10Best.Guide

Seedling Starter Trays

Top Picks

Last Updated: October, 2023
Pros
  • Durable enough to be reused
  • Easy to push dirt pods out from the bottom
  • Cost-effective solution for reusing seed trays
  • Good for starting small plug transplants
  • Comes with plant labels
Cons
  • Smaller than expected
  • Difficult to remove root/rootball from cells
Bottom Line
These trays are a cost-effective option for starting small plug transplants and are durable enough to be reused. However, they may be too small for larger plants and may not hold up well in hot or dry climates.
Pros
  • Sturdy and durable for indoor seed starting.
  • Holds a good amount of small 6-packs.
  • Works fine as a stationary water reservoir.
  • Suitable for starting a microgreens business.
  • Decent size and lip for easy handling.
Cons
  • Wimpy and not easy to carry when full.
  • Flimsy and not suitable for carrying with water.
Bottom Line
These trays are suitable for indoor seed starting and stationary use as a water reservoir. They are sturdy enough for starting a microgreens business but may not be the most durable option. Be cautious of their flimsiness and consider the price before purchasing.
Pros
  • Vented tops
  • Good value
  • Sturdy and reusable
  • Perfect size cells for starting seeds
  • Retains moisture well
Cons
  • Flimsy without tray
  • Lids do not click securely
Bottom Line
These seed trays are a good value for the price and come with helpful tools. They are sturdy and reusable, but require careful handling and are not suitable for moving around. The plastic is thin and flimsy without the tray, and the bottom base tray is not sturdy enough. However, they are well made of durable materials and retain moisture well.
Pros
  • Good price for 10 mini greenhouses
  • Vent at the top prevents moisture buildup and provides fresh air
  • Sturdy insert tray
  • Humidity control works well
  • Easy to remove seedlings from trays
Cons
  • Flimsy and tops don't lock into trays
  • Lids don't fit tightly and slide off easily
Bottom Line
These mini greenhouses are a good value for the price and have some useful features like adjustable vents and good drainage. However, they are flimsy and the lids don't fit tightly, which can be problematic when moving them. Overall, they are a decent option for starting seedlings indoors.
Pros
  • Sturdy and spacious
  • Good size cells
  • Affordable
  • Large enough to keep seedlings in longer
  • Fast delivery
Cons
  • Flimsy and easily damaged
  • Thin plastic and prone to cracking
Bottom Line
These seedling trays are affordable and have good-sized cells, making them suitable for starting plants. However, they are flimsy and prone to damage, and the plastic is thin and can crack easily. They may not be as sturdy as expected, but they are still a decent option for the price.

The Ultimate Buying Guide for Seedling Starter Trays

Overview

Starting your own seeds is an exciting and cost-effective way to kickstart your gardening journey. To ensure successful germination and healthy seedlings, investing in quality seedling starter trays is crucial. This buying guide will walk you through the different types of seedling trays, key considerations to keep in mind, essential features to look for, pricing ranges, helpful tips, and frequently asked questions.

Types

1. Plastic Seedling Trays: These are the most common and affordable option, typically made of durable plastic and available in various sizes and cell configurations.

2. Biodegradable Seedling Trays: Environmentally-friendly alternatives made from materials like peat, coconut coir, or paper pulp that can be planted directly into the soil.

3. Seedling Trays with Domes: These trays come with transparent domes that create a mini greenhouse effect, providing optimal humidity and temperature for seed germination.

4. Seedling Trays with Drainage Holes: Essential for preventing waterlogging and ensuring proper drainage, these trays are ideal for gardeners who tend to overwater.

5. Adjustable Vent Seedling Trays: Designed with adjustable vents or humidity control mechanisms, these trays allow you to fine-tune the environment for your seedlings.

6. Hydroponic Seedling Trays: Specifically designed for hydroponic systems, these trays provide the necessary support and aeration for water-based seedling growth.

