10Best.Guide

Ice Cube Tray

Top Picks

Last Updated: April, 2023
Pros
  • Durable and made from a material that is part plastic and part rubber.
  • Easy to remove ice cubes.
  • Stackable in any direction.
  • Made in the USA.
  • Ice cubes pop out easily.
Cons
  • Expensive.
  • May add a bad taste to the ice.
Bottom Line
Rubbermaid ice cube trays are a great investment for those looking for durable and easy-to-use ice cube trays. While they may be more expensive than other options, they are worth the investment for their quality and ease of use. However, some customers have reported issues with taste and quality control, so it's important to be aware of these potential drawbacks before purchasing.
Pros
  • Cute and small ice balls.
  • Easy to fill trays.
  • Comes with a container and scoop.
  • Perfect size for ice crunching.
  • Can be used to blend smoothies or frozen drinks.
Cons
  • Difficult to remove ice balls from the tray.
  • Some extra water gets in, causing it to be more like an ice sheet.
Bottom Line
This ice tray is perfect for those who want small and cute ice balls. It is easy to fill and comes with a container and scoop. However, it can be difficult to remove the ice balls from the tray and there is a small amount of ice cubes.
Pros
  • Makes unique round ice balls
  • Comes with ice trays, storage container, and scoops/tongs
  • Easy to use and makes a lot of ice at once
  • Ice cubes keep in the cup for a long time
  • Container holds at least 5 sets of trays
Cons
  • Difficult to close the top of the trays without getting splashed
  • Excess water comes with filling the trays
Bottom Line
This product is great for those who want unique round ice balls and comes with everything needed to make and store the ice. However, some customers have experienced issues with the product such as difficulty filling the trays and incomplete or damaged products.
Pros
  • Easy to fill and seal shut
  • Fun shape and good size
  • Built-in funnel and overflow
  • Roses come out beautifully
  • Durable and easy to use
Cons
  • Can be difficult to fill
  • May spill over when filling
Bottom Line
This ice cube tray is a fun and creative way to add a floral touch to drinks. It is easy to use and produces beautiful roses, but may have some issues with filling and tipping in drinks. It is also important to handle the silicone carefully to prevent cracking. Overall, it is a good value for the price.
Pros
  • Perfect cubes
  • Easy to pop out
  • Sturdy trays
  • Effortless to remove ice cubes
  • Takes up less space
Cons
  • Hard to twist sometimes
  • Inconsistent ice cube removal
Bottom Line
These ice cube trays are great for making perfect cubes and easy removal. They are sturdy and take up less space. However, they may be difficult to twist and inconsistent with ice cube removal. The lids are helpful for stacking, but they are made of thin plastic and the silicone bottom may detach over time.

The Ultimate Buying Guide for Ice Cube Trays: Types, Key Considerations, Features and Prices

Overview

Ice cube trays are an essential tool in any kitchen, especially during the summer months. They come in a variety of shapes, sizes, and materials, making it difficult to know which one to choose. This buying guide will help you make an informed decision by providing you with information on the different types of ice cube trays, key considerations when purchasing one, features to look for, and prices.

Types

1. Plastic ice cube trays: These are the most common type of ice cube trays and are made of plastic. They come in a variety of shapes and sizes, and are easy to use and clean.

2. Silicone ice cube trays: These are becoming increasingly popular due to their flexibility and ease of use. They are also dishwasher safe and come in a variety of shapes and sizes.

3. Stainless steel ice cube trays: These are durable and long-lasting, making them a great investment. They are also easy to clean and can be used for both ice and food.

4. Large ice cube trays: These are perfect for those who prefer larger ice cubes for their drinks. They come in a variety of shapes and sizes, and are typically made of silicone or plastic.

Key Considerations

1. Size: Consider the size of the ice cube tray and whether it will fit in your freezer.

2. Shape: Think about the shape of the ice cube tray and whether it will fit your needs. Some trays come in unique shapes, such as hearts or stars.

