10Best.Guide

Eye Shadow Cream

Top Picks

Last Updated: September, 2023
Pros
  • Laura Mercier shadow stick dupe
  • Easy to use
  • Long-wearing
  • Well-pigmented
  • Quick and mess-free application
Cons
  • Some colors are impractical for everyday use
  • Some shades don't show up well
Bottom Line
The ELF No-Budge Shadow Sticks are a great value for the price, with well-pigmented and long-wearing colors that are easy to use and perfect for quick and mess-free application. However, some colors are impractical for everyday use and the pigment may not be as deep as advertised.
Pros
  • Easy to apply and blend
  • Long-lasting
  • Suitable for every skin tone
  • Great texture
  • Smooth application
Cons
  • Not pigmented enough
  • Irritates some eyes
Bottom Line
This eyeshadow is easy to apply, blend, and has a great texture. It is long-lasting and suitable for every skin tone. However, it can be pricey and some colors are not pigmented enough. The packaging is not color-coded, making it difficult to differentiate between shades.
Pros
  • Texture is amazing and easy to apply
  • Great alternative to more expensive brands
  • Super easy to apply and blend
  • Waterproof and stays on all day
  • Glides on smoothly and quickly
Cons
  • Product is only half the container size
  • Slightly sheer and creases on some eyelids
Bottom Line
This eyeshadow stick is a great alternative to more expensive brands and is easy to apply and blend. It is waterproof and stays on all day, but may be slightly sheer and not as shimmery as some users may expect. The product is also inconsistent in color quality control and may be too shimmery for some users.
Pros
  • Easy to use
  • Customizable color boldness
  • Glides on eyelid nicely
  • Silky and pretty
  • Comes with a brush for blending
Cons
  • Sheer colors
  • Smudges easily
Bottom Line
These eyeshadow sticks are easy to use and come in a variety of colors, but they have some issues with sheerness, smudging, and uneven product distribution. They are a good option for those who want a quick and easy makeup routine, but may not be the best choice for those who want more control over their eyeshadow application or need long-lasting wear.
Pros
  • Lovely shimmer
  • Great for hooded eyes
  • Beautiful colors
  • Long-lasting
  • Subtle smoky eye
Cons
  • Difficult to open
  • Large sparkles
Bottom Line
Revlon ColorStay Creme Eye Shadow has beautiful colors, lovely shimmer, and is long-lasting. However, it can be difficult to open, has large sparkles, and some shades have little pigmentation. It is a great option for those who want a subtle smoky eye and easy application.

The Ultimate Buying Guide for Eye Shadow Cream: Reviews, Tips, and More

Overview

Eye shadow cream is a versatile and easy-to-use makeup product that can add depth, dimension, and drama to your eye makeup look. Unlike traditional powder eye shadow, cream formulas are creamy, blendable, and offer a wide range of finishes, from matte to metallic to shimmery. With so many options on the market, it can be tough to choose the right eye shadow cream for your needs. That's where our buying guide comes in. We've researched and reviewed the best eye shadow creams available, and we're sharing our top picks, along with tips and tricks to help you get the most out of your purchase.

Types

- Cream eye shadow: This is the most basic type of eye shadow cream, and it comes in a pot or tube. It's easy to apply with your fingers, a brush, or a sponge, and it can be layered for a more intense look.

- Cream-to-powder eye shadow: This type of eye shadow cream has a unique texture that starts as a cream and dries down to a powder finish. It's ideal for those who want the blendability of a cream shadow but the staying power of a powder.

- Cream eye shadow stick: These are twist-up sticks that apply the cream shadow directly to your eyelids. They're convenient and easy to use, making them a great option for on-the-go touch-ups.

Key Considerations

- Finish: Eye shadow cream comes in a variety of finishes, including matte, metallic, and shimmery. Consider your personal style and the occasion when choosing a finish.

- Longevity: Look for eye shadow cream that is long-lasting and won't crease or fade throughout the day.

- Skin type: If you have oily eyelids, choose a waterproof or smudge-proof formula to prevent transfer. If you have sensitive skin or eyes, look for eye shadow cream that is hypoallergenic and fragrance-free.

