10Best.Guide

Ponytail Holders

Top Picks

Last Updated: May, 2023
Pros
  • Variety of colors
  • Comfortable to wear on wrist
  • Sturdy
  • Holds thick hair up well
  • Durable
Cons
  • Glitter/metallic ones are harsher on hair
  • Don't last as long as some would like
Bottom Line
These hair ties are a great value and come in a variety of colors. They are comfortable to wear on the wrist and hold thick hair up well. They are durable and have a good stretch, but may not last as long as some would like. The glitter/metallic ones are harsher on hair and they may eat hair more than regular ones. Overall, they are a great choice for those looking for a soft, gentle hair tie that is also cute on the wrist.
Pros
  • Durable for thick hair
  • Holds tight for sports and activities
  • Good for course and curly hair
  • Never breaks or pulls
  • Holds ponytails in place for working out
Cons
  • Loses elasticity quickly
  • Glue separates after multiple uses
Bottom Line
These hair ties are great for thick, curly, and course hair, and hold up well during sports and activities. However, they may lose elasticity quickly and snap or stretch out after multiple uses.
Pros
  • Comes in a variety of colors.
  • Soft and gentle on hair.
  • Holds up thick and long hair.
  • Durable and long-lasting.
  • Cute and fluffy.
Cons
  • Some scrunchies lack stretch.
  • Satin fabric slips down hair.
Bottom Line
This product offers a wide range of colors and soft, durable scrunchies that are great for holding up thick and long hair. However, some scrunchies lack stretch, slip down hair, feel cheap, and break easily.
Pros
  • Large quantity for the price
  • Good for thick hair
  • Strong and durable
  • Comfortable to wear
  • Nice stretch and hold
Cons
  • Inconsistent quality
  • Easily stretch out of shape
Bottom Line
These hair ties are a great value for the price and work well for those with thick hair. While they may not last as long as other hair ties, the large quantity in the package makes up for it. However, the quality can be inconsistent and the packaging could be improved.
Pros
  • Good quality and work well on fine hair
  • Convenient resealable bag
  • Soft and stretchy fabric
  • Hold hair well without being too tight
  • Suitable for thin hair and toddlers
Cons
  • Stretch out easily
  • Not suitable for thick or curly hair
Bottom Line
These hair ties are a good option for those with fine or thin hair, toddlers, and those who want a soft and comfortable option that won't pull or damage hair. However, they may not be suitable for those with thick or curly hair, and they may stretch out or pill after a few uses.

The Ultimate Buying Guide for Ponytail Holders: Types, Key Considerations, Features, Prices, and Tips

Overview

Ponytail holders are essential hair accessories that can help you achieve a variety of hairstyles, from a simple ponytail to a fancy updo. With so many types, materials, designs, and sizes available, choosing the right ponytail holder can be overwhelming. That's why we've created this buying guide to help you navigate the options and find the best ponytail holder for your needs.

Types

1. Hair Ties: These are the most common type of ponytail holders, made of elastic material that stretches to hold your hair in place. They come in different thicknesses, colors, and designs, and are suitable for most hair types.

2. Scrunchies: These are fabric-covered hair ties that add volume and texture to your ponytail. They are gentle on your hair and come in various colors, patterns, and materials, from velvet to silk.

3. Ribbon Hair Ties: These are ponytail holders made of ribbon or fabric that tie around your hair, creating a cute and feminine look. They are ideal for special occasions or when you want to add a pop of color to your hair.

4. Bungee Hair Ties: These are elastic cords with hooks on both ends that wrap around your hair and secure it tightly. They are perfect for thick or heavy hair that needs extra hold.

Key Considerations

1. Hair Type: Consider your hair texture, thickness, length, and color when choosing a ponytail holder. Some types of ponytail holders may not work well with certain hair types, such as fine or curly hair.

2. Comfort: Look for ponytail holders that are comfortable to wear and don't pull or tug your hair. Avoid ponytail holders with metal parts or sharp edges that can damage your hair.

3. Durability: Choose ponytail holders that are durable and can withstand frequent use. Look for high-quality materials and well-made designs that won't break or stretch out easily.

4. Style: Consider the occasion and your personal style when choosing a ponytail holder. Some types of ponytail holders are more suitable for casual or formal settings, while others are more trendy or playful.

