10Best.Guide

Fishing Cooler

Top Picks

Last Updated: May, 2023
Pros
  • Great price for a large cooler
  • Lightweight and easy to keep clean
  • Roomy and holds in cold incredibly well
  • Sturdy replacements available on Amazon
  • Large and durable
Cons
  • Latches are frail and weak
  • Clasp and hinges may need to be replaced
Bottom Line
The Igloo Polar 120 is a great value for a large and durable cooler that holds in cold well. However, buyers should be aware of potential issues with the latches, clasp, hinges, and insulation.
Pros
  • Perfect size for day trips and picnics
  • Sturdy and seals temperature well
  • Good for storing perishable items in hot and humid climates
  • Keeps items cold for about 8 hours
  • Easy to carry around and stores a lot
Cons
  • Lid falls off easily
  • Some units arrive dirty
Bottom Line
The Coleman cooler is a good option for day trips and picnics, as it is sturdy, seals temperature well, and is easy to carry around. However, there are some quality control issues, and the lid may fall off easily. It is also not clear on size and capacity, and ice may melt within 4-6 hours.
Pros
  • Keeps minnows alive for several days
  • Quality cooler
  • Holds over a hundred 2in minnows
  • Handles rough ice conditions well
  • Batteries last a long time
Cons
  • Pump stopped working after a few uses
  • No response from seller
Bottom Line
This minnow cooler is effective at keeping bait alive for several days, but there are some quality control issues with the pump and lid latches. The loud aerator and potential for the bubbler to quit working may also be a concern for some buyers.
Pros
  • Large size with plenty of room for food and ice.
  • Light and easy to maneuver with telescoping handle and wheels.
  • Heavy-duty and solid construction.
  • Drain is a nice touch and is really handy.
  • Affordable compared to other similar coolers.
Cons
  • Lid is thin and warps easily, degrading the time items can stay cold.
  • Hard to pull and walk, as feet and legs keep hitting the cooler.
Bottom Line
The Coleman 316 Series Insulated Portable Cooler is a decent buy for those who want a large cooler and don't care about how long they can keep things cold. It is light, easy to maneuver, and affordable compared to other similar coolers. However, the lid is thin and warps easily, and the handles and wheels are not as sturdy as expected.
Pros
  • Great dry box
  • Inexpensive and lightweight
  • Keeps things cool and critters out
  • Good insulation
  • Handy size
Cons
  • Showed up beat up
  • Not well insulated or sturdy
Bottom Line
The Igloo Marine Cooler is a great option for those looking for an inexpensive and lightweight cooler that keeps things cool and dry. It has a handy size, built-in rod holders, and a simple, strong design. However, it may not be the best option for those looking for a highly insulated or sturdy cooler, and some customers have reported issues with the lid and dimensions.

The Ultimate Guide to Buying a Fishing Cooler

Overview

A fishing cooler is an essential piece of equipment for any angler. It keeps your catch fresh, your food and drinks cold, and can even serve as a seat or table. But with so many options on the market, it can be tough to know which one to choose. This guide will help you understand the different types of fishing coolers, key considerations when making your purchase, important features to look for, and tips for using and maintaining your cooler.

Types

1. Hard-Sided Coolers: These coolers are made of durable materials like plastic or metal and offer excellent insulation. They come in a range of sizes and can keep ice frozen for several days.

2. Soft-Sided Coolers: These coolers are lightweight and easy to carry, making them a popular choice for day trips or short excursions. They are not as well insulated as hard-sided coolers and may not keep ice frozen as long.

3. Wheeled Coolers: These coolers have wheels and a handle, making them easy to transport over long distances. They are typically larger and heavier than other types of coolers.

4. Backpack Coolers: These coolers are worn like a backpack and are ideal for hiking or other activities where you need to keep your hands free. They are typically smaller than other types of coolers and may not keep ice frozen as long.

Key Considerations

1. Size: Consider how much food and drink you need to bring, as well as the size of your catch. Choose a cooler that is large enough to accommodate everything you need.

2. Durability: Look for a cooler made of high-quality materials that can withstand rough handling and exposure to the elements.

3. Insulation: Choose a cooler with thick insulation that will keep your food and drinks cold for as long as possible.

4. Portability: Consider how you will be transporting your cooler and choose a model that is easy to carry or has wheels.