Features

- Pigmentation: The best eye shadow cream should be highly pigmented and offer buildable coverage.

- Blendability: Cream eye shadow should be easy to blend and layer for a seamless look.

- Packaging: Look for eye shadow cream that comes in a hygienic and convenient package, such as a pot with a screw-on lid or a twist-up stick.

Prices

Eye shadow cream prices can vary depending on the brand and quality. Drugstore options can range from $5 to $15, while high-end options can cost $20 to $40 or more.

Tips

- Use a primer: To ensure your eye shadow cream stays put all day, apply a primer to your eyelids before applying the cream.

- Layer shades: To create a multidimensional eye look, layer different shades of eye shadow cream on top of each other.

- Use your fingers: For a more intense look, use your fingers to apply the eye shadow cream. The warmth of your fingers will help the cream blend seamlessly.

FAQs

Q: How do I apply eye shadow cream?

A: There are several ways to apply eye shadow cream, including using your fingers, a brush, or a sponge. Choose the method that works best for you.

Q: Can I wear eye shadow cream without primer?

A: While you can wear eye shadow cream without primer, using a primer will ensure the cream stays put all day and prevents creasing.

Q: Can eye shadow cream be used as eyeliner?

A: Yes, you can use a small brush to apply eye shadow cream as eyeliner for a softer, smudged look.

Q: How do I remove eye shadow cream?

A: Use a gentle eye makeup remover or micellar water to remove eye shadow cream.

Runner-Ups

Pros
  • Beautiful colors
  • Easy to apply
  • Long-lasting
  • Great quality
  • Chic packaging
Cons
  • Expensive
  • Color fades throughout the day
Bottom Line
Lady Gaga's liquid eyeshadows are easy to apply, long-lasting, and come in beautiful colors. However, they can be expensive and some colors may fade throughout the day. The product is great quality and can be used as a multitasker, but some users may find the consistency thin and the scent unpleasant.
Pros
  • Easy to use and apply
  • Natural or bold depending on application
  • Comes with a blending brush
  • Good for sensitive skin
  • Creamy and pigmented
Cons
  • Colors are darker in person
  • Doesn't last very long
Bottom Line
These eyeshadow sticks are easy to use and blend, with a good range of natural or bold colors. However, they may not last very long and can smudge easily. They are a good option for those with sensitive skin, but may take up a lot of space in a makeup bag.
Pros
  • Beautiful colors that last all day
  • Smooth texture that goes on easily
  • Includes an applicator brush
  • Great for hooded eyes
  • Subtle smoky eye look
Cons
  • Difficult to open
  • Feels sticky/tacky
Bottom Line
Revlon ColorStay Creme Eye Shadow has a smooth texture, beautiful colors, and long-lasting wear. However, it can be difficult to open and has some packaging and pigmentation issues. Overall, it is a decent product that is worth trying.
Pros
  • 1) Nice shimmer and subtle sparkle
  • 2) Easy to apply and blend
  • 3) Long-lasting
  • 4) Comes in pretty colors
  • 5) Can be used as an everyday eyeshadow
Cons
  • 1) Creases easily
  • 2) Difficult to apply an even layer with the wand
Bottom Line
This eyeshadow is a good option for those who want a subtle, shimmery look that is easy to apply and long-lasting. However, it may crease easily and the colors may not match the description. Buyers should be aware that the product cannot be returned.
Pros
  • Colors are pretty and work well for a natural look
  • Creamy and easy to apply with fingers
  • Great for beginners and travel
  • Glitters stick to the eyeshadow
  • Perfect for a wet, glamour, simple yet sexy look
Cons
  • Difficult to use without an applicator
  • Not a lot of pigmentation
Bottom Line
This Revlon cream eyeshadow palette is great for beginners and those looking for a natural, simple look. The colors are pretty and the formula is creamy and easy to apply with fingers. However, it may not have a lot of pigmentation and doesn't stay on long. It's also small in size and doesn't have a lot of product.
Please add more products to compare
You can compare up to four products at once
{{compareData.brand}}