10Best.Guide

Eye Shadow

Top Picks

Last Updated: April, 2023
Pros
  • Beautiful colors
  • Variety of shades
  • Pigmented
  • Long-lasting
  • Minimal fallout
Cons
  • Not as pigmented as high-end brands
  • Doesn't blend as well as high-end brands
Bottom Line
This eyeshadow palette offers a variety of beautiful, pigmented shades at an affordable price. While it may not be as high-quality as some high-end brands, it is a good value for those looking to experiment with color. The opalized shimmer effect makes it wearable for all ages. However, be aware that the packaging may be damaged during shipping.
Pros
  • Long-lasting
  • Easy to apply
  • Vibrant pigment
  • No creasing
  • Butter soft and creamy texture
Cons
  • Not as pigmented as advertised
  • Metallic finish may not be suitable for all ages
Bottom Line
Julep crème to powder waterproof eyeshadow stick is a long-lasting, easy-to-apply, and vibrant pigment eyeshadow that does not crease or smudge once set. However, it may not be as pigmented as advertised, and the metallic finish may not be suitable for all ages.
Pros
  • Nice range of shades
  • Affordable
  • Good for everyday wear
  • Can be used for filling in brows
  • Can be used for all seasons
Cons
  • Some colors are sheer
  • Some colors are not as pigmented as others
Bottom Line
The Maybelline New York Nudes Eyeshadow Palette is an affordable option for those who prefer nude and earthy tones. The eyeshadows are pigmented, but some colors may require a primer or water to get the desired color transfer. The palette has a nice mix of shiny and matte shades and can be used for filling in brows. However, some colors are sheer, not as pigmented as others, and may not show up on tan or dark skin tones. The eyeshadows have a powdery texture and may not last all day.
Pros
  • Beautiful color scheme
  • Great value for the price
  • Matte shades are smooth and long-lasting
  • Good pigmentation with one swatch
  • Can create beautiful looks
Cons
  • Lighter colors have poor color payoff
  • Some shades have too much shimmer
Bottom Line
This Wet n Wild eyeshadow palette is a great value for the price, with a beautiful color scheme and long-lasting matte shades. However, some shades have poor color payoff and too much shimmer, and there is no light silver color for highlight.
Pros
  • Wide variety of colors
  • Good value for the price
  • Solid colors work well and stay on
  • Beautiful presentation
  • Talc-free
Cons
  • Colors not as vibrant as shown online
  • Some colors are more sheer than others
Bottom Line
This palette offers a wide variety of colors at a good value, but some colors may not be as vibrant as shown and there may be some issues with blending and fallout. The presentation is beautiful and the palette is talc-free.

The Ultimate Buying Guide for Eye Shadow: Tips, Types, Features & More

Overview

Eye shadow is an essential part of any makeup look, whether you're going for a natural daytime look or a bold and dramatic nighttime look. With so many different types, colors, and finishes available, it can be overwhelming to choose the right one. That's why we've put together this comprehensive buying guide to help you find the perfect eye shadow for your needs.

Types

1. Matte Eye Shadow: Matte eye shadows have a flat finish and are great for creating a natural look. They are perfect for daytime wear and for creating a subtle smoky eye.

2. Shimmer Eye Shadow: Shimmer eye shadows have a sparkly finish and are perfect for creating a glamorous look. They are great for nighttime wear and for adding a pop of color to your eyes.

3. Cream Eye Shadow: Cream eye shadows have a creamy texture and are easy to apply. They are perfect for creating a bold and dramatic look and are great for people with dry skin.

4. Powder Eye Shadow: Powder eye shadows have a lightweight texture and are easy to blend. They are perfect for people with oily skin and for creating a smoky eye.

Key Considerations

1. Skin Tone: When choosing an eye shadow, it's important to consider your skin tone. If you have cool undertones, choose shades with blue or purple undertones. If you have warm undertones, choose shades with orange or yellow undertones.

2. Occasion: Consider the occasion when choosing an eye shadow. For daytime wear, choose a natural or neutral shade. For nighttime wear, choose a bold or dramatic shade.

