10Best.Guide

Eyeliner Pencil

Top Picks

Last Updated: April, 2023
Pros
  • Smooth and pigmented consistency
  • Stays put all day
  • Easy to apply
  • Super pigmented formula
  • Beautiful metallic color
Cons
  • Smudges after several hours
  • Difficult to take off
Bottom Line
This NYX eyeliner has a smooth and pigmented consistency that stays put all day. It's easy to apply and has a super pigmented formula with beautiful metallic colors. However, it can smudge after several hours and is difficult to take off. It also smears under bottom lashes and doesn't stay on the waterline.
Pros
  • Smooth and pigmented consistency.
  • Easy to apply with one stroke.
  • Stays on all day.
  • Smooth and creamy formula.
  • Bold and metallic color.
Cons
  • Smudges easily.
  • Difficult to take off.
Bottom Line
This NYX eyeliner has a smooth and pigmented consistency that is easy to apply with one stroke. It stays on all day and has a smooth and creamy formula that does not pull or tear at aging skin. However, it smudges easily and is difficult to take off. It also smears under bottom lashes and does not stay on the waterline.
Pros
  • Goes on easy
  • Retractable
  • Suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
  • Good for smoky look
  • Stays on all day
Cons
  • Not smudge proof
  • Wears off after about 5 hours
Bottom Line
Maybelline Unstoppable eyeliner is an affordable and easy-to-use eyeliner that is suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. While it is not completely smudge proof, it is good for creating a smoky look and stays on all day. However, it may wear off after a few hours and has some application issues. Overall, it is a good option for those looking for an affordable and reliable eyeliner.
Pros
  • Inexpensive
  • Goes on smoothly
  • Waterproof
  • Unique colors available
  • Lasts all day
Cons
  • Smudges easily
  • Difficult to remove
Bottom Line
This eyeliner is a good option for those on a budget who want a smooth, long-lasting, and unique color eyeliner. However, it may smudge easily and be difficult to remove, and the tip can break off easily while sharpening.
Pros
  • Intense color payoff
  • Smooth and easy to apply
  • Precise lines with felt tip applicator
  • Lasts all day without smudging or fading
  • Natural looking black/brown color
Cons
  • Some difficulty with sharpening
  • Patchy application at times
Bottom Line
The L'Oreal Paris Makeup Infallible Eyeliner is a convenient and easy-to-use twist-up pencil with a built-in sharpener. It provides intense color payoff and precise lines with a smooth and easy application. While it may have some difficulty with sharpening and patchy application at times, it is long-lasting and doesn't transfer easily.

The Ultimate Buying Guide for Eyeliner Pencil: Types, Key Considerations, Features, Prices, Tips, and FAQs

Overview

Eyeliner pencil is a versatile and essential makeup tool that can help you achieve a wide range of looks, from subtle and natural to bold and dramatic. However, with so many types, brands, and features available, choosing the right eyeliner pencil can be overwhelming. In this buying guide, we'll help you navigate the world of eyeliner pencils by discussing the different types, key considerations, features, prices, tips, and FAQs.

Types

- Waterproof eyeliner pencil: Ideal for humid or rainy weather, swimming, or long-lasting wear.

- Smudge-proof eyeliner pencil: Perfect for those who tend to rub their eyes or have oily eyelids.

- Long-lasting eyeliner pencil: Great for all-day wear or special occasions.

- Black eyeliner pencil: Classic and versatile, suitable for most skin tones and eye colors.

- Brown eyeliner pencil: A softer and more natural alternative to black, ideal for light or fair skin tones and blue or green eyes.

- Colored eyeliner pencil: Adds a pop of color and can complement or contrast with your eye color or outfit.

- Retractable eyeliner pencil: Convenient and mess-free, no need to sharpen.

- Twist-up eyeliner pencil: Similar to retractable, but requires twisting instead of clicking.

