10Best.Guide

Gel Eyeliner

Top Picks

Last Updated: November, 2023
Pros
  • Very pigmented color
  • Creamy and durable
  • Truly waterproof
  • Glides on smoothly
  • Stays all day
Cons
  • Doesn't hold up in heat
  • Bleeds onto eyelid
Bottom Line
This eyeliner and Duraline set is highly pigmented, creamy, and durable. It is truly waterproof and stays all day. However, it may bleed onto the eyelid and the lid doesn't stay on well. Overall, it is a great option for those looking for a long-lasting eyeliner.
Pros
  • Waterproof ability is intense and hard to remove.
  • Stays put once it dries, even on hooded eyes.
  • Easy to apply and lasts for a long time.
  • Blackest black color.
  • Good condition upon arrival.
Cons
  • Takes a long time to dry.
  • Texture becomes weird after a few months.
Bottom Line
This gel eyeliner has intense waterproof ability and stays put once it dries, making it suitable for those with hooded eyes. However, it takes a while to dry and may smudge easily. It also has a tendency to dry out over time.
Pros
  • Perfect size for precision work
  • Great for tight lining and creating a cat eye look
  • Excellent quality and value for the cost
  • Provides control and allows for a perfect line
  • Mimics single hairs for eyebrow application
Cons
  • Gel liner can ruin the brush if not cleaned immediately
  • Fragile and prone to breaking
Bottom Line
These eye makeup brushes are perfect for precision work, tight lining, and creating a cat eye look. They offer excellent quality and value for the cost, and are great for gel eyeliner application. However, they require careful cleaning and may be fragile.
Pros
  • Stays put and doesn't smudge
  • Smudges nicely for a smokey look
  • Brings out shadow without being too dark
  • Smudge-proof and water-resistant
  • Stays put throughout the day
Cons
  • Doesn't smudge easily for a smokey eye
  • No sharpener included
Bottom Line
The Maybelline Tattoo Studio Liner Smokey Gel Pencil is a long-lasting and smudge-proof eyeliner that works well for defined liner looks and stays put throughout the day. However, it may not be the best option for creating a smokey eye and may break easily when sharpening.
Pros
  • Smooth and pigmented consistency
  • Long-lasting in the waterline
  • Twist-up design for easy use on the go
  • Good for sensitive eyes
  • Comes in a variety of colors
Cons
  • Smudges easily
  • Not completely waterproof
Bottom Line
The NYX eyeliner is a good option for those looking for a smooth and pigmented eyeliner that is easy to use on the go. However, it may smudge easily and is not completely waterproof. It comes in a variety of colors and is suitable for sensitive eyes.

The Ultimate Buying Guide for Gel Eyeliner

Overview

When it comes to achieving a precise and long-lasting eye makeup look, gel eyeliner is a popular choice among beauty enthusiasts. This buying guide aims to help you navigate through the various options available and choose the best gel eyeliner for your needs. From different types and key considerations to must-have features and price ranges, we've got you covered. Plus, we'll share expert tips to ensure a flawless application every time.

Types

1. Gel Pot Eyeliner: This classic type of gel eyeliner comes in a small pot and is applied using an eyeliner brush. It offers intense pigmentation and is known for its long-lasting formula.

2. Gel Pencil Eyeliner: These gel eyeliners come in a pencil form, allowing for easy and precise application. They offer the convenience of a pencil with the smoothness and longevity of a gel formula.

3. Twist-Up Gel Eyeliner: This type of gel eyeliner comes in a retractable pencil form, eliminating the need for sharpening. It offers a creamy texture and is perfect for on-the-go touch-ups.

Key Considerations

1. Pigmentation: Look for a gel eyeliner that offers rich and intense pigmentation to create bold and defined eye looks.

2. Longevity: Opt for a gel eyeliner that is long-lasting and smudge-proof, ensuring your eye makeup stays intact throughout the day or night.

3. Water Resistance: If you need a gel eyeliner that can withstand water or sweat, choose a waterproof option for a smudge-free and long-wearing finish.