Features

1. Material: Ponytail holders can be made of various materials, such as elastic, fabric, ribbon, metal, plastic, or silicone. Each material has its own advantages and disadvantages, so choose the one that works best for your hair type and needs.

2. Design: Ponytail holders come in different designs, from plain and simple to embellished and decorative. Choose a design that matches your style and personality.

3. Size: Ponytail holders come in different sizes, from small and discreet to large and statement-making. Consider the size of your hair and the look you want to achieve when choosing a size.

4. Grip: Ponytail holders can have different levels of grip, from loose and gentle to tight and secure. Choose a grip that holds your hair in place without causing discomfort or damage.

Prices

Ponytail holders can range in price from a few cents to several dollars, depending on the type, material, design, and brand. Hair ties and scrunchies are usually the most affordable options, while bungee hair ties and ribbon hair ties can be more expensive. You can find ponytail holders at drugstores, supermarkets, beauty supply stores, and online retailers.

Tips

1. Use a detangler or hair oil to make it easier to put your hair up.

2. Don't tie your hair too tightly, as it can cause breakage and damage.

3. Change your ponytail holder frequently to avoid stretching out or damaging your hair.

4. Experiment with different types of ponytail holders to find the one that works best for your hair type and style.

FAQs

Q: Can ponytail holders cause hair breakage?

A: Yes, if you tie your hair too tightly or use a ponytail holder with metal parts or sharp edges, it can cause breakage and damage to your hair.

Q: Can ponytail holders be reused?

A: Yes, most ponytail holders can be reused multiple times, but it's important to change them frequently to avoid stretching out or damaging your hair.

Q: Are scrunchies better for your hair than hair ties?

A: Yes, scrunchies are gentler on your hair than hair ties, as they don't pull or tug your hair. They are also less likely to cause breakage or damage.

Q: What is the best ponytail holder for thick hair?

A: Bungee hair ties are the best ponytail holders for thick hair, as they provide extra hold and can wrap around multiple times.

Q: Can ponytail holders be worn with different hairstyles?

A: Yes, ponytail holders can be worn with a variety of hairstyles, from a simple ponytail to a messy bun or a half-up, half-down style.

Runner-Ups

Pros
  • Soft and gentle on hair
  • Good for thick and fine hair
  • Comes in large quantity
  • Reusable
  • Good for preventing breakage
Cons
  • Quality not as good as more expensive options
  • Some may have a strong smell
Bottom Line
These hair ties are a good value for those looking for a large quantity of soft and gentle hair ties that are good for preventing breakage. However, they may not be the best quality and may have a strong smell. They also may be too small for some hair types.
Pros
  • Large pack size
  • Holds up well
  • Good for fine hair
  • Neutral colors
  • Good for holding hair while washing face
Cons
  • Too thin for some hair types
  • Too small for some wrist sizes
Bottom Line
These Goody hair ties are a good option for those with fine or thin hair, and come in a large pack with neutral colors. However, they may be too thin or small for some hair types and wrist sizes, and have been reported to have a chemical smell.
Pros
  • Good for thick hair
  • Durable and strong
  • Stretchy but not too much
  • Comes in multiple colors
  • Doesn't break easily
Cons
  • Loose threads come off easily
  • Frays after a lot of use
Bottom Line
These hair ties are great for those with thick hair and are durable and strong. They come in multiple colors and a large pack, but may not be suitable for those with fine hair. Be aware that loose threads may come off easily and they may fray after a lot of use.
Pros
  • Firm and thick
  • High quality
  • Do not dent hair
  • Non-slip
  • Easy to use
Cons
  • Stretch out easily
  • Hard to take out of hair
Bottom Line
These hair ties are high quality, non-slip, and prevent hair breakage. They are suitable for thick and long hair, and do not leave a bad hair tie mark. However, they may stretch out easily and some may break easily.
Pros
  • Super thick and durable.
  • Enough stretch to go in easily.
  • Better hold and last all day.
  • Variety of colors.
  • Best band to hold dreadlock extensions.
Cons
  • Not work well for baby's hair.
  • Cheap quality and snap easily.
Bottom Line
These super thick and durable hair bands are perfect for adults and older kids. They have enough stretch to go in easily and last all day. The variety of colors and great color collection make them perfect for decorating hair. However, they are not suitable for baby's hair and have some quality issues.
Please add more products to compare
You can compare up to four products at once
{{compareData.brand}}