- Sharpenable eyeliner pencil: Allows for precise and sharp lines, but requires a sharpener.

- Gel eyeliner pencil: Creamy and pigmented, ideal for bold and dramatic looks or tightlining.

- Creamy eyeliner pencil: Soft and blendable, perfect for smoky and smudged looks.

- Matte eyeliner pencil: Provides a flat and non-shiny finish, suitable for natural or subtle looks.

- Shimmer eyeliner pencil: Contains glitter or shimmer particles, great for festive or glamorous looks.

- Metallic eyeliner pencil: Has a metallic or foil finish, adds a futuristic or edgy touch.

- Drugstore eyeliner pencil: Affordable and accessible, available in most drugstores and supermarkets.

- High-end eyeliner pencil: Expensive and luxurious, often with premium ingredients and packaging.

- Cruelty-free eyeliner pencil: Not tested on animals, suitable for ethical and animal-friendly consumers.

- Vegan eyeliner pencil: Free of animal-derived ingredients, suitable for vegans and vegetarians.

- Hypoallergenic eyeliner pencil: Gentle and non-irritating, suitable for sensitive or allergy-prone skin.

- Easy-to-apply eyeliner pencil: User-friendly and beginner-friendly, suitable for those who are new to makeup.

- Professional-grade eyeliner pencil: High-quality and precise, suitable for makeup artists or advanced users.

- Smoky eye eyeliner pencil: Ideal for creating a smoky eye look, usually comes with a smudger or brush.

- Winged eyeliner pencil: Has a pointed and angled tip, perfect for creating a winged or cat eye look.

- Tightline eyeliner pencil: Designed for tightlining or lining the upper waterline, creates a fuller and more defined lash line.

- Waterline eyeliner pencil: Safe and suitable for lining the lower waterline, brightens and enlarges the eyes.

- Natural eyeliner pencil: Made with natural and organic ingredients, suitable for eco-conscious and health-conscious consumers.

- Bold eyeliner pencil: Provides a bold and intense color payoff, suitable for those who want to make a statement.

- Subtle eyeliner pencil: Gives a subtle and understated effect, suitable for those who prefer a natural or minimalist look.

Key Considerations

- Skin type: Consider your skin type when choosing an eyeliner pencil, as some formulas may be too drying or too oily for certain skin types.

- Eye shape: Take into account your eye shape and size when selecting an eyeliner pencil, as some types may be more flattering or easier to use for your eye shape.

- Eye color: Consider your eye color when choosing a colored eyeliner pencil, as some shades may enhance or clash with your natural eye color.

- Occasion: Think about the occasion or event you will be attending when selecting an eyeliner pencil, as some types may be more appropriate or suitable for certain occasions.

- Budget: Determine your budget before shopping for an eyeliner pencil, as prices can vary widely depending on the brand, type, and quality of the product.

Features

- Pigmentation: Look for an eyeliner pencil with rich and intense pigmentation, as this will ensure a bold and long-lasting color payoff.

- Texture: Consider the texture of the eyeliner pencil, as some formulas may be too hard, too soft, too creamy, or too dry for your liking.

- Durability: Choose an eyeliner pencil that is durable and long-lasting, especially if you need it to stay put for hours or in challenging conditions.

- Ease of use: Look for an eyeliner pencil that is easy to use and apply, especially if you are a beginner or have limited time and skills.

- Smudge-proof: Consider whether the eyeliner pencil is smudge-proof or not, as this will affect its staying power and overall appearance.

- Waterproof: Look for an eyeliner pencil that is waterproof if you need it to withstand water, sweat, or humidity.

- Packaging: Consider the packaging of the eyeliner pencil, as some may come with additional features such as a built-in sharpener, a smudger, or a brush.

Prices

- Drugstore eyeliner pencils: $5-$15

- High-end eyeliner pencils: $20-$50

- Professional-grade eyeliner pencils: $50-$100

Tips

- Always start with a clean and dry eyelid to ensure the eyeliner pencil adheres properly.