3. Application: Consider the application method when choosing an eye shadow. Cream and liquid eye shadows are best applied with a brush or your fingers, while powder eye shadows are best applied with a brush.

Features

1. Long-lasting: Look for eye shadows that are long-lasting and won't fade or crease throughout the day.

2. Blendable: Look for eye shadows that are easy to blend and create a seamless look.

3. Color Selection: Look for eye shadows with a wide range of colors to choose from, so you can find the perfect shade for your needs.

Prices

Eye shadow prices can vary greatly depending on the brand, type, and quality. Drugstore eye shadows can range from $5 to $15, while high-end eye shadows can range from $20 to $50 or more.

Tips

1. Use a primer: To make your eye shadow last longer and prevent creasing, use an eye shadow primer before applying your eye shadow.

2. Use the right brush: Use a flat brush to apply your eye shadow and a fluffy brush to blend it out.

3. Experiment with different colors: Don't be afraid to try new colors and experiment with different shades to find the perfect look for you.

FAQs

Q: What is the best type of eye shadow for oily skin?

A: Powder eye shadows are best for people with oily skin, as they have a lightweight texture and are less likely to crease.

Q: How do I choose the right shade of eye shadow for my skin tone?

A: If you have cool undertones, choose shades with blue or purple undertones. If you have warm undertones, choose shades with orange or yellow undertones.

Q: How do I apply cream eye shadow?

A: Cream eye shadows are best applied with a brush or your fingers. Use a small amount and blend it out for a seamless look.

Runner-Ups

Pros
  • Good for beginners
  • Affordable
  • Great color range
  • Shimmer pigments are gorgeous
  • Variety of colors
Cons
  • Smaller than anticipated
  • Knock off brand
Bottom Line
This affordable makeup palette is great for beginners and offers a variety of colors, including gorgeous shimmer pigments. However, it may require a little bit of skill to use, and some colors may arrive broken.
Pros
  • Nice natural colors with shine
  • Complimentary colors that are not bold
  • Affordable price
  • Nice and vibrant colors
  • Long-wearing and stays on
Cons
  • Not highly pigmented for long wear
  • Feels dry and dusty, doesn't blend well
Bottom Line
This eyeshadow palette is a great value for the price, with a variety of natural colors that have a nice shine and are easy to apply. While it may not be highly pigmented for long wear, it is still a good option for those looking for an affordable and versatile eyeshadow palette.
Pros
  • Beautiful selection of nude/neutral shadows
  • Versatile enough to accomplish either a natural or dramatic look
  • Long-lasting
  • Great for seniors or those who prefer subtle makeup
  • Affordable
Cons
  • Some shades may be dry and crumbly
  • Some shades may arrive broken
Bottom Line
This nude L.A. Girl palette is a great affordable option for those looking for a versatile selection of nude/neutral shadows. While some shades may be dry or arrive broken, the palette is long-lasting and great for seniors or those who prefer subtle makeup. However, it may not be highly pigmented or blendable, and some shades may not match well together.
Pros
  • Portable size
  • Nice colors
  • Generous amounts of product
  • Good for traveling
  • Affordable price
Cons
  • Not as pigmented as claimed
  • Takes a lot to get the color to show up
Bottom Line
This palette is a good option for those who want a portable and affordable eyeshadow palette with beautiful colors and good pigmentation. However, it may take some effort to get the color to show up and there is a risk of it arriving damaged.
Pros
  • Good color selection
  • Lasts a decently long time
  • Flatters the eye with a bit of shimmer
  • Neutral colors
  • Good value
Cons
  • Colors received were not as represented
  • Random shade received
Bottom Line
Covergirl eyeshadows offer a good color selection, decent longevity, and a bit of shimmer. However, be aware that the colors received may not match the representation, and some shades may have too much shimmer or not be as dark as expected. Overall, a good value for the price.
Please add more products to compare
You can compare up to four products at once
{{compareData.brand}}