitive skin and eyes.
Pros
  • Easily removes lash glue and waterproof mascara.
  • Gentle and doesn't sting or burn.
  • Removes makeup in one or two swipes.
  • Removes makeup easily without intense rubbing or pain.
  • Great for sensitive skin.
Cons
  • Significant oil and water separation.
  • No seal on the bottle.
Bottom Line
Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover is a good option for removing makeup, especially for those with sensitive skin. It effectively removes makeup without causing any irritation or discomfort. However, it may not be the best option for removing waterproof mascara and may have a greasy feel and appearance.

The Ultimate Buying Guide for Eye Makeup Remover: Find the Best One for Your Needs

Overview

Eye makeup remover is an essential part of any beauty routine, as it helps to remove stubborn eye makeup without damaging the delicate skin around the eyes. With so many different types and brands of eye makeup remover available, it can be difficult to know which one is right for you. In this buying guide, we'll take a closer look at the different types of eye makeup remover, key considerations to keep in mind when choosing one, important features to look for, prices, tips, and FAQs to help you make an informed decision.

Types

1. Oil-based eye makeup remover: This type of eye makeup remover is great for removing waterproof or long-lasting eye makeup. It is gentle on the skin and helps to moisturize the eye area.

2. Water-based eye makeup remover: This type of eye makeup remover is ideal for removing light to medium eye makeup. It is gentle on the skin and doesn't leave any residue.

3. Micellar water eye makeup remover: This type of eye makeup remover is a gentle, water-based solution that contains tiny micelles that attract and remove dirt, oil, and makeup from the skin.

4. Bi-phase eye makeup remover: This type of eye makeup remover is a two-part solution that contains both oil and water. When shaken, the two parts mix together to create a powerful makeup remover that is gentle on the skin.

5. Cream eye makeup remover: This type of eye makeup remover is a thick, creamy formula that is ideal for removing heavy eye makeup. It is gentle on the skin and helps to moisturize the eye area.

6. Gel eye makeup remover: This type of eye makeup remover is a lightweight, gel-like formula that is ideal for removing light to medium eye makeup. It is gentle on the skin and doesn't leave any residue.

Key Considerations

1. Skin type: Consider your skin type when choosing an eye makeup remover. If you have sensitive skin, look for a gentle formula that won't irritate your skin.

2. Type of makeup: Consider the type of makeup you wear when choosing an eye makeup remover. If you wear waterproof or long-lasting makeup, look for an oil-based or bi-phase formula.

3. Ingredients: Look for eye makeup removers that contain natural or gentle ingredients, such as chamomile, aloe vera, or cucumber extract.

4. Brand reputation: Choose a reputable brand that has a good track record for producing high-quality eye makeup removers.

Features

1. Gentle formula: Look for an eye makeup remover that is gentle on the skin and won't cause irritation.

2. Moisturizing: Look for an eye makeup remover that contains moisturizing ingredients to help hydrate the eye area.

3. Non-comedogenic: Look for an eye makeup remover that is non-comedogenic, meaning it won't clog pores.

4. Vegan and cruelty-free: Look for eye makeup removers that are vegan and cruelty-free if you prefer to use products that are ethically and environmentally conscious.

Prices

Eye makeup removers can range in price from around $5 to $50, depending on the brand, type, and size of the product. Drugstore brands tend to be more affordable, while high-end brands can be more expensive.

Tips

1. Use a cotton pad: Apply eye makeup remover to a cotton pad and gently wipe it over your closed eyes to remove makeup.

2. Be gentle: Avoid rubbing or tugging at the delicate skin around your eyes, as this can cause irritation and damage.

3. Follow up with a cleanser: After using an eye makeup remover, follow up with a gentle cleanser to remove any remaining makeup or residue.

4. Store properly: Store your eye makeup remover in a cool, dry place to prevent it from spoiling or becoming contaminated.

FAQs

Q: How do I choose the right eye makeup remover for me?

A: Consider your skin type, the type of makeup you wear, the ingredients, and the reputation of the brand when choosing an eye makeup remover.

Q: Can I use regular makeup remover on my eyes?

A: No, regular makeup remover is not designed for use on the delicate skin around the eyes. Use a dedicated eye makeup remover instead.

Q: How do I use eye makeup remover?

A: Apply eye makeup remover to a cotton pad and gently wipe it over your closed eyes to remove makeup.

Q: Can eye makeup remover cause irritation?

A: Yes, eye makeup remover can cause irritation if it contains harsh ingredients or if you rub or tug at your eyes too hard.

Q: How often should I use eye makeup remover?

A: Use eye makeup remover as often as needed to remove your eye makeup.

Runner-Ups

Pros
  • Gentle on skin and eyes
  • Removes makeup well, even waterproof
  • Good for sensitive eyes
  • Works quickly
  • Sustainable replacement for makeup wipes
Cons
  • Leaves an oily film on the face
  • May cause itching and dryness
Bottom Line
Neutrogena Oil-Free Liquid Eye Makeup Remover is a good option for those with sensitive eyes and a tight budget. It removes makeup well, but may leave an oily residue and cause itching or dryness. The packaging quality could be improved.
Pros
  • Effective in removing waterproof makeup
  • Good for sensitive skin
  • Moisturizing
  • Removes makeup without scrubbing hard
  • Good for removing tough makeup
Cons
  • Leaves an oily residue
  • Pads are small and thin
Bottom Line
Almay Eye Makeup Remover Pads are effective in removing waterproof and long-wear makeup, but may leave an oily residue and irritate eyes. They are good for sensitive skin and moisturizing, but the pads are small and thin, and may require more effort to remove waterproof mascara.
Pros
  • Effective at removing waterproof makeup
  • Cruelty-free
  • Affordable
  • Gentle on sensitive skin
  • Removes eye makeup and foundation easily
Cons
  • May not work as well as high-end brands
  • Not a quick one-swipe remover
Bottom Line
Solimo Eye Makeup Remover is an affordable and effective option for removing waterproof makeup and is gentle on sensitive skin. However, it may not work as well as high-end brands and may require multiple swipes to fully remove makeup.
Pros
  • Effective at removing eye makeup
  • Does not irritate eyes
  • Great for waterproof mascara
  • Easy to use
  • Affordable price
Cons
  • Leaves an oily residue
  • Not effective for heavy makeup
Bottom Line
This eye makeup remover is effective and affordable, but may leave an oily residue and require more product than other removers. It is best for those with minimal eye makeup.
Pros
  • Removes waterproof mascara quickly and easily.
  • No burning or irritation.
  • Removes eye makeup completely in one or two swipes.
  • Gentle on skin.
  • Non-oily.
Cons
  • Dries out skin.
  • Small pads.
Bottom Line
These makeup remover pads are effective in removing eye makeup quickly and easily, without causing burning or irritation. However, they may dry out skin and leave a slight oily residue. The pads are small and thin, so multiple pads may be needed to remove all makeup.
Please add more products to compare
You can compare up to four products at once
{{compareData.brand}}