10Best.Guide

Matte Eye Shadow

Top Picks

Last Updated: September, 2023
Pros
  • Desirable make-up brand
  • Well-packaged and fresh
  • Versatile color selection
  • Gorgeous and natural colors
  • Highly pigmented
Cons
  • Useless first color
  • Very dark last color
Bottom Line
Urban Decay Naked2 Basics Eyeshadow Palette is a versatile and highly pigmented all-matte neutral palette suitable for everyday and travel. However, it has some downsides such as useless first color, very dark last color, and small size for the price.
Pros
  • Pigmented shimmer shadows
  • Affordable
  • Comes with a double-sided brush and mini mirror
  • Pigmented and vibrant colors
  • Lasts all day
Cons
  • Matte shades are not the same as pictured
  • Some shades are weird
Bottom Line
This product is affordable and comes with two palettes, but the matte shades are not the same as pictured and some shades are weird. The shimmer shadows are pigmented and vibrant, but the matte shades lack pigment and color. The product is powdery and not long-lasting, and the colors change after 30 minutes of wear. However, it is blendable and feels light on the skin.
Pros
  • Affordable price
  • Good color selection
  • Smooth application
  • Long-lasting
  • Great for everyday use
Cons
  • Inconsistent quality
  • Smashed product upon arrival
Bottom Line
The Revlon Colorstay Eyeshadow palette offers a good selection of colors at an affordable price, but the quality may be inconsistent. The shadows have a smooth application and are long-lasting, but some shades may not suit all skin tones and the formula may clump and fall off the eyelids.
Pros
  • Reasonably priced
  • 100% matte shades
  • Great neutral colors
  • Smooth application
  • Nice matte finish
Cons
  • Some shades may be too dark or orange-based
  • Some shades may lack color
Bottom Line
This eyeshadow palette offers a range of 100% matte shades with good color payoff and smooth application. It is reasonably priced and foolproof for less confident users. However, some shades may be too dark or orange-based, and the shimmer palette may be too sparkly for some.
Pros
  • Beautiful natural shades in a matte finish
  • Goes on easily and deposits rich, subtle color
  • Great value for the price
  • Stays in place until you take it off
  • True to the pictures
Cons
  • Lids were dirty
  • Not as pigmented as other brands
Bottom Line
This eyeshadow palette is a great value for the price and provides beautiful natural shades in a matte finish. However, it may require primer and setting spray and the brushes are mediocre. The palette is smaller than pictured and the colors may not be exactly as pictured.

The Ultimate Buying Guide for Matte Eye Shadow

Overview

Matte eye shadow is a must-have for any makeup lover's collection. It's versatile, easy to wear, and perfect for creating a variety of looks, from natural to dramatic. However, with so many options on the market, it can be tough to know where to start. In this buying guide, we'll explore the different types of matte eye shadow, key considerations to keep in mind when making a purchase, the most important features to look for, and tips for getting the most out of your matte eye shadow.

Types

Matte eye shadow comes in a variety of types, including pressed powder, loose powder, cream, and stick. Pressed powder is the most common type and is easy to apply with a brush. Loose powder is great for blending and can be applied with a brush or your fingers. Cream and stick formulas are ideal for those who want a more intense color payoff and are perfect for creating a smoky eye or bold look.

Key Considerations

When shopping for matte eye shadow, there are a few key considerations to keep in mind. First, consider your skin tone. If you have fair skin, lighter shades like beige and taupe will look best. If you have medium skin, try shades like warm browns and coppers. If you have dark skin, go for deeper shades like espresso and black. Next, think about the texture and finish you prefer. Do you want a soft, velvety finish or a more intense, pigmented look? Finally, consider the ingredients. Look for matte eye shadow that is free of harmful chemicals and is cruelty-free if that's important to you.

Features

When shopping for matte eye shadow, there are a few key features to look for. First, consider the color selection. Look for a palette that has a range of shades that will work for a variety of looks. Next, consider the staying power. You want a matte eye shadow that will last all day without creasing or fading. Finally, consider the blendability. A good matte eye shadow should be easy to blend and layer for a seamless finish.

Prices

Matte eye shadow comes in a range of prices, from drugstore to high-end. You can find great options at any price point, but keep in mind that higher-end brands may have more pigmented formulas and longer-lasting wear.

Tips

- Use a primer before applying matte eye shadow to ensure it stays in place all day.

- Apply lighter shades as a base and darker shades in the crease for a natural-looking gradient.

- Use