10Best.Guide

Eyebrow Pencil

Top Picks

Last Updated: April, 2023
Pros
  • Perfect pencil diameter for drawing thinner or thicker lines.
  • Formula is blendable with the spoolie.
  • Creates a defined looking brow without any effort.
  • Shade matches perfectly with natural color and blends in seamlessly.
  • More product and better value than other brands.
Cons
  • Pencil falls out or breaks off easily.
  • Less potent (opaque) than before.
Bottom Line
Anastasia Brow Wiz is a great eyebrow pencil that is easy to use and creates a defined, natural-looking brow. However, it may have some issues with durability and opacity, and users should be aware that it may require some effort to apply.
Pros
  • Color matches well with eyebrows
  • Easy to apply
  • Long-lasting
  • Customizable color
  • Great for filling in and shaping brows
Cons
  • Pencil may fall apart
  • Inconsistent quality
Bottom Line
IT Cosmetics Brow Power Universal Eyebrow Pencil is a long-lasting and easy-to-apply product that matches well with eyebrows. However, some customers have reported issues with the pencil falling apart or receiving faulty products. It may not be universal for all hair colors and may be too dark for some.
Pros
  • Perfect color for light blonde hair and light eyebrows
  • Easy to apply and lasts long
  • Natural looking and versatile
  • Matches blonde color well
  • Retractable and smoother application
Cons
  • Product arrived broken
  • Brittle condition when purchased through Amazon
Bottom Line
The e.l.f. Instant Lift Brow Pencil is a great choice for those with light blonde hair and light eyebrows. It is easy to apply, lasts long, and has a natural look. However, customers should be cautious when purchasing through Amazon as the product may arrive in brittle condition or broken. Overall, it is a good quality, low-priced product that is worth the investment.
Pros
  • Fine and precise lines
  • Easy to use and blends beautifully
  • Good for natural-looking eyebrows
  • No need for sharpening
  • Good color match for blondes
Cons
  • Overpriced
  • May break easily
Bottom Line
The Benefit Cosmetics Precisely My Brow Pencil is a great option for those looking for a fine and precise eyebrow pencil that creates natural-looking brows. However, it may be overpriced and may break easily. It is recommended to purchase from reputable sellers like Ulta or Sephora.
Pros
  • True gray color
  • Affordable price point
  • Fine point and brush make it easy to apply
  • Great selection of colors
  • Lasts long and doesn't smudge easily
Cons
  • Chocolate color is not the same as Anastasia Beverly Hills version
  • Product looked old and did not apply well
Bottom Line
This brow pencil is a great affordable option with a true gray color and fine point for easy application. However, some colors may not match up to other high-end brands and the product may not last all day. Be careful with the pencil as it may break easily.

The Ultimate Buying Guide for Eyebrow Pencil

Overview

Eyebrow pencils are a must-have in every makeup kit. They help fill in sparse brows, define the shape of your eyebrows, and give your face a polished look. But with so many options on the market, it can be overwhelming to choose the right one. This buying guide will help you navigate the world of eyebrow pencils and find the perfect one for you.

Types

1. Traditional Pencil: These are the most common type of eyebrow pencils. They come in a variety of shades and are easy to use. They are ideal for filling in sparse areas and defining the shape of your brows.

2. Mechanical Pencil: These pencils have a retractable tip that eliminates the need for sharpening. They are great for precision work and creating fine lines.

3. Powder Pencil: These pencils have a powder-like texture that fills in brows naturally. They are ideal for those with oily skin or those who prefer a more natural look.

4. Gel Pencil: These pencils have a gel-like texture that helps keep brows in place. They are ideal for those with unruly brows or those who want a more dramatic look.

Key Considerations

1. Shade: Choose a shade that matches your natural brow color or is one shade lighter. Avoid going too dark, as it can look unnatural.

2. Formula: Consider your skin type and preferences when choosing a formula. If you have oily skin, a powder pencil may be best. If you prefer a more dramatic look, a gel pencil may be the way to go.

3. Longevity: Look for a pencil that will last all day without smudging or fading.

Features

1. Waterproof: A waterproof eyebrow pencil is ideal for those who live in humid climates or have oily skin.

2. Dual-ended: A dual-ended pencil with a spoolie brush on one end is perfect for blending and shaping.

3. Twist-up: A twist-up pencil eliminates the need for sharpening and is great for on-the-go touch-ups.

Prices

Eyebrow pencils can range in price from $5 to $50. The price will depend on the brand, formula, and features.

Tips

1. Use short, feathery strokes to mimic the look of natural brow hairs.

2. Start filling in your brows at the arch and work your way out.

3. Use a spoolie brush to blend the product and create a natural look.

FAQs

Q: How do I choose the right shade?

A: Choose a shade that matches your natural brow color or is one shade lighter.

Q: How do I make my brows look natural?

A: Use short, feathery strokes and a spoolie brush to blend the product.

Q: How long will my eyebrow pencil last?

A: The longevity will depend on the formula and brand. Look for a pencil that is long-lasting and smudge-proof.

Runner-Ups

Pros
  • Easy to use
  • Precise tip
  • Affordable
  • Natural-looking color
  • Smooth application
Cons
  • Smudges easily
  • Light color pigmentation
Bottom Line
Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil is an affordable and easy-to-use product that provides a natural-looking color. However, it smudges easily and is not waterproof, so it may not be the best option for those who need long-lasting wear.
Pros
  • Easy to apply
  • Ultra-thin pencil for precise lines
  • Good for beginners
  • Lasts a long time
  • Good color options for blondes
Cons
  • Smudges easily
  • Not good for filling in large areas
Bottom Line
This ultra-thin eyebrow pencil is great for beginners and those looking for precise lines. However, it may smudge easily and not be the best for filling in large areas. The color options are good for blondes, but the color may not match expectations.
Pros
  • Easy to use
  • Affordable
  • Precise application
  • Good for mimicking tiny hairs
  • Stays on until washed off
Cons
  • Little product in pencil
  • Harsh on its own
Bottom Line
This NYX brow pencil is an affordable and precise option for those looking to fill in their brows, but it may not have the best staying power and the colors may not be the most natural-looking.
Pros
  • Precise, angled tip
  • Affordable price
  • Good color selection
  • Long-lasting
  • Smooth application
Cons
  • Red undertones in dark brown color
  • Greasy texture
Bottom Line
Wet n Wild Ultimate Eyebrow Retractable Definer is an affordable and long-lasting eyebrow pencil with a precise tip and good color selection. However, it may have some texture issues and the pencil can be fragile.
Pros
  • Natural looking
  • Precise application
  • Affordable
  • Lasts longer than most
  • Creates hair-like strokes
Cons
  • Color may be too dark
  • Can appear bold and cakey
Bottom Line
NYX Micro Brow Pencil is an affordable and precise option for creating natural-looking eyebrows, but may have some issues with color and longevity. It is a good alternative to more expensive brands, but may not be the best option for everyone.
Please add more products to compare
You can compare up to four products at once
{{compareData.brand}}