10Best.Guide

Smoker

Top Picks

Last Updated: April, 2023
Pros
  • Easy to use and holds temps well.
  • Great for smoking ribs, brisket, and turkey.
  • Makes better tasting BBQ than any restaurant.
  • Quick cooking time.
  • Good for smoking beef short ribs.
Cons
  • Difficulty in searing steaks.
  • Traeger support is not efficient.
Bottom Line
The Traeger grill is a great investment for those who love to grill, smoke, and bake. It is easy to use, holds temperatures well, and produces better tasting BBQ than most restaurants. However, some customers have experienced issues with delivery, assembly, and heating up to temperature correctly. It may also not be suitable for extreme winter conditions.
Pros
  • Can be used as a smoker and has temperature control.
  • Well-made and heavy-duty.
  • Easy to assemble.
  • Good quality and exceeded expectations.
  • Great for small groups and excellent price.
Cons
  • Paint peeling and rust issues.
  • Confusing instructions regarding usage.
Bottom Line
The Char-Griller firebox is a heavy-duty and well-made product that can be used as a smoker with temperature control. However, there are some issues with paint peeling and rust, and the instructions can be confusing. It is great for small groups and has an excellent price, but it may require additional drilling to attach to some grills. Overall, it is a good product that does its job well.
Pros
  • Runs off natural gas line
  • Good for smoking meat
  • Best smoker in its price range
  • Easy to manage temperature
  • Great smoke flavor
Cons
  • Packaging and shipping issues
  • Dents and warping in the unit
Bottom Line
The smoker works well for smoking meat and is a good option for those with a natural gas line. However, there have been some issues with packaging and shipping, as well as some limitations with temperature control and wood usage. Additional purchases may be necessary for optimal use.
Pros
  • Maintains temperature well
  • Easy to assemble
  • Accurate temperature control
  • Side wood chip dispenser is easy to use
  • Digital electric controls are convenient
Cons
  • Control panel has failed for some users
  • Wood chips do not char at low settings
Bottom Line
The Masterbuilt 40-inch digital smoker is a convenient and easy-to-use option for those looking for a set-and-forget smoking experience. However, some users have experienced durability issues with the control panel and heating element, and some units may arrive damaged due to shipping.
Pros
  • Arrived in pristine condition.
  • Assembly was straightforward.
  • Easy to maintain temperature.
  • Sturdy and well-made for the price.
  • Holds heat well.
Cons
  • Not heavy-duty compared to top models.
  • Poorly sealed.
Bottom Line
This smoker is a good option for those looking for a mid-weight smoker at an affordable price. It requires some adjustments to improve its efficiency and temperature control, but it can produce great-tasting food with proper use. However, it may not be suitable for those looking for a heavy-duty or fully automated smoker.

The Ultimate Buying Guide for Smokers: Types, Features, Prices, Tips, and FAQs

Overview

Smoking meat is an art, and having the right smoker can make all the difference. Whether you're a seasoned pitmaster or a newbie looking to up your grilling game, there are a variety of smokers on the market to choose from. In this guide, we'll walk you through the different types of smokers, key considerations when making your purchase, important features to look for, and pricing options. We'll also provide tips to help you get the most out of your smoker and answer frequently asked questions.

Types

1. Wood Smokers: These traditional smokers use logs or wood chips to create smoke and heat. They require more attention and maintenance than other types of smokers, but the flavor they produce is unmatched.

2. Charcoal Smokers: These smokers use charcoal to generate heat and smoke. They offer a classic smoky flavor and are more affordable than other types of smokers.

3. Electric Smokers: These smokers use electricity to create heat and smoke. They're easy to use and require less maintenance than other types of smokers, but some argue that they don't produce as much flavor.

4. Propane Smokers: These smokers use propane gas to generate heat and smoke. They're easy to use and maintain and offer a consistent temperature, but some argue that they don't produce as much flavor as other types of smokers.

Key Considerations

1. Size and Capacity: Consider how much food you'll be smoking at once and choose a smoker with enough space to accommodate it.

