10Best.Guide

Olive Oil

Top Picks

Last Updated: April, 2023
Pros
  • Good value for the amount of oil
  • Quality olive oil in a colored glass bottle
  • Reasonably priced for an organic option
  • Great flavor for cooking and mixing with other ingredients
  • Excellent quality and widely available
Cons
  • Lid doesn't stay on well
  • Dark plastic container not the best choice
Bottom Line
Colavita Extra Virgin Olive Oil is a great value for the amount of oil and is of good quality. It has a great flavor and is widely available. However, some customers have received rancid oil and some don't like the flavor. The lid doesn't stay on well and the dark plastic container is not the best choice.
Pros
  • Good value for the price
  • Mild, grassy flavor
  • Great for everyday use
  • Nice peppery flavor
  • XL bottle size
Cons
  • Harsh chemical taste
  • Poor packaging
Bottom Line
This olive oil is a good value for everyday use, but may not be the best choice for raw dressings or flavor purposes. The packaging and spout could be improved, and some customers have noted a lack of flavor or a harsh chemical taste.
Pros
  • Good value for the price
  • Suitable for cooking various types of food
  • Quality speaks for itself
  • Peppery flavor
  • Can be used for marinades and frying
Cons
  • Cap does not seal properly
  • Not as robust as advertised
Bottom Line
Pompeian Robust Extra Virgin Olive Oil is a good value for the price and can be used for cooking various types of food. While some customers have experienced issues with the cap and taste, the majority of reviews are positive and recommend this product.
Pros
  • Clean taste
  • Great for salads, frying eggs, and finishing drizzle
  • Nice and mild flavor
  • Cheaper and better quality than other brands
  • Highly rated and good tasting blend
Cons
  • Not 100% Californian
  • Greasy and tastes like other cheap oils
Bottom Line
This olive oil is a great choice for those who want a clean, mild-tasting oil that is good for salads, frying eggs, and finishing drizzle. It is cheaper and better quality than many other brands and has a higher polyphenol count than many Mediterranean blends. However, it is not 100% Californian and may not be the best choice for those looking for a rich, robust flavor.
Pros
  • Delicious taste
  • Good value for the price
  • Ideal for cooking
  • Mild flavor
  • Cold-pressed
Cons
  • Poor quality plastic bottle
  • No screw top
Bottom Line
Pompeian Extra Virgin Olive Oil is a good value for those who need a large amount of olive oil for cooking. The plastic bottle is not the best quality, but the oil itself has a delicious taste and is cold-pressed. However, the pop off cap can be difficult to use and some bottles may arrive damaged.

The Ultimate Guide to Buying Olive Oil: Types, Key Considerations, Features, Prices, Tips, and FAQs

Overview

Olive oil is a staple in many households, and for good reason. It is not only delicious but also offers numerous health benefits. However, with so many options available, it can be overwhelming to choose the right one. This guide will help you understand the different types of olive oil, key considerations when buying, features to look for, prices, tips, and frequently asked questions.

Types

1. Extra Virgin Olive Oil - Made from the first cold press of the olives, this is the highest quality and most flavorful type of olive oil. It has a low acidity level and is best used for dressings, dips, and drizzling over foods.

2. Virgin Olive Oil - Also made from the first press of the olives, this type has a slightly higher acidity level than extra virgin olive oil. It is still a good option for dressings and dips.

3. Pure Olive Oil - A blend of virgin and refined olive oils, this type has a milder flavor and higher smoke point, making it suitable for cooking at higher temperatures.

4. Light Olive Oil - This type is not lower in calories or fat, as the name suggests. It is simply a refined olive oil with a lighter color and milder flavor. It is also suitable for cooking at higher temperatures.

Key Considerations

1. Quality - Look for olive oils that are labeled as extra virgin or virgin, as they are the highest quality.

2. Freshness - Olive oil can go rancid over time, so look for bottles with a harvest date or best-by date.

3. Origin - Some regions, such as Italy and Greece, are known for producing high-quality olive oil.

4. Price - High-quality olive oil can be expensive, but it is worth the investment for the flavor and health benefits.

Features

1. Harvesting method - Look for olive oils that are made using traditional cold-press methods rather than chemical extraction.

2. Packaging - Dark glass bottles can help protect the oil from light and air, which can cause it to spoil faster.

3. Organic - Consider buying organic olive oil to avoid exposure to pesticides.

Prices

Prices for olive oil can vary widely depending on the type and quality. Extra virgin olive oil can range from $10 to $50 per bottle, while pure olive oil and light olive oil are generally less expensive.

Tips

1. Store olive oil in a cool, dark place to help preserve its flavor and quality.

2. Use olive oil within 6 months of opening the bottle.

3. Taste the olive oil before buying if possible to ensure you like the flavor.

4. Use olive oil for dressings, dips, and drizzling over foods, and use pure or light olive oil for cooking at higher temperatures.

FAQs

Q: Is olive oil healthy?

A: Yes, olive oil is a healthy source of monounsaturated fats and antioxidants.

Q: How can I tell if olive oil has gone bad?

A: Olive oil that smells rancid or has a bitter taste has likely gone bad.

Q: Can I use olive oil for frying?

A: Extra virgin olive oil is not recommended for frying due to its low smoke point. Pure or light olive oil can be used for frying at higher temperatures.

Runner-Ups

Pros
  • Excellent flavor
  • Great value for the price
  • Versatile for cooking
  • 100% virgin olive oil
  • Good for health
Cons
  • Plastic bottle
  • Difficult to open cap
Bottom Line
Pompeian's Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil is a great value for the price with excellent flavor and versatility for cooking. However, the plastic bottle and difficult-to-open cap may be a downside for some buyers.
Pros
  • Good price compared to local markets
  • Great taste and flavor
  • Consistent quality
  • Good for cooking and salads
  • Has health benefits for both inside and outside the body
Cons
  • Some customers claim it's not real EVOO
  • Bitter taste for some customers
Bottom Line
Bertolli Extra Virgin Olive Oil is a good quality product with a great taste and consistent quality. It has health benefits and is good for cooking and salads. However, some customers claim it's not real EVOO and it may have a bitter taste for some. The plastic packaging may also be a concern for some customers.
Pros
  • Nice taste
  • Good for cooking
  • Mild flavor
  • Great for making homemade mayonnaise
  • Good value
Cons
  • Not pure olive oil
  • Poor packaging
Bottom Line
Pompeian Extra Light Tasting Olive Oil is a good option for those who want a mild-tasting oil for cooking and making homemade mayonnaise. However, it may not be pure olive oil and the packaging can be problematic. It has a high smoke point for frying but may not be suitable for high heat cooking.
Pros
  • Healthy cooking oil that doesn't trigger migraines.
  • Good taste and quality.
  • Easy pour spout.
  • Versatile and has many uses.
  • Packaged in a can to preserve quality and freshness.
Cons
  • Expensive.
  • One can arrived badly dented.
Bottom Line
La Tourangelle offers a range of high-quality cooking oils that are versatile and healthy. While some customers have had issues with dented cans, cloudy substance, and short expiration dates, most customers enjoy the taste and quality of the oils. The price may be a bit high for some, but the benefits of using a healthy and versatile cooking oil may outweigh the cost.
Pros
  • Great flavor
  • High quality
  • Fresh taste
  • Clean, nutty taste
  • Good for finishing dishes and salads
Cons
  • Poor packaging, cans arrived dented
  • Expensive for the amount of product
Bottom Line
This olive oil has a great flavor and high quality, but the packaging is poor and cans often arrive dented. It is also expensive for the amount of product.
Please add more products to compare
You can compare up to four products at once
{{compareData.brand}}