10Best.Guide

Black Eye Shadow

Top Picks

Last Updated: June, 2023
Pros
  • Beautiful linen color
  • Great alternative to black eyeliner
  • Khaki Camo shade brings out green eyes
  • Sage color is stunning and lasts well
  • Good highlight for eyes
Cons
  • Arrived broken and crumbly
  • Specks of color fall onto other areas
Bottom Line
This product has beautiful shades that are great for highlighting and bringing out eye colors. However, there are issues with packaging and color accuracy that may be a concern for some buyers.
Pros
  • Great range of shades
  • Nice color payout
  • Smooth application
  • Highly pigmented
  • Terrific price
Cons
  • Talc ingredient
  • Fallout, especially with black
Bottom Line
This palette is a good option for those on a budget who want a range of shades, but it has some drawbacks such as fallout and creasing. The talc ingredient may also be a concern for some.
Pros
  • Easy to apply and blend
  • Long-lasting
  • Great texture
  • Suitable for all skin types
  • Smooth application
Cons
  • Not highly pigmented
  • May irritate eyes
Bottom Line
This eyeshadow is easy to apply, long-lasting, and has a great texture. It is suitable for all skin types and comes in a variety of colors, including shimmery shades that add subtle light to lids. However, it may not be highly pigmented, may irritate eyes, and is pricey. The packaging is not color-coded, making it difficult to identify colors in a makeup drawer.
Pros
  • Highly pigmented shades
  • Great color payoff
  • Easy to blend
  • Matte white shade available
  • Nice packaging
Cons
  • Poor quality with fallout
  • Not long-lasting
Bottom Line
This eyeshadow palette has highly pigmented shades that are great for creating Smokey eye looks. However, it has poor quality with fallout and is not long-lasting. It also has limited matte shades.
Pros
  • Good color palette for the price.
  • Cruelty-free and adorably-packaged.
  • True red matte and shimmer shades.
  • Great color payout and smooth shimmers.
  • Bright and pigmented red shades.
Cons
  • Poor packaging for shipping, resulting in damaged palettes.
  • No green palette shade names mentioned.
Bottom Line
This color palette is a great value for the price, with a mix of shimmers and mattes that are pigmented and blendable. However, the packaging for shipping needs improvement, and the shade range is limited. Overall, a good option for those looking for a budget-friendly palette with some standout shades.

The Ultimate Buying Guide for Black Eye Shadow: Tips, Types, Features and Prices

Overview

Black eye shadow is a versatile makeup product that can be used to create a variety of looks, from a classic smokey eye to a more dramatic and edgy look. However, with so many different types and brands of black eye shadow available, it can be challenging to find the perfect product that meets your needs. In this buying guide, we'll cover everything you need to know to choose the right black eye shadow for you.

Types

- Matte black eye shadow: This type of eye shadow has a flat, non-shimmery finish, making it perfect for creating a classic smokey eye.

- Shimmer black eye shadow: This type of eye shadow has a subtle sparkle or shine, making it ideal for adding dimension to your eye makeup.

- Cream black eye shadow: This type of eye shadow has a creamy texture and is easy to blend, making it perfect for creating a soft, smudged look.

- Powder black eye shadow: This type of eye shadow is easy to apply and blend, making it a popular choice for everyday use.

Key Considerations

- Skin tone: Consider your skin tone when choosing a black eye shadow. If you have fair skin, a lighter black shade may work better for you, while those with darker skin tones may prefer a deeper, richer black.

- Eye shape: The shape of your eyes can also impact the type of black eye shadow you choose. For example, if you have hooded eyes, you may want to avoid using too much shimmer, as it can make your eyes appear more sunken.

- Occasion: Consider the occasion when choosing a black eye shadow. A matte black eye shadow is perfect for a daytime look, while a shimmer black eye shadow is ideal for a night out.

Features

- Long-lasting: Look for a black eye shadow that is long-lasting and won't smudge or fade throughout the day or night.

