10Best.Guide

Vanilla Extract

Top Picks

Last Updated: April, 2023
Pros
  • Better priced than grocery stores and other online ordering.
  • Care and precision with which they make their vanilla is incredible.
  • Fantastic and great value.
  • Strong clean, natural vanilla flavor which holds through baking.
  • Packs much more vanilla flavor than the standard grocery store brands.
Cons
  • Lid is difficult to remove.
  • Hard to put a price on something that is quality.
Bottom Line
Nielsen-Massey is a high-quality vanilla extract that is better priced than grocery stores and other online ordering. It has a strong, clean, natural vanilla flavor that holds through baking. However, the lid is difficult to remove, and due to the shape of the bottle, it is almost impossible not to spill a single drop.
Pros
  • High quality ingredients
  • Great for baking and candy making
  • Good presentation for gifting
  • Pleasant taste and aroma
  • No artificial ingredients
Cons
  • Expensive
  • Large lid and opening can be tricky for pouring
Bottom Line
Nielsen-Massey Pure Vanilla Extract is a high-quality, natural vanilla extract that is great for baking and candy making. While it is expensive, it is worth the investment for those who value quality ingredients and taste.
Pros
  • Great vanilla flavor
  • Good value for the price
  • Watkins is a trusted brand
  • Good for baking
  • Large bottle size
Cons
  • Contains sugar and other ingredients besides vanilla extract
  • Not as potent as pure vanilla extract
Bottom Line
Watkins Vanilla Extract is a good option for those looking for a reasonably priced vanilla extract that still has good flavor. However, it does contain sugar and other ingredients, and may not be as potent as pure vanilla extract.
Pros
  • Great product for baking
  • Mild and flavorful vanilla
  • Excellent for making pure white frosting
  • No artificial colors, Non-GMO Certified, no corn syrup, gluten-free
  • Good for making coffee syrup
Cons
  • Bottle arrived with no lid
  • Artificially flavored
Bottom Line
Watkins Clear Vanilla Flavor is a great product for baking, especially for making pure white frosting. It has a mild and flavorful vanilla taste and is free from artificial colors, Non-GMO Certified, no corn syrup, and gluten-free. However, some customers received the product without a lid, and it is artificially flavored, which may not be suitable for some people.
Pros
  • Great quality for the price.
  • Tastes like vanilla ice cream.
  • Superior to standard supermarket vanilla.
  • Perfect for baking and flavoring.
  • Mellow flavor for baking.
Cons
  • Plastic bottle and questionable source.
  • Inconsistent quality.
Bottom Line
Mexican vanilla extract is a great alternative to standard supermarket vanilla, with a more flavorful taste and scent. However, buyers should be aware of the inconsistent quality and questionable source, as well as the higher cost compared to buying in Mexico.

The Ultimate Buying Guide for Vanilla Extract: How to Choose the Best One for Your Baking and Cooking Needs

Overview

Vanilla extract is a popular ingredient used in baking and cooking. It is made by steeping vanilla beans in alcohol, which extracts their flavor and aroma. With so many options available, it can be overwhelming to choose the best vanilla extract for your needs. In this guide, we will cover the different types of vanilla extract, key considerations, features, prices, tips, and FAQs to help you make an informed decision.

Types

1. Pure Vanilla Extract: Made with real vanilla beans and alcohol, pure vanilla extract is the most expensive and highest quality option. It has a rich and complex flavor and is ideal for recipes where vanilla is the star ingredient.

2. Natural Vanilla Extract: Made with real vanilla beans and a mixture of alcohol and water, natural vanilla extract is a more affordable option than pure vanilla extract. It has a similar flavor to pure vanilla extract but is slightly less intense.

3. Artificial Vanilla Extract: Made with synthetic vanillin and other artificial flavors, artificial vanilla extract is the cheapest option. It has a simpler flavor profile and is best used in recipes where vanilla is not the main flavor.