Key Considerations

1. Tray Size and Capacity

2. Cell Configuration

3. Material Durability and Reusability

4. Drainage System

5. Compatibility with Heat Mats or Grow Lights

6. Stackability and Space Efficiency

Features

1. Sturdy Construction: Look for trays made from durable materials to ensure longevity.

2. Clear Lids or Domes: Transparent covers allow for easy monitoring of seedling growth.

3. Cell Depth and Spacing: Optimal cell depth and spacing promote healthy root development and prevent overcrowding.

4. Labels and Markings: Pre-marked trays or labels help keep track of different plant varieties.

5. Easy-to-Clean: Trays with smooth surfaces and detachable parts simplify cleaning and sanitization.

Prices

Seedling starter tray prices can vary depending on the type, size, and quality. Plastic trays are generally more affordable, ranging from $5 to $20, while biodegradable or specialized trays may cost between $10 and $30.

Tips

1. Use a sterile seed starting mix to prevent diseases and promote healthy seedlings.

2. Consider using bottom-watering techniques to prevent disturbing delicate seedlings.

3. Label your trays to keep track of different plant varieties and sowing dates.

4. Gradually acclimate seedlings to outdoor conditions before transplanting them into the garden.

5. Clean and sanitize trays between uses to prevent the spread of diseases.

FAQs

Q: Can I reuse seedling starter trays?

Q: How many cells should a seedling tray have?

Q: Can I use seedling trays without drainage holes?

Q: Are biodegradable seedling trays better for the environment?

Q: Can I use seedling trays for hydroponics?

A: Conclusion:

Choosing the right seedling starter tray is essential for successful seed germination and healthy plant growth. Consider the types, key considerations, features, and pricing options outlined in this buying guide to find the perfect tray for your seed starting needs. With the right tray, you'll be on your way to nurturing vibrant and thriving seedlings for your garden.

Runner-Ups

Pros
  • Excellent quality and sturdy.
  • Stackable for convenient storage.
  • Perfect size for specific needs.
  • Well-made and durable.
  • Fits nicely on shelves.
Cons
  • Pricey.
  • Size may not be as expected.
Bottom Line
The Mr. Pen Plastic Growing Trays are excellent quality and sturdy trays that are stackable and convenient for storage. They come in a perfect size for specific needs and are well-made and durable. However, they may be a bit pricey and some trays may have issues such as holes or leaks. The plastic is thin and flimsy, and the ridged bottoms may cause plants to wobble or tip over. Additionally, the packaging with tape and stickers can leave a sticky residue. Overall, they serve their purpose well and are easy to clean.
Pros
  • Sturdy and thick plastic
  • Tall covers for high humidity
  • Comes with little tools
  • Numerous containers
  • Good quality and reusable
Cons
  • Small individual cells
  • Flimsy and not steady
Bottom Line
These seed trays are a great value for the price and come with useful tools. However, they have some flaws such as small cells, flimsy lids, and mold issues. Buyers should be aware of the smaller size and consider using rubber bands to secure the lids.
Pros
  • Durable and thick plastic
  • Good quality compared to other greenhouses
  • Reusable
  • Good drainage and ventilation
  • Clear bottom for root view
Cons
  • Difficult to remove seedlings once rooted
  • Lids don't snap on securely
Bottom Line
These seedling trays offer good value for the price, with durable plastic, good drainage and ventilation, and the ability to reuse them. However, they may have some issues with lid fit, difficulty in removing seedlings, and flimsy construction.
Pros
  • Keeps humidity inside the container.
  • Easy to use and comes with tags.
  • Clear seed tray allows monitoring of roots.
  • Cheap and takes up little room.
  • Retains moisture and can be used over and over.
Cons
  • Plants are difficult to remove from the plastic.
  • Lids do not close or seal tight.
Bottom Line
This seed starter is an affordable and easy-to-use option for starting seeds indoors. It retains moisture well and comes with tags for labeling. However, the plastic layers are thin and the lids do not seal tightly. The small size may not be suitable for keeping seedlings until transplanting.
Pros
  • Great alternative to plastic
  • Well constructed
  • Fast shipping
  • Sturdy and the right size
  • Kit includes everything for transplanting seedlings
Cons
  • Bottom fell out and started getting moldy after a couple of days
  • Deteriorated and grew mold after a couple of months
Bottom Line
These seedling trays are a great alternative to plastic, well constructed, and come with everything needed for transplanting. However, they have issues with durability and mold growth, and may not be suitable for use with a heating mat.
Please add more products to compare
You can compare up to four products at once
{{compareData.brand}}