10Best.Guide

Eyebrow Mascara

Top Picks

Last Updated: June, 2023
Pros
  • Perfect shade for light eyebrows
  • Easy to apply
  • Lasts as long as more expensive pencils
  • Fills in and extends without looking fake
  • Good quality low priced product
Cons
  • Arrives in brittle condition when bought through Amazon
  • Used up quickly
Bottom Line
This e.l.f. Instant Lift Brow Pencil is a great low-priced option for those with light eyebrows. It is easy to apply, lasts long, and fills in without looking fake. However, buyers should be aware of the potential issues with buying through Amazon and the quick usage of the product.
Pros
  • Good dupe for high-end mascaras.
  • Adds volume without being clumpy.
  • Smudge-proof and long-lasting.
  • Creates noticeable length and thickness.
  • Easy to layer.
Cons
  • Some tubes run out quickly.
  • Formula can be clumpy.
Bottom Line
This mascara is a great dupe for high-end mascaras, adding volume and noticeable length and thickness without being clumpy. It is smudge-proof and long-lasting, but some tubes may run out quickly and the formula can be difficult to remove.
Pros
  • Perfect shade for auburn hair
  • Soft texture
  • Easy to use
  • Long-lasting
  • Comes with a spoolie brush
Cons
  • Too much packaging
  • No way to tell when pencil is running out
Bottom Line
Revlon Brow Fantasy Pencil and Gel is an affordable and easy-to-use product that comes with a spoolie brush and is good for filling in sparse areas. However, it can be patchy if filling in too much and runs out quickly. The packaging is also excessive and there is no way to tell when the pencil is running out.
Pros
  • Stays on all day
  • Smooth and easy to apply
  • Perfect shape
  • Great color options
  • Affordable price
Cons
  • Greasy and difficult to apply
  • Hard to remove cap
Bottom Line
This eyebrow pencil is a great affordable option with a smooth application and long-lasting wear. However, it may not be suitable for those looking for a thin, hair-like line or a natural color for their eyebrows.
Pros
  • Easy to apply and build
  • Stays in place all day
  • Fills in thin areas without looking wet or shiny
  • Matches hair color well
  • Comes in different shades
Cons
  • May be darker than expected
  • Smudges easily
Bottom Line
Maybelline Eyebrow Pomade is a good value for the money and comes in different shades to match hair color. It is easy to apply and build, stays in place all day, and fills in thin areas without looking wet or shiny. However, it may be darker than expected, smudges easily, and may not work for those with very sparse brows or oily skin.

The Ultimate Buying Guide for Eyebrow Mascara: Types, Key Considerations, Features, Prices, Tips, and FAQs

Overview

Eyebrow mascara is a versatile and easy-to-use product that can help you achieve natural-looking, defined, and fuller brows. Whether you have sparse, unruly, or thin brows, eyebrow mascara can help you shape, tint, and hold your brows in place. In this buying guide, we'll cover the different types of eyebrow mascara, key considerations when choosing one, essential features to look for, prices, tips on how to use it, and frequently asked questions.

Types

1. Clear brow mascara: This type of brow mascara is ideal for those who want to tame unruly brows without adding any color or tint. It can help you hold your brows in place and add a subtle shine.

2. Tinted brow mascara: If you want to add some color and definition to your brows, tinted brow mascara is a great option. It comes in various shades, from blonde to black, and can help you fill in sparse areas and create a more polished look.

3. Colored brow mascara: Colored brow mascara is similar to tinted brow mascara, but it has a more intense color payoff. It can help you create bold and dramatic brows, especially if you have naturally light or sparse brows.

Key Considerations

1. Shade: Choosing the right shade of brow mascara is crucial for achieving a natural-looking result. If you have blonde or light brown hair, go for a shade that matches your hair color. If you have dark hair, you can choose a shade that is one or two shades lighter than your hair color.

2. Formula: Look for a formula that is long-lasting, smudge-proof, and waterproof, especially if you have oily skin or live in a humid climate. You may also want to choose a formula that is enriched with nourishing ingredients, such as vitamins and minerals, to promote healthy and strong brows.

3. Applicator: The applicator can make a big difference in how easy and precise it is to apply the brow mascara. Look for an applicator that is small, tapered, and easy to control, especially if you have thin or sparse brows.

Features

1. Hold: The hold of the brow mascara refers to how well it can keep your brows in place. Look for a product that has a strong hold but doesn't feel too stiff or crunchy.