2. Temperature Control: Look for a smoker with accurate temperature control to ensure consistent cooking.

3. Ease of Use: Consider how easy the smoker is to set up, use, and clean.

4. Durability: Look for a smoker made of high-quality materials that will last for years.

5. Portability: If you plan to take your smoker on the go, consider its weight and size.

Features

1. Temperature Gauge: A built-in thermometer or temperature gauge will help you monitor the temperature of your smoker.

2. Multiple Racks: Look for a smoker with multiple racks to increase your cooking space.

3. Wood Chip Box: A wood chip box allows you to easily add wood chips to your smoker for added flavor.

4. Water Pan: A water pan helps regulate the temperature and adds moisture to your meat.

5. Side Doors: Look for a smoker with side doors for easy access to the cooking chamber.

Prices

Smokers range in price from around $100 to over $1000. Consider your budget and how frequently you plan to use your smoker when making your purchase.

Tips

1. Use high-quality wood chips for the best flavor.

2. Preheat your smoker before adding your meat.

3. Consider using a rub or marinade to add flavor to your meat.

4. Avoid opening the smoker too frequently to maintain a consistent temperature.

5. Clean your smoker after each use to prolong its lifespan.

FAQs

Q: How long does it take to smoke meat?

A: Smoking times vary depending on the type of meat and the temperature of your smoker. As a general rule, plan for around 1 hour of smoking time per pound of meat.

Q: Can I use my smoker for other types of food besides meat?

A: Yes, you can smoke vegetables, cheese, and even fruit in your smoker.

Q: Can I smoke in cold weather?

A: Yes, but you may need to adjust the cooking time and temperature to account for the colder weather.

Q: How do I clean my smoker?

A: Follow the manufacturer's instructions for cleaning your smoker, but in general, you'll want to remove any leftover ash or debris and wipe down the interior with a damp cloth.

Q: Do I need to soak my wood chips before using them?

A: It's not necessary to soak your wood chips, but some people prefer to do so to create more smoke and flavor.

Runner-Ups

Pros
  • Easy to regulate temperature
  • Sufficient rack space
  • Consistent smoke and cook
  • Good value for the price
  • Upgraded heating and chip tray
Cons
  • Door does not seal tightly
  • Thermometer isn't accurate
Bottom Line
The Masterbuilt analog electric smoker is a good starter smoker with easy temperature regulation and consistent results. However, it has some quality issues such as a poorly sealing door and inaccurate thermometer, and the wood chip box is small and difficult to access. Overall, it is a decent option for the price.
Pros
  • Good price for a beginner offset smoker.
  • Nice looking pit.
  • Stable temperature control ability.
  • Comes with a cover.
  • Can grill or smoke on it.
Cons
  • Thin metal construction.
  • Overly complicated build.
Bottom Line
This is a good beginner offset smoker for the price, but it has some issues with construction and assembly. The temperature control is a little off, but it cooks meat well and comes with a cover.
Pros
  • Vertical design takes up minimal garage space with plenty of room for cooking.
  • Nice smoker, well built from good material.
  • Solid construction and simple design.
  • Smoker is great and keeps at the temperature you want.
  • Good value for the money.
Cons
  • Temperature control is difficult due to loose tolerances in air vents and around doors.
  • Door was misaligned and needed to be fixed.
Bottom Line
This smoker is a good value for the money, but it has its limitations. It requires modifications to improve temperature control and seal off smoke leaks. The construction is solid, but the door may need to be fixed. Overall, it is a nice smoker for those on a budget.
Pros
  • Versatile - can smoke, grill, and be used for a bonfire.
  • Good price point.
  • Dual racks provide a ton of grilling surface space.
  • Assembly is not too difficult.
  • Can be used for vertical roasting.
Cons
  • Bowl for the charcoal doesn't sit on the ground and can be a little unstable.
  • Mediocre smoking performance.
Bottom Line
This smoker is a good option for beginners or infrequent smokers due to its good price point and decent performance. However, it has some stability issues and mediocre smoking performance. Assembly can be a bit tedious, but it provides a ton of grilling surface space and can be used for vertical roasting.
Pros
  • Easy assembly
  • Good for beginners
  • Great for residential use
  • Affordable price
  • Compact design
Cons
  • Poor quality construction
  • Temperature control can be difficult
Bottom Line
The Cuisinart COS-116 is an affordable and compact smoker that is great for beginners and residential use. However, it has poor quality construction, unclear instructions, and can be difficult to control the temperature.
Please add more products to compare
You can compare up to four products at once
{{compareData.brand}}