10Best.Guide

Maple Syrup

Top Picks

Last Updated: April, 2023
Pros
  • Real maple syrup from Vermont
  • Good flavor and sweetness
  • Fast shipping
  • Good packaging
  • Auto-delivery option
Cons
  • Inconsistent flavor and color
  • Price is higher than some other brands
Bottom Line
Butternut Mountain Vermont Maple Syrup is a high-quality, pure and natural alternative to sugar substitutes. While some customers have experienced packaging issues and inconsistent flavor, the majority of reviews praise the flavor and sweetness of this real maple syrup from Vermont. It is a bit more expensive than some other brands, but the quality and taste make it worth the investment for those who appreciate real maple syrup.
Pros
  • Real maple flavor
  • Rich and flavorful
  • Good value for the price
  • Healthier alternative to sugar
  • Great for making sauces and BBQ
Cons
  • Packaging issues
  • Inconsistent taste
Bottom Line
This organic maple syrup is a great value for those looking for a healthier alternative to sugar. While it has a rich and flavorful taste, there have been some issues with packaging and consistency.
Pros
  • Great value for the price
  • 100% pure maple syrup
  • Excellent deep maple taste
  • Tastes like local Vermont syrup
  • Good quantity for the price
Cons
  • Thin and watery consistency
  • Flavor is not intense
Bottom Line
This Vermont Maple Syrup is a great value for those looking for a pure maple syrup option. While it may not have the best taste quality, it is a good option for bulk-buying and has a deep maple taste. However, some customers have noted that it is thin and watery, and lacks an intense flavor.
Pros
  • Rich flavor, great taste
  • Good value for the money
  • Smokey and nuanced taste
  • Excellent tasting syrup
  • Delicious, no odd aftertaste
Cons
  • Very bitter taste
  • Mild taste, not strong enough
Bottom Line
This Vermont maple syrup is a great choice for those who want a rich, flavorful syrup. It is a good value for the money and has a smokey, nuanced taste. However, it may not be for everyone, as some find it too bitter or mild in taste. Additionally, some customers feel that it is overpriced and not worth the premium price. Overall, it is a good choice for those who want a high-quality maple syrup.
Pros
  • Distinctive deliciousness on pancakes, waffles, and French toast.
  • Robust flavor with notes of smoky bourbon.
  • Consistency is just right.
  • Best tasting maple syrup with a hint of bourbon.
  • Fantastic smell when you open the bottle.
Cons
  • Expensive.
  • Sickening sweetness with added sugar.
Bottom Line
Crown Maple Bourbon Aged Organic Maple Syrup is a delicious and distinctive syrup with a robust flavor and perfect consistency. However, it is quite expensive and some customers find it too sweet or too pricey for the size of the bottle.

The Ultimate Guide to Buying Maple Syrup: Types, Features, Prices, and Tips

Overview

Maple syrup is a delicious and versatile sweetener that can be used in a variety of recipes, from pancakes and waffles to glazes and marinades. But with so many different types, grades, and brands of maple syrup available, it can be hard to know which one to choose. In this guide, we'll walk you through everything you need to know to make an informed decision when buying maple syrup.

Types

There are several different types of maple syrup available, each with its own unique flavor and characteristics. Here are some of the most common types:

- Pure maple syrup: Made entirely from the sap of maple trees, pure maple syrup is the most natural and authentic form of maple syrup. It comes in several different grades, which we'll discuss in more detail below.

- Organic maple syrup: Like pure maple syrup, organic maple syrup is made entirely from the sap of maple trees, but it is produced without the use of synthetic pesticides or fertilizers.

- Grade A maple syrup: Grade A maple syrup is the highest quality maple syrup available, with a light color and delicate flavor. It is typically used for table syrup and in recipes where a subtle maple flavor is desired.

- Grade B maple syrup: Grade B maple syrup has a darker color and stronger flavor than Grade A maple syrup, making it a popular choice for cooking and baking.

- Dark maple syrup: Dark maple syrup has a robust, full-bodied flavor and is often used in recipes that call for a stronger maple flavor.

- Light maple syrup: Light maple syrup has a milder flavor than dark maple syrup and is often used as a topping for pancakes and waffles.

- Amber maple syrup: Amber maple syrup has a rich, caramel-like flavor and is often used in baking and cooking.

- Vermont maple syrup: Maple syrup produced in Vermont is known for its high quality and distinctive flavor. It is often considered the gold standard of maple syrup.

- Canadian maple syrup: Canada is the world's largest producer of maple syrup, and Canadian maple syrup is known for its rich, complex flavor.

Key Considerations

When buying maple syrup, there are several key considerations to keep in mind. Here are some of the most important factors to consider:

- Grade: As we mentioned earlier, maple syrup comes in several different grades, each with its own unique flavor and characteristics. Consider what grade of maple syrup will work best for your intended use.

- Purity: Look for maple syrup that is 100% pure and free from additives or preservatives.

- Price: Maple syrup can be expensive, so consider your budget when making a purchase.

- Brand: There are many different brands of maple syrup available, each with its own unique flavor and reputation. Do some research to find a brand that you trust.