2. Pigmentation: The pigmentation of the brow mascara refers to how much color it adds to your brows. Choose a product that has a natural-looking and buildable pigmentation, so you can control the intensity of the color.

3. Texture: The texture of the brow mascara refers to how it feels on your brows. Look for a product that has a lightweight and non-greasy texture, so it doesn't weigh down your brows or make them look oily.

Prices

The price of eyebrow mascara can vary depending on the brand, formula, and features. You can find affordable options for as low as $5, while high-end brands can cost up to $50. However, you don't necessarily need to spend a lot of money to get a good quality brow mascara. Look for products that have a good balance between price and performance.

Tips

1. Brush your brows upward before applying the brow mascara to create a fuller and more natural look.

2. Start with a light hand and build up the color and hold gradually, so you don't end up with overly dark or stiff brows.

3. Use a spoolie brush or a clean mascara wand to comb through your brows after applying the brow mascara to remove any clumps or excess product.

FAQs

Q: Is eyebrow mascara better than eyebrow pencil or powder?

A: It depends on your preference and the look you want to achieve. Eyebrow mascara is ideal for those who want a quick and easy way to shape and tint their brows, while eyebrow pencil or powder can give you a more precise and defined result.

Q: Can I use eyebrow mascara on my eyelashes?

A: It's not recommended to use eyebrow mascara on your eyelashes, as it's formulated specifically for the brow hairs and may cause irritation or clumping on the delicate eyelashes.

Q: How long does eyebrow mascara last?

A: The longevity of eyebrow mascara can vary depending on the formula, but most products can last up to 12 hours or more, especially if they are smudge-proof and waterproof.

Q: How do I remove eyebrow mascara?

A: You can remove eyebrow mascara with a gentle makeup remover or micellar water, using a cotton pad or a soft cloth. Avoid rubbing or pulling your brows, as it can cause damage or breakage.

Runner-Ups

Pros
  • Separates lashes well
  • Waterproof and smudge-proof
  • Goes on smoothly and doesn't clump
  • Provides volume and length
  • Makes lashes appear thicker and longer
Cons
  • Not completely smudge-proof
  • May dry out quickly
Bottom Line
L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Original Washable Bold Eye Volume Building Mascara is a reasonably priced product that separates lashes well, provides volume and length, and is easy to use and remove. However, it may not be completely smudge-proof and may dry out quickly.
Pros
  • Best overall eyebrow product
  • Covers gray brows and fills in quickly and easily
  • Looks natural and lasts till you take it off
  • Believable blonde color
  • Lower price on Amazon than at Target or drug stores
Cons
  • Wand breaks off easily
  • Dries out quickly
Bottom Line
This eyebrow product is the best overall and covers gray brows while filling in quickly and easily. It looks natural and lasts until you take it off. The blonde color is believable and the price on Amazon is lower than at Target or drug stores. However, the wand breaks off easily and the product dries out quickly. It can smear after applying and the chocolate color is not as dark as it sounds.
Pros
  • Hairline precision
  • Great value
  • Glides on smooth
  • Perfect for shaping and filling in eyebrows
  • Affordable alternative to high-end pencils
Cons
  • Runs out quickly
  • Color is darker than expected
Bottom Line
The Wet n Wild Ultimate Brow Micro Eyebrow Retractable Pencil is an affordable option for those looking for hairline precision and a slim tip for precise application. It may not last as long as other pencils and the color may be darker than expected, but it is a good alternative to high-end pencils. However, the color may not work for those with light/medium brown hair.
Pros
  • Perfect color for dark brown hair
  • Defines eyebrows well
  • Easy to use
  • Fills in thinning eyebrows
  • Can be used as eyeliner
Cons
  • Doesn't last very long
  • Pencil tip falls off while sharpening
Bottom Line
This eyebrow pencil is perfect for those with sparse or thinning eyebrows. It defines and fills in eyebrows well, giving a natural look. However, it doesn't last very long and the gel can leave a sticky residue. The blonde color is also too yellow for some users.
Pros
  • Covers gray eyebrows
  • Long-lasting
  • Natural-looking
  • Good for thin and patchy eyebrows
  • Easy to use
Cons
  • Messy application
  • Clumps when applying
Bottom Line
This eyebrow gel is a good option for those with gray, thin, or pale eyebrows. It is easy to use and affordable, but can have a messy or clumpy application. It is important to wipe off excess gel and use a light touch.
Please add more products to compare
You can compare up to four products at once
{{compareData.brand}}