10Best.Guide

Pillow Inserts

Top Picks

Last Updated: May, 2023
Pros
  • Great quality and support
  • Accurately fills pillow covers
  • Soft and fluffy
  • Holds shape well
  • Washable
Cons
  • Some had odor issues
  • Some found the inserts too squishy or not firm enough
Bottom Line
The Pillowflex Synthetic Down Pillow Inserts are a great option for those who want a washable, hypoallergenic pillow insert that provides good support and holds its shape well. Be sure to size up 2 inches for the best fit.
Pros
  • Pillows are wonderful and comfortable.
  • Pillows have a cotton covering with a zipper that provides access to the stuffing.
  • Pillows arrive vacuum sealed and fluff up nicely.
  • Pillows are well protected during shipping.
  • Pillows have no smell.
Cons
  • Pillows are understuffed.
  • Sizing is off.
Bottom Line
These pillows are comfortable, well-protected during shipping, and fluff up nicely. They have a cotton covering with a zipper that provides access to the stuffing. However, they may be understuffed and sizing is off, so buyers may want to consider going up a size.
Pros
  • Firm and doesn't squish down
  • Fluffs up well in the dryer
  • Great replacement inserts for sofa pillows
  • Good quality and thickness
  • Dense and fluffy
Cons
  • Minimum amount of stuffing
  • Not suitable for lumbar support
Bottom Line
These pillow inserts are a good option for those looking for firm and fluffy inserts that don't squish down easily. However, they may not be suitable for those looking for lumbar support or overstuffed pillows. It's important to size up and fluff them up in the dryer for best results.
Pros
  • Good quality
  • Affordable
  • Hold their shape well
  • Best throw pillow fillers on Amazon
  • Come in a pack of two
Cons
  • Some pillows did not fully puff up
  • Corners were empty
Bottom Line
These pillows are a good quality and affordable option for decorative purposes, but may not provide enough functional support for chairs. They come vacuum sealed and may require some fluffing to fully expand.
Pros
  • High-quality stitching.
  • Full yet soft.
  • Retains shape well.
  • Firm yet plushy.
  • Good price.
Cons
  • Inability to be "chopped".
  • Sizing issues.
Bottom Line
These pillow inserts are a great option for those looking for full, firm, and supportive inserts at a good price. However, buyers should be aware of sizing issues and the material's roughness and noise.

The Ultimate Guide to Buying Pillow Inserts: Types, Features, and Tips

Overview

Pillow inserts are an essential part of any pillow. They provide the structure and support that make pillows comfortable and functional. However, with so many types of pillow inserts available, it can be challenging to know which one to choose. This guide will provide you with all the information you need to make an informed decision when buying pillow inserts.

Types

1. Down Pillow Inserts: Down pillow inserts are made from the soft, fluffy feathers found under the outer feathers of ducks and geese. They are lightweight, soft, and provide excellent insulation. They are also more expensive than other types of pillow inserts.

2. Synthetic Pillow Inserts: Synthetic pillow inserts are made from polyester or other synthetic fibers. They are less expensive than down pillow inserts and are hypoallergenic, making them an excellent choice for people with allergies.

3. Feather Pillow Inserts: Feather pillow inserts are made from the outer feathers of ducks and geese. They are heavier and denser than down pillow inserts and provide more support. They are also less expensive than down pillow inserts.

4. Cotton Pillow Inserts: Cotton pillow inserts are made from 100% cotton. They are lightweight, soft, and breathable. They are an excellent choice for people who want a natural filling.

5. Polyester Pillow Inserts: Polyester pillow inserts are made from synthetic fibers. They are less expensive than down pillow inserts and are easy to care for. They are also hypoallergenic.

6. Memory Foam Pillow Inserts: Memory foam pillow inserts are made from a special type of foam that conforms to the shape of your head and neck. They are excellent for people who need extra support.

Key Considerations

1. Size: Pillow inserts come in various sizes, so it's essential to measure your pillow cover before buying an insert.

2. Shape: Pillow inserts come in different shapes, including square, lumbar, bolster, euro, standard, king, and queen. Choose the shape that matches your pillow cover.