- Cruelty-free and vegan: If you're looking for an ethical and sustainable option, choose a black eye shadow that is cruelty-free and vegan.

- Natural ingredients: Consider choosing a black eye shadow that contains natural ingredients, such as mineral pigments, to avoid harsh chemicals.

Prices

- Budget: $5-$10

- Mid-range: $10-$25

- High-end: $25-$50+

Tips

- Use a primer: To ensure your black eye shadow stays in place all day or night, use a primer before applying your eye makeup.

- Blend well: Whether you're using a matte or shimmer black eye shadow, be sure to blend it well to avoid any harsh lines or uneven application.

- Experiment with different looks: Don't be afraid to experiment with different looks using your black eye shadow. Try a classic smokey eye, a bold winged liner, or a subtle smudged look.

FAQs

Q: Can black eye shadow be used as eyeliner?

A: Yes, black eye shadow can be used as eyeliner by applying it with a small brush.

Q: How do I choose the right black eye shadow for my skin tone?

A: Consider your skin tone when choosing a black eye shadow. If you have fair skin, a lighter black shade may work better for you, while those with darker skin tones may prefer a deeper, richer black.

Q: How do I make my black eye shadow last longer?

A: Use a primer before applying your eye makeup to help your black eye shadow last longer. You can also use a setting spray to keep your makeup in place throughout the day or night.

Q: What is the best way to apply black eye shadow?

A: Use a small brush to apply your black eye shadow, starting at the outer corner of your eye and working your way in. Be sure to blend well to avoid any harsh lines or uneven application.

Runner-Ups

Pros
  • Affordable price
  • Smooth application
  • Versatile shades
  • Long-lasting
  • Pigmented color
Cons
  • Fragile packaging
  • Allergic reactions
Bottom Line
The Lady Gaga Glam Attack Liquid Eyeshadow line offers affordable, pigmented, and versatile shades with a smooth application and shimmer effect. However, the packaging is fragile, and some users experienced allergic reactions. The eyeshadow can be difficult to blend and may require a black base for better pigmentation. It also has a tendency to rub off and migrate to creases.
Pros
  • Nice color combinations
  • Goes on smooth and blends nicely
  • True shades of black to white silver
  • Secure packaging
Cons
  • Poor quality, breaks easily
  • Eyeshadow not usable due to breakage
Bottom Line
This eyeshadow palette has nice color combinations and goes on smoothly, but the quality is poor and it breaks easily. The black is not very opaque and the glitters are not consistent in size. However, it is packaged securely and may be suitable for on-the-go goth looks.
Pros
  • Goes on nicely
  • Highly pigmented
  • Good value for the price
  • Matches black eyeshadow well
  • Perfect for dark eye shadow looks
Cons
  • Prone to fallout
  • Doesn't spread smoothly
Bottom Line
This eyeshadow is highly pigmented and goes on nicely, making it perfect for dark eye shadow looks. However, it requires blending and building, and is prone to fallout. It is a decent value for the price, but not suitable for on-the-go touch-ups.
Pros
  • Nice matte finish
  • Highly pigmented
  • Smooth and even application
  • Affordable price
  • Generous size
Cons
  • Color not as advertised
  • Flakes off onto face
Bottom Line
The Anastasia eyeshadows are highly pigmented, smooth, and affordable, but some colors may not match the advertised shade and may flake off onto the face. Be aware that some people may have an allergic reaction to the product. The eyeshadows come in a generous size and are easy to blend, making them a good choice for those looking to replace used products or add to their collection.
Pros
  • Great value for the price.
  • Lovely neutral color.
  • Very pigmented.
  • Perfect base shade.
  • Soft and easy to work with.
Cons
  • Very small container.
  • Poor packaging.
Bottom Line
This eyeshadow is a great value for the price, with lovely neutral colors that are very pigmented and long-lasting. However, the packaging is small and fragile, and the color may not be as advertised.
Please add more products to compare
You can compare up to four products at once
{{compareData.brand}}