5. Price: Fishing coolers can range from under $50 to over $500, so consider your budget when making your purchase.

Features

1. Drainage: Look for a cooler with a built-in drainage system to make it easy to empty melted ice and water.

2. Handles: Choose a cooler with sturdy handles that are comfortable to grip and won't break under heavy loads.

3. Locking Mechanism: Consider a cooler with a locking mechanism to keep your food and drinks secure.

4. Cup Holders: Some coolers come with built-in cup holders, making it easy to enjoy a cold drink while you fish.

5. UV Protection: Look for a cooler with UV protection to prevent sun damage and keep your food and drinks fresh.

Prices

Fishing coolers can range from under $50 to over $500, depending on the size, features, and brand. Soft-sided coolers are typically the most affordable, while hard-sided coolers with advanced features like locking mechanisms and UV protection can be quite expensive.

Tips

1. Pre-cool your cooler before adding food and drinks to maximize its cooling power.

2. Use block ice instead of ice cubes to keep your cooler colder for longer.

3. Keep your cooler out of direct sunlight to prevent ice from melting too quickly.

4. Use a separate cooler for your catch to prevent contamination of your food and drinks.

5. Clean your cooler thoroughly after each use to prevent mold and bacteria growth.

FAQs

Q: How long will my fishing cooler keep ice frozen?

A: The length of time your cooler will keep ice frozen depends on several factors, including the type of cooler, the amount of ice you use, and the ambient temperature. Hard-sided coolers with thick insulation can keep ice frozen for several days, while soft-sided coolers may only keep ice frozen for a few hours.

Q: Can I use dry ice in my fishing cooler?

A: Yes, you can use dry ice in your fishing cooler, but be sure to handle it carefully and follow all safety precautions. Dry ice can cause skin and eye irritation and can be dangerous if ingested.

Q: Can I use my fishing cooler for other activities besides fishing?

A: Yes, fishing coolers are versatile and can be used for a variety of activities, including camping, tailgating, and picnicking.

Runner-Ups

Pros
  • Multi-purpose compact seat
  • Lightweight and easy to carry
  • Roomy storage pouch
  • Includes a cooler
  • Can be secured to anything
Cons
  • Uncomfortable to sit on without cushion
  • Too small for people over 180 lbs
Bottom Line
This backpack/stool is a good option for people who need a lightweight and compact seat for outdoor activities or quick rests. However, it may not be comfortable for everyone, especially for those who are taller or heavier. The fabric and strap quality could also be improved.
Pros
  • Sturdy and durable
  • Perfect size for road trips and camping
  • Light weight design
  • Fits perfectly in an RV or car
  • Can hold ice for a decent amount of time
Cons
  • No drainage hole
  • Ice retention not as good as advertised
Bottom Line
The Igloo Heavy Duty 25 qt cooler is a sturdy and durable option for road trips, camping, and outdoor activities. It is affordable compared to other high-end brands, but may require additional modifications for better ice retention and watertightness. It is not suitable for long-term storage, but great for packing lunches and snacks.
Pros
  • Attaches securely to the back of the kayak seat, leaving more room for gear.
  • Spacious and well-insulated.
  • Handy pockets for storing items.
  • Good quality and durable.
  • Perfect size for a kayak.
Cons
  • Hangs back too far and is hard to reach.
  • Bungees may not hold heavy items well.
Bottom Line
The cooler is a great addition to a kayak, providing ample space for drinks and snacks, and handy pockets for storing items. It is well-made, durable, and flexible, fitting perfectly behind the seat. However, it may not be suitable for heavy items, and the soft bag may droop and collapse when loaded with water bottles.
Pros
  • Holds ice for a few hours
  • Straps are heavy duty
  • Higher quality than expected
  • Solid with a good feeling zipper
  • Fish stayed cold all day
Cons
  • Bottom of the bag is coming apart
  • Zipper is not leak proof
Bottom Line
The Calcutta fish bag is an affordable option for fishermen who need to keep their catch cold for a few hours. It has heavy-duty straps, a solid zipper, and a ruler on the bag. However, the bag may not be leak-proof, and the bottom may come apart after a few uses. It is also not suitable for carrying more than two fish.
Pros
  • Keeps bait alive for a long time
  • Good battery life
  • Nice appearance
  • Mesh basket makes getting bait out easy
  • Perfect for solo fisherman
Cons
  • Hinges are plastic and may break easily
  • Lid is not watertight
Bottom Line
The Frabill Bait Box with Aerator is a good product for keeping bait alive for a long time, but it has some issues with missing parts, leaking, and problematic hose setup.
Please add more products to compare
You can compare up to four products at once
{{compareData.brand}}