3. Density: Pillow inserts come in different densities, which affect their firmness and support. Choose the density that matches your comfort preferences.

4. Loft: Pillow inserts come in different lofts, which affect their height and fluffiness. Choose the loft that matches your comfort preferences.

Features

1. Hypoallergenic: Some pillow inserts are hypoallergenic, making them an excellent choice for people with allergies.

2. Breathable: Some pillow inserts are breathable, which helps regulate your body temperature while you sleep.

3. Easy to clean: Some pillow inserts are easy to clean, which makes them a practical choice for people who want low-maintenance bedding.

Prices

Pillow inserts vary in price depending on their size, type, and features. Down pillow inserts are the most expensive, while synthetic pillow inserts are the least expensive.

Tips

1. Choose the right size and shape for your pillow cover.

2. Consider your comfort preferences when choosing the density and loft of your pillow insert.

3. Look for hypoallergenic and breathable pillow inserts if you have allergies or sleep hot.

4. Follow the care instructions carefully to prolong the life of your pillow insert.

FAQs

Q: How often should I replace my pillow insert?

A: It's recommended to replace your pillow insert every 1-2 years.

Q: Can I wash my pillow insert?

A: It depends on the type of pillow insert. Some can be washed in a washing machine, while others need to be dry cleaned. Check the care instructions before washing.

Q: What size pillow insert should I buy?

A: Measure your pillow cover and choose an insert that matches the size.

Q: Which type of pillow insert is the best?

A: It depends on your comfort preferences, budget, and any allergies you may have. Consider the pros and cons of each type before making a decision.

Conclusion:

Choosing the right pillow insert is essential for a good night's sleep. Consider the size, shape, type, density, and loft when making your decision. Look for features that match your comfort preferences, such as hypoallergenic and breathable materials. Follow the care instructions carefully to prolong the life of your pillow insert.

Runner-Ups

Pros
  • High quality and soft
  • Nice finished edge
  • Holds shape well
  • Good for accessory staging
  • Good quality casing
Cons
  • Strong mildew smell
  • Lack of fill
Bottom Line
This pillow insert is of good quality and holds its shape well, but buyers should be aware of the potential for a strong mildew smell and consider ordering a size up for optimal fullness.
Pros
  • Soft and lightweight
  • Well-made and nicely fluffy
  • Can be easily laundered
  • Perfect size for certain shams and for lumbar support
  • Good for decorative purposes and comfortable for napping
Cons
  • Not enough filling for some customers
  • Smaller than advertised for some customers
Bottom Line
These pillow inserts are a good choice for those looking for soft and lightweight inserts that are easy to launder and come in a variety of sizes. However, they may not be the best option for those looking for a lot of support or a lot of filling in their pillows.
Pros
  • Good value for the price
  • Nice and hefty
  • Great quality
  • Soft and perfect for "chopping"
  • No odor
Cons
  • Feathers poke through
  • Compress down quickly and lose shape
Bottom Line
These feather inserts are a good value for the price and are great for decorative purposes. However, they may not hold up well over time and may require fluffing to maintain their shape. Buyers should be aware of the potential for feathers to poke through and the need to order a size up.
Pros
  • Item as described
  • Shipped and delivered on time
  • Good value for the price
  • Perfect size for 18x18 pillow covers
  • Nice and full without being too fat
Cons
  • Subpar stuffing
  • Flat upon arrival
Bottom Line
These pillow inserts are a good value for the price and are perfect for 18x18 pillow covers. They are fluffy and firm once shaken, but may be too flat for larger pillow cases. Be cautious with dryer use and note that they are not hefty enough for anything more than affordable throw pillows.
Pros
  • Soft and comfortable
  • Plush and adds great structure
  • Washable and dryable
  • Good quality
  • Fluffs up quickly in the dryer
Cons
  • Not as full as expected
  • Smells unusual
Bottom Line
These feather pillows are a good option for decoration and provide some support, but may not be as full as expected and have an unusual smell. They are washable and dryable, and fluff up quickly in the dryer. However, they may go flat easily and have a slightly small size for the case.
Please add more products to compare
You can compare up to four products at once
{{compareData.brand}}