10Best.Guide

Ice Cream Maker

Top Picks

Last Updated: April, 2023
Pros
  • Easy to use and clean
  • No need to pre-freeze anything
  • Stylish design
  • Intuitive machine
  • Makes consistent ice cream
Cons
  • Costly
  • Large size
Bottom Line
The Whynter ice cream maker is a great investment for those who want to make consistent and delicious ice cream with minimal effort. It is easy to use, clean, and does not require pre-freezing. However, it is costly and has a large size. The poorly designed blade and the possibility of receiving a used product are also potential downsides to consider.
Pros
  • Can turn almost anything into a creamy, delicious treat.
  • Can make healthy treats with low-fat and sugar substitutes.
  • Can make vegan ice cream and sorbet.
  • Can make endless options of ice cream and sherbet flavors.
  • Comes with a recipe book with good recipes.
Cons
  • Poor design that does not stand up to wear and tear.
  • Inedible hard ice layer on the final product.
Bottom Line
The Ninja Creami is a great appliance for making healthy and delicious treats, but it has some design flaws and customer service issues. It is best for those who want to experiment with different flavors and ingredients and are willing to put in the time and effort to prepare the ice cream mixture.
Pros
  • Easy to use
  • Can make a variety of frozen treats
  • Can make healthier versions of frozen treats
  • Can use protein drinks to make ice cream
  • Can make sorbet and gelato
Cons
  • Difficult to clean smaller pieces
  • Requires pre-planning
Bottom Line
The Ninja Creami is a versatile machine that can make a variety of frozen treats, including healthier versions and custom flavors. However, it requires pre-planning and some recipes call for cream cheese. The machine can be difficult to clean and may have an inconsistent texture.
Pros
  • Easy to use
  • Makes soft serve ice cream quickly
  • Heavy-duty motor
  • Sleek design
  • No need for ice or salt
Cons
  • Consistency is soft
  • Loud
Bottom Line
The Cuisinart ice cream maker is a great option for those who want to make homemade ice cream quickly and easily. While it may be loud and expensive, it has a large capacity and a heavy-duty motor that can handle frequent use. However, the consistency may be softer than some prefer, and the freezer bowl can be tricky to unload. Overall, it is a solid choice for those who want to make ice cream at home without the hassle of traditional ice cream makers.
Pros
  • Easy to use and clean
  • Makes delicious ice cream
  • Freezes ice cream quickly
  • Durable and long-lasting
  • Looks great on the countertop
Cons
  • Loud noise
  • Takes up freezer space
Bottom Line
The Cuisinart ice cream maker is a great investment for those who love homemade ice cream. It is easy to use and clean, makes delicious ice cream quickly, and is durable and long-lasting. However, it can be loud, takes up freezer space, and doesn't turn off when finished. Overall, it is a great product for ice cream lovers.

The Ultimate Buying Guide for Ice Cream Makers

Overview

Nothing beats the taste of homemade ice cream, and with the right ice cream maker, you can easily make your own delicious frozen treats at home. However, with so many different types and features available, choosing the best ice cream maker can be overwhelming. In this buying guide, we'll discuss the different types of ice cream makers, key considerations to keep in mind, important features to look for, prices, tips, and FAQs to help you make an informed decision.

Types

1. Manual ice cream makers: These are the most basic type of ice cream makers and require manual labor to churn the ice cream. They are usually less expensive but can be time-consuming and require a lot of effort.

2. Electric ice cream makers: These are the most popular type of ice cream makers and are powered by electricity. They are easy to use and produce consistent results. They are more expensive than manual ice cream makers but are worth the investment.

3. Compressor ice cream makers: These are the most advanced type of ice cream makers and come with a built-in freezer. They are the most expensive but offer the convenience of making ice cream without pre-freezing the bowl.

Key Considerations

1. Capacity: Consider the size of your family or the amount of ice cream you plan to make. Choose an ice cream maker with a capacity that suits your needs.

2. Speed: Some ice cream makers take longer to make ice cream than others. If you want to make ice cream quickly, choose an ice cream maker with a fast churning time.

3. Ease of use: Look for an ice cream maker that is easy to use and clean. Avoid models with complicated controls or hard-to-reach parts.

4. Noise level: Some ice cream makers can be quite noisy. If you plan to use your ice cream maker frequently, choose a model with a quiet motor.

5. Price: Consider your budget and choose an ice cream maker that offers the best value for your money.

Features

1. Automatic shut-off: This feature automatically turns off the ice cream maker when the ice cream is ready to prevent over-churning.

