10Best.Guide

Fireplace Mantel

Top Picks

Last Updated: November, 2023
Pros
  • Heavy and high-quality brackets
  • Well-made and great design
  • Easy access to screw holes
  • Impressive quality
  • Perfect for projects
Cons
  • Inconsistent delivery of pairs
  • Lack of extra screws and screw covers
Bottom Line
These heavy-duty brackets are well-made and of great quality, making them perfect for various projects. However, there have been some issues with inconsistent delivery and the lack of extra screws and screw covers. Overall, they are a reliable choice for those in need of sturdy brackets.
Pros
  • Very sturdy and well constructed
  • Easy installation on drywall
  • Nice finish and good looking mantle
  • Affordable compared to other options
  • Rustic look and beautiful design
Cons
  • Difficult to install on masonry
  • Wood takes stain differently in some areas
Bottom Line
This mantle is a sturdy and well-constructed option that adds a beautiful rustic look to any fireplace. It is easy to install on drywall, but may require more effort on masonry. The finish and design are nice, although there may be some inconsistencies in the wood stain. It is an affordable alternative to more expensive options and can make a significant difference in fireplace aesthetics. However, it may not be suitable for outdoor use and the finish may peel in outdoor elements.
Pros
  • Extremely sturdy and heavy duty.
  • Great for supporting heavy objects like butcher block islands and mantels.
  • Adds a rustic and stylish look to fireplace surrounds.
  • Good quality and well made.
  • Easy to install.
Cons
  • Some brackets arrived damaged or with welding issues.
  • May require additional adjustments or shimming for proper installation.
Bottom Line
These brackets are highly durable and suitable for heavy-duty applications. They provide a rustic aesthetic and are relatively easy to install. However, there may be some quality control issues and lack of customer support.
Pros
  • Looks great and excellent value for the price.
  • No ticking sound.
  • Fits well in small spaces.
  • Keeps accurate time.
  • Easy to set up and use.
Cons
  • Made of cheap materials.
  • Not as durable as expected.
Bottom Line
The clock is a great value for its price, with a beautiful design and accurate timekeeping. However, it may not be as durable or high-quality as expected, and some units may arrive broken.
Pros
  • Easy assembly and shipping.
  • Beautiful design that matches other furniture.
  • Provides heat during cold weather.
  • Pleasing to the eye with therapeutic flames.
  • Compact size for small spaces.
Cons
  • Heat output is not impressive.
  • Grate gets very hot, contrary to product description.
Bottom Line
This electric fireplace is easy to assemble and has a beautiful design. It provides heat and a pleasing ambiance with therapeutic flames. However, the heat output may not be sufficient for larger spaces, and there are some issues with temperature control and noise.

A Comprehensive Buying Guide for Fireplace Mantels

Overview

A fireplace mantel not only adds a touch of elegance to your living space but also serves as a focal point for your fireplace. With various types, materials, styles, and features available, choosing the right fireplace mantel can be overwhelming. This comprehensive buying guide will provide you with valuable insights to make an informed decision.

Types

1. Wood Fireplace Mantels: Known for their classic and timeless appeal, wood mantels offer a wide range of designs and finishes.

2. Stone Fireplace Mantels: Crafted from natural stone, these mantels exude a rustic and luxurious charm.

3. Metal Fireplace Mantels: Contemporary and sleek, metal mantels add a modern touch to any fireplace.

4. Cast Stone Fireplace Mantels: Resembling natural stone, cast stone mantels are a cost-effective alternative with a high-end appearance.

5. Marble Fireplace Mantels: Elegant and sophisticated, marble mantels create a luxurious ambiance.

Key Considerations

1. Size and Dimensions: Measure your fireplace opening and surrounding space to ensure the mantel fits perfectly.

2. Style and Design: Consider the overall aesthetic of your home and choose a mantel that complements your existing décor.