Features

Here are some features to look for when buying maple syrup:

- Organic certification: If you're concerned about synthetic pesticides and fertilizers, look for maple syrup that is certified organic.

- Glass vs. plastic bottles: Maple syrup is often sold in glass or plastic bottles. Glass bottles are more environmentally friendly and can help preserve the flavor of the syrup.

- Size: Maple syrup is often sold in a variety of sizes, from small bottles to large jugs. Consider how much maple syrup you'll need and choose a size that works for you.

Prices

The price of maple syrup can vary widely depending on the grade, brand, and size of the bottle. Here are some general price ranges to keep in mind:

- Grade A maple syrup: $10-$20 per 8-ounce bottle

- Grade B maple syrup: $10-$20 per 8-ounce bottle

- Organic maple syrup: $15-$30 per 8-ounce bottle

- Vermont maple syrup: $15-$30 per 8-ounce bottle

- Canadian maple syrup: $15-$30 per 8-ounce bottle

Tips

Here are some expert tips to help you buy the best maple syrup:

- Look for maple syrup that is labeled "100% pure" and free from additives or preservatives.

- Consider the grade of maple syrup that will work best for your intended use.

- If possible, buy maple syrup in glass bottles to help preserve the flavor.

- Store maple syrup in a cool, dark place to help prolong its shelf life.

- Consider buying maple syrup in bulk to save money.

FAQs

Q: What is the difference between Grade A and Grade B maple syrup?

A: Grade A maple syrup is lighter in color and has a more delicate flavor than Grade B maple syrup, which is darker and has a stronger flavor. Grade A maple syrup is typically used for table syrup and in recipes where a subtle maple flavor is desired, while Grade B maple syrup is often used for cooking and baking.

Q: Is organic maple syrup worth the extra cost?

A: If you're concerned about synthetic pesticides and fertilizers, organic maple syrup may be worth the extra cost. However, keep in mind that all maple syrup is produced without the use of harmful chemicals, so non-organic maple syrup is still a safe and healthy choice.

Q: How should I store maple syrup?

A: Maple syrup should be stored in a cool, dark place, such as a pantry or cupboard. It can also be stored in the refrigerator, although this is not necessary.

Q: How long does maple syrup last?

A: Maple syrup can last for several years if stored properly. Once opened, it should be consumed within a few months.

Q: Can I use maple syrup as a substitute for sugar in recipes?

A: Yes, maple syrup can be used as a substitute for sugar in many recipes. Keep in mind that it will add a distinct maple flavor to the dish.

Runner-Ups

Pros
  • Most flavorful maple syrup ever tasted
  • Great gift for maple syrup lovers
  • Good choice for people who prefer lighter syrup
  • Super unique, deep flavor
  • Generous amount in the bottle
Cons
  • One batch had a bad taste
  • Mold found in a sealed bottle
Bottom Line
This maple syrup is a bit pricier, but it is worth it for its unique and deep flavor. It makes a great gift for maple syrup lovers and is a good choice for those who prefer lighter syrup. However, there have been some issues with bad batches, mold, and difficult-to-remove caps.
Pros
  • Intense maple flavor
  • Organic and natural
  • Great for those who prefer a milder taste
  • Good quality
  • Attractively packaged
Cons
  • False advertising
  • No cap included in shipping
Bottom Line
This organic Grade B maple syrup has an intense maple flavor and is great for those who prefer a milder taste. It is organic and natural, but more expensive than some alternatives. However, it is attractively packaged and of good quality. Be aware that it is a lower grade than some may prefer and may not be as thick or strong as some alternatives.
Pros
  • Great flavor
  • Consistently good price
  • Strong maple taste
  • Dark amber color
  • Caramel-like flavor
Cons
  • Description and source of syrup is unclear
  • Strong flavor is different from other maple syrups
Bottom Line
Coombs Family Farms Grade A Dark Robust Maple Syrup has a great flavor and consistently good price. It has a strong maple taste with a caramel-like flavor and dark amber color. However, some customers have reported issues with the description and source of the syrup, as well as separation and lack of flavor.
Pros
  • Great taste and flavor
  • Arrived quickly and makes a great gift
  • Real Vermont maple syrup
  • Rich flavor that works well on pancakes and French toast
  • Cute and substantial plastic jug
Cons
  • Expensive for the amount received
  • Thin and too sugary for some
Bottom Line
This Vermont maple syrup has a great taste and flavor, and is a real Vermont maple syrup that works well on pancakes and French toast. However, it is expensive for the amount received and some found it too thin and sugary.
Pros
  • Real maple syrup taste
  • Comes in glass bottle
  • Maintains quality for a long time
  • Great taste for recipes
  • Right thickness
Cons
  • Inconsistent flavor
  • Thin consistency
Bottom Line
Maple Grove Farms syrup offers a real maple syrup taste in a glass bottle with the right thickness for recipes. However, the inconsistent flavor, thin consistency, and price not being special may not be worth it for some buyers. Additionally, the packaging can be terrible and wasteful.
Please add more products to compare
You can compare up to four products at once
{{compareData.brand}}