2. Pre-freezing bowl: Some ice cream makers require the bowl to be pre-frozen before use. Look for a model with a pre-freezing bowl that can be stored in your freezer.

3. Transparent lid: A transparent lid allows you to monitor the progress of your ice cream without opening the lid and interrupting the churning process.

4. Multiple paddle attachments: Some ice cream makers come with multiple paddle attachments for making different types of frozen treats, such as sorbet or gelato.

Prices

Ice cream makers can range in price from $20 to $500. Manual ice cream makers are the least expensive, while compressor ice cream makers are the most expensive.

Tips

1. Chill your ingredients before using them to make ice cream.

2. Don't overfill the ice cream maker, as this can prevent proper churning.

3. Clean your ice cream maker thoroughly after each use to prevent bacteria growth.

4. Experiment with different mix-ins and flavors to create your own unique ice cream recipes.

FAQs

Q: How long does it take to make ice cream in an ice cream maker?

A: Answer: The time it takes to make ice cream depends on the type of ice cream maker and the recipe you are using. Generally, it takes 20-30 minutes to make ice cream in an electric ice cream maker.

Q: Can I make sorbet or gelato in an ice cream maker?

A: Answer: Yes, some ice cream makers come with multiple paddle attachments for making different types of frozen treats, such as sorbet or gelato.

Q: Do I need to pre-freeze the bowl before using an ice cream maker?

A: Answer: It depends on the type of ice cream maker. Manual and electric ice cream makers usually require the bowl to be pre-frozen, while compressor ice cream makers have a built-in freezer and do not require pre-freezing.

Runner-Ups

Pros
  • Easy to use and clean
  • Makes ice cream quickly
  • Comes with a booklet with different ice cream flavors
  • Lightweight and compact
  • Quiet operation
Cons
  • Paddle mechanism isn't very effective
  • Motor may break down after a few uses
Bottom Line
This ice cream maker is easy to use and clean, makes ice cream quickly, and comes with a booklet with different flavors. However, the paddle mechanism isn't very effective, the motor may break down after a few uses, and the ice cream may turn out thick and airy instead of traditional.
Pros
  • Vintage look
  • Easy to set up
  • Good amount of ice cream
  • Can be playful with flavors
  • Perfect size for family gatherings
Cons
  • Paddle doesn't scrape the hardening ice cream
  • Does not shut itself off when ice cream is done
Bottom Line
The Nostalgia 6-quart electric ice cream maker has a vintage look and is easy to set up. It makes a good amount of ice cream and can be playful with flavors. However, it has some drawbacks such as the paddle not scraping the hardening ice cream and no auto shut-off.
Pros
  • Easy to use and clean.
  • Makes great quality and smooth texture ice cream.
  • Easy to set up and comes with a lid for ripening and storing ice cream.
  • Freezes ice cream quickly.
  • Strong motor.
Cons
  • Freezing time is longer than stated in the literature.
  • Motor and paddle are made of plastic and may wear out quickly.
Bottom Line
This ice cream maker is easy to use and clean, and produces great quality ice cream with a smooth texture. However, the freezing time may be longer than stated, and the motor and paddle are made of plastic and may wear out quickly. The aluminum canister is difficult to clean and may oxidize, and the motor may overheat and need to cool down before restarting. Some parts may arrive damaged or missing.
Pros
  • Easy to use and clean.
  • A healthy alternative to ice cream.
  • Recipe book included.
  • Great for getting kids to eat fruit.
  • Can use a variety of frozen fruits.
Cons
  • End product doesn't look like the photos.
  • May not be creamy enough for some.
Bottom Line
The Yonanas Frozen Fruit Soft Serve Maker is a great option for those looking for a healthy alternative to ice cream and a way to use up ripe fruit. However, it may not be suitable for those who don't like bananas and the end product may not be as creamy as traditional ice cream.
Pros
  • Easy to use and makes delicious ice cream.
  • Solid packaging and doesn't feel cheaply made.
  • Can make a variety of frozen treats.
  • Refurbished option saves money.
Cons
  • Some parts may crack or corrode over time.
  • The Turner attachment may not fit well.
Bottom Line
This ice cream maker attachment is a great option for those who want to make homemade ice cream without the hassle of traditional methods. However, buyers should be aware of potential issues with certain parts and the need for some prep time. The refurbished option can be a cost-effective choice for those on a budget.
Please add more products to compare
You can compare up to four products at once
{{compareData.brand}}