3. Installation: Determine if you prefer a DIY installation or if professional assistance is required.

4. Maintenance: Evaluate the maintenance requirements of different materials and choose one that suits your lifestyle.

5. Safety: Ensure the mantel meets safety standards and consider fire-resistant options for added protection.

Features

1. Shelf: Consider the width and depth of the mantel shelf, as it provides space for displaying decorative items.

2. Corbels: These decorative brackets add visual interest and support to the mantel shelf.

3. Surround: The surround frames the fireplace opening and can be a simple or elaborate design element.

4. Hearth: Some mantels include a hearth, which is the base that extends beyond the fireplace opening.

Prices

Fireplace mantel prices can vary based on material, size, design complexity, and brand. Wood mantels typically range from $200 to $2,000, while stone and marble mantels can range from $1,000 to $10,000 or more. Metal and cast stone mantels often fall within the $500 to $3,000 price range.

Tips

1. Consider the architectural style of your home when choosing a mantel to ensure it harmonizes with the overall design.

2. Take inspiration from magazines, online resources, and home improvement shows to gather ideas for your fireplace mantel.

3. If you're unsure about the installation process, consult a professional to ensure proper and safe installation.

4. Experiment with different decorative elements, such as artwork, mirrors, or candles, to enhance the visual appeal of your mantel.

FAQs

Q: Can I install a fireplace mantel on a brick or stone fireplace?

Q: What is the average lifespan of a fireplace mantel?

Q: How do I maintain and clean my fireplace mantel?

Q: Can I customize a fireplace mantel to my specific design preferences?

Q: Are there any safety precautions I should consider when installing a mantel?

A: By following this buying guide, you'll be equipped with the knowledge to choose the perfect fireplace mantel that suits your style, budget, and enhances the ambiance of your living space.

Runner-Ups

Pros
  • Easy to assemble
  • Good quality
  • Carefully packaged
  • Looks expensive
  • Matches crown molding
Cons
  • Missing parts
  • Weak attachment of leg to top
Bottom Line
The Mike Fireplace Mantel 48-Inch is a good quality product that is easy to assemble and looks expensive. However, there may be issues with missing parts and weak attachments, and there is a risk of damage during shipping.
Pros
  • Very cute design
  • Well made and durable
  • Perfect size for spacious rooms
  • Beautiful addition to any space
  • Great for rustic-themed events
Cons
  • Fragile glass panels
  • Some customers received broken or damaged products
Bottom Line
These lanterns are cute, well-made, and perfect for adding a rustic touch to any space or event. However, the fragile glass panels and occasional issues with breakage may be a concern for some buyers.
Pros
  • Beautiful finish and look
  • Well made and sturdy
  • Easy to install
  • Can be swapped out to create 3 different styles
  • Adds character to the fireplace
Cons
  • Strange appearance and finish in some spots
  • Requires minor assembly
Bottom Line
This mantel offers a beautiful and sturdy addition to any fireplace at a great price. It is easy to install and can be customized with different styles. However, there may be some quality control issues and potential additional costs for returns.
Pros
  • Perfect size for small spaces
  • Good sturdiness and durability
  • Beautiful flame choices
  • Easy installation
  • Prompt shipping
Cons
  • Limited heat output options
  • Low heat output
Bottom Line
This fireplace heater is a good option for small spaces, with beautiful flame choices and easy installation. However, it has limited heat output options, low heat output, and some quality control issues.
Pros
  • Great classic look
  • Large and easy-to-read numbers
  • Runs quietly with no ticking or clicking
  • Accurate timekeeping
  • Attractive and complements desk or living room decor
Cons
  • Made of cheap plastic instead of wood
  • Clock runs slower and may require replacement
Bottom Line
This clock has a great classic look, runs quietly, and is easy to read. However, it is made of cheap plastic and may have issues with timekeeping. It is a good option for those who need a table clock with large numbers and easy visibility.
Please add more products to compare
You can compare up to four products at once
{{compareData.brand}}