3. Material: Consider the material of the ice cube tray and whether it is durable and easy to clean.

4. Ease of use: Look for ice cube trays that are easy to use and release the ice cubes easily.

5. Stackable: Consider whether the ice cube tray is stackable for easy storage.

Features

1. Lid: Look for ice cube trays that come with a lid to prevent spills and contamination.

2. Non-stick: Consider ice cube trays that are non-stick for easy release of the ice cubes.

3. BPA-free: Look for ice cube trays that are BPA-free to ensure they are safe for use.

4. Dishwasher safe: Consider ice cube trays that are dishwasher safe for easy cleaning.

Prices

Ice cube trays can range in price from $5 to $30, depending on the material, size, and features.

Tips

1. Use distilled water to make clear ice cubes.

2. Use a silicone ice cube tray for easy release of the ice cubes.

3. Consider purchasing an ice cube tray with a lid to prevent spills.

FAQs

Q: Can I use my ice cube tray for freezing food?

A: Yes, many ice cube trays can be used for freezing food.

Q: Do I need to wash my ice cube tray before using it?

A: Yes, it is recommended to wash your ice cube tray before using it for the first time.

Q: How do I remove the ice cubes from the tray?

A: Some ice cube trays have a release button or lever, while others can be twisted or tapped to release the ice cubes.

Q: Can I put my ice cube tray in the dishwasher?

A: It depends on the material of the ice cube tray. Plastic and silicone trays are typically dishwasher safe, while stainless steel trays may need to be hand washed.

Runner-Ups

Pros
  • Perfect size for flavored ice
  • Can be used for various drinks
  • Easy to use and stack in the freezer
  • Makes round ice balls
  • Comes with a lid and scoop
Cons
  • Container may arrive broken
  • Warps after multiple uses
Bottom Line
These ice cube trays are a good option for those who want smaller, round ice balls and a convenient storage container. However, there may be issues with durability and difficulty in use.
Pros
  • Perfect size for freezing baby food portions
  • Easy to clean and remove frozen food
  • Sturdy and comes with lids
  • Large cubes melt slower than traditional trays
  • Good for freezing leftover smoothie ingredients
Cons
  • Can easily tip when filled with water
  • Difficult to remove cubes once frozen
Bottom Line
These ice cube trays are sturdy, easy to clean, and come with lids. However, they can be difficult to remove cubes once frozen and may retain freezer smell. The larger cubes are great for drinks that need to stay cold longer.
Pros
  • Makes perfect round ice cubes
  • Comes with a container to hold the ice
  • Easy to use
  • Fun and aesthetically pleasing
  • Great for cold brew coffee
Cons
  • Lid may not seal properly
  • May be difficult to release ice cubes
Bottom Line
This ice cube tray is a great option for those who want perfect round ice cubes and a fun, aesthetically pleasing addition to their drinks. However, it may have some issues with the lid and packaging.
Pros
  • Perfect ice cube size
  • Easy to dislodge ice cubes
  • Silicone bottoms make it easy to take ice cubes out
  • Good for small spaces
  • Lids help keep water from splashing out
Cons
  • Lids are flimsy
  • Plastic becomes brittle when frozen
Bottom Line
These ice cube trays are great for those who want a simple and reliable way to make ice cubes. They are perfect for small spaces and freezing fresh squeezed juice. However, the lids are flimsy and don't seal water in well, and stacking can be a bit of a challenge.
Pros
  • Easy to fill and stack
  • Flexible material
  • Convenient lid to avoid water spills
  • Easy to clean
  • Easy to remove ice cubes
Cons
  • Cubes are difficult to remove
  • Some trays break easily
Bottom Line
This silicone ice cube tray is a functional and affordable option for those who want to avoid the hassle of traditional plastic trays. However, some trays may have quality issues, so buyers should be careful when using them.
Please add more products to compare
You can compare up to four products at once
{{compareData.brand}}