4. Ease of Application: Consider the applicator type that suits your preference, such as a brush or pencil, for a smooth and effortless application.

Features

1. Creamy Texture: Opt for a gel eyeliner with a creamy texture for easy gliding and precise application.

2. Quick Drying: Look for a gel eyeliner that dries quickly to avoid smudging or transferring onto the eyelids.

3. Buildable Formula: Choose a gel eyeliner that allows for layering, so you can achieve different levels of intensity and thickness in your eyeliner look.

Prices

Gel eyeliners are available in a wide price range to suit various budgets. Prices can range from affordable drugstore options to high-end luxury brands. Consider your budget and desired quality when selecting a gel eyeliner.

Tips

1. Prep Your Eyelids: Ensure a smooth application by priming your eyelids with an eyeshadow primer or concealer before applying gel eyeliner.

2. Use the Right Brush: Invest in a high-quality eyeliner brush with a fine tip for precise and controlled application.

3. Set with Eyeshadow: To enhance the longevity of your gel eyeliner, set it with a matching eyeshadow shade using a small angled brush.

FAQs

Q: Can I use gel eyeliner on my waterline?

Q: How do I remove gel eyeliner?

Q: Can I create a winged eyeliner look with gel eyeliner?

Q: Is gel eyeliner suitable for sensitive eyes?

Q: How long does gel eyeliner last before drying out?

A: Additional Sections:

- Pros and Cons of Gel Eyeliner

- How to Clean and Maintain Gel Eyeliner Brushes

- Gel Eyeliner Application Techniques for Different Eye Shapes

Remember to incorporate the keywords naturally throughout the content to optimize it for search engines.

Runner-Ups

Pros
  • Very black and creamy color
  • Stays in place and does not smudge
  • Good value for the price
  • Glides on smoothly and lasts all day
  • Easy to apply and dries quickly
Cons
  • Difficult to remove, requires oil-based makeup remover
  • May smudge to lower eye area
Bottom Line
This gel eyeliner is a good value for its price, providing a very black and creamy color that stays in place all day. It is easy to apply and comes with a good brush for precise application. However, it can be difficult to remove and may smudge to the lower eye area.
Pros
  • Stays in place all day
  • Very dark and intense color
  • Affordable price
  • Long-lasting formula
  • Smudge-proof and waterproof
Cons
  • Applicator brush is bent and difficult to use
  • Gel liner can become patchy and smudge after a few hours
Bottom Line
Maybelline's New York Makeup Eyestudio Lasting Drama Gel Eye Liner is an affordable and long-lasting option for those looking for a dark and intense eyeliner. However, the bent applicator brush and potential for smudging may be drawbacks for some users.
Pros
  • Waterproof and smudge-proof
  • Good for sensitive eyes
  • Long-lasting
  • Great pigmentation
  • Affordable
Cons
  • Can cause eye irritation
  • Difficult to sharpen
Bottom Line
Maybelline Tattoo Studio Eyeliner is a great waterproof and smudge-proof eyeliner that is affordable and suitable for sensitive eyes. However, it can be difficult to sharpen and may cause eye irritation.
Pros
  • Goes on easily for lining the upper eyelid
  • Stays put quite well
  • Great in color
  • Smooth application
  • Easy to use retractable pen format
Cons
  • Burns eyes when used on waterline
  • Fragile and breaks easily
Bottom Line
This Wet n Wild Breakup Proof Retractable Gel Waterproof Eyeliner is a good product for the price. It goes on easily, stays put quite well, and is jet blacker than black. However, it may smudge, break easily, and have inconsistent quality.
Pros
  • Long-lasting (up to 12-14 hours)
  • Creamy and smooth application
  • Intense black color
  • Great for creating winged liner
  • Suitable for tight lining
Cons
  • May cause irritation in some users' eyes
  • Difficult to open eyes wide with the liner on
Bottom Line
Maybelline Eyestudio Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner is a long-lasting, creamy liner that provides intense black color and is great for creating winged liner and tight lining. However, it may cause irritation in some users' eyes and can be difficult to find in stores.
Please add more products to compare
You can compare up to four products at once
{{compareData.brand}}