Key Considerations

1. Quality: Look for high-quality vanilla extract made with real vanilla beans for the best flavor.

2. Type: Consider the type of vanilla extract that will work best for your recipe and budget.

3. Alcohol Content: Check the alcohol content of the vanilla extract, as some recipes may require a specific percentage.

4. Brand: Choose a reputable brand with good reviews and a history of producing high-quality vanilla extract.

Features

1. Origin: Vanilla extract can be made from beans grown in different regions, such as Madagascar, Tahiti, and Mexico. Each region has a unique flavor profile.

2. Organic: Look for organic vanilla extract made with beans grown without pesticides or other harmful chemicals.

3. Gluten-Free: Check for gluten-free certification if you have a gluten allergy or intolerance.

Prices

Vanilla extract prices can vary depending on the type, quality, and brand. Pure vanilla extract is the most expensive, while artificial vanilla extract is the cheapest. Expect to pay anywhere from $5 to $50 for a bottle of vanilla extract.

Tips

1. Store vanilla extract in a cool, dark place away from heat and light to preserve its flavor.

2. Use vanilla extract sparingly, as a little goes a long way.

3. Experiment with different types and brands of vanilla extract to find your favorite.

FAQs

Q: Is vanilla extract gluten-free?

A: Answer: Most vanilla extract is gluten-free, but it's always best to check for certification to be sure.

Q: How long does vanilla extract last?

A: Answer: Vanilla extract can last for several years if stored properly in a cool, dark place.

Q: Can I use artificial vanilla extract instead of pure vanilla extract?

A: Answer: Yes, but keep in mind that the flavor will be simpler and less intense.

Q: What is the difference between natural and pure vanilla extract?

A: Answer: Natural vanilla extract is made with a mixture of alcohol and water, while pure vanilla extract is made with only alcohol and vanilla beans.

Q: Can I make my own vanilla extract?

A: Answer: Yes, you can make your own vanilla extract by steeping vanilla beans in alcohol for several weeks.

Runner-Ups

Pros
  • Good quality vanilla
  • Reasonable price
  • Certified organic
  • Comes in a dark glass bottle
  • Simply Organic Giving Fund
Cons
  • Heavy on alcohol
  • Mild flavor
Bottom Line
Simply Organic Vanilla Extract is a good quality, certified organic vanilla extract at a reasonable price. However, the heavy alcohol content and mild flavor may not be suitable for everyone, and the bottle design can be frustrating.
Pros
  • Intense flavor
  • Light, mildly sweet, almost a buttery vanilla tasting extract
  • Depth of flavor that this product adds to baked goods is excellent
  • Great quality product
  • Organic and responsibly sourced
Cons
  • Plastic bottle instead of glass
  • Some customers found it to be a bit pricey
Bottom Line
Rodelle Gourmet Pure Vanilla Extract is an intense, high-quality vanilla extract that adds depth of flavor to baked goods. It is organic and responsibly sourced, and offers great value for the price. However, some customers may find the plastic bottle and price to be a downside, and a few customers found it to have a more artificial taste.
Pros
  • Good quality vanilla
  • Reasonable price
  • Certified organic
  • Comes in a dark glass bottle
  • Potent flavor
Cons
  • Heavy on alcohol
  • Mild flavor
Bottom Line
Simply Organic Vanilla Extract is a good quality, certified organic product that comes in a dark glass bottle. It has a potent flavor and can be used in various baked goods. However, it is heavy on alcohol, has a mild flavor, and the bottle design can be frustrating.
Pros
  • Generously sized bottle
  • Affordable
  • Suitable for everyday use
  • Good for general baking use
  • Tight inner seal and flip-top pouring cap
Cons
  • Messy pouring
  • More alcohol than other vanilla extracts
Bottom Line
Happy Belly Pure Vanilla Extract is an affordable and convenient option for everyday baking needs, but may not be suitable for more specialized or high-end recipes due to its weaker taste and higher alcohol content.
Pros
  • Great taste
  • Easy pour container
  • Real vanilla flavor
  • Reliable company
  • Good value
Cons
  • Small bottle
  • Cap liner doesn't stay in place
Bottom Line
McCormick's Pure Vanilla Extract is a reliable and good value product with a great taste, but the small bottle size, cap liner issue, and weak flavor may be a concern for some buyers.
Please add more products to compare
You can compare up to four products at once
{{compareData.brand}}