- Use a primer or a setting spray to prolong the wear time of your eyeliner pencil.

- Experiment with different types and colors of eyeliner pencil to find your perfect match.

- Use a sharpener or a tissue to sharpen your eyeliner pencil if it becomes dull or blunt.

- Apply your eyeliner pencil in short and precise strokes to achieve a clean and sharp line.

- Use a smudger or a brush to blend and soften your eyeliner pencil for a smoky or smudged effect.

- Remove your eyeliner pencil with a gentle and effective makeup remover to avoid tugging or rubbing your eyes.

FAQs

Q: Can I use eyeliner pencil on my waterline?

A: Yes, but make sure to choose a safe and suitable formula that won't irritate or harm your eyes.

Q: How do I sharpen my eyeliner pencil?

A: Use a sharpener that is specifically designed for eyeliner pencils, and make sure to clean it regularly to avoid contamination.

Q: How do I prevent my eyeliner pencil from smudging?

A: Use a smudge-proof or waterproof formula, and set it with a powder or a setting spray.

Q: Can I use eyeliner pencil for tightlining?

A: Yes, but make sure to choose a formula that is safe and suitable for that purpose, and apply it carefully to avoid poking or hurting your eyes.

Q: How do I remove my eyeliner pencil?

A: Use a gentle and effective makeup remover that is suitable for your skin type and eye area, and avoid rubbing or tugging your eyes.

Runner-Ups

Pros
  • Intense color payoff
  • Smooth and easy to apply
  • Precise lines with felt tip applicator
  • Impressive staying power
  • Good for quick and easy application
Cons
  • Applies irregularly
  • Sometimes patchy
Bottom Line
The L'Oreal Paris Infallible Grip Precision Felt Liquid Eyeliner is a good choice for those who want intense color payoff and precise lines. However, it can be difficult to sharpen and the tip can break off easily. It is not very smudge-proof and may transfer to the undereye or lower eyelid.
Pros
  • Smooth and pigmented consistency
  • Long-lasting in the waterline
  • Twist-up design for easy use on the go
  • Good for sensitive eyes
  • Comes in a variety of colors
Cons
  • Smudges easily
  • Not completely waterproof
Bottom Line
The NYX eyeliner is a good option for those looking for a smooth and pigmented eyeliner that is easy to use on the go. However, it may smudge easily and is not completely waterproof. It comes in a variety of colors and is suitable for sensitive eyes.
Pros
  • Inexpensive
  • Self-sharpening
  • Glides on smoothly
  • Lasts all day
  • Good value for money
Cons
  • Smudges easily
  • Not completely smudgeproof or waterproof
Bottom Line
This Revlon eyeliner is a good value for money and comes in unique shades. It glides on smoothly and lasts all day, but may smudge easily and be difficult to remove. It is not completely smudgeproof or waterproof and may break easily while sharpening.
Pros
  • Goes on smoothly and evenly
  • Long-lasting
  • Pigmented and bold colors
  • No need to sharpen
  • Easy to apply
Cons
  • Smudges easily
  • Difficult to remove
Bottom Line
This eyeliner is a good choice for those who want a smooth and pigmented pencil liner that lasts all day. However, it may smudge easily and be difficult to remove, and is not suitable for use on the waterline or bottom lid.
Pros
  • Perfect darkness
  • Long-lasting
  • Does not smudge
  • Easy to apply and blend
  • Sharpenable
Cons
  • Not long-lasting on oily eyelids
  • Limited color options
Bottom Line
Covergirl Perfect Blend Eyeliner is an affordable and versatile product that can be used as an eyeliner or eyebrow pencil. It has good longevity and is easy to apply and blend. However, it may not be suitable for oily eyelids and has limited color options.
Please add more products to compare
You can compare up to four products at once
{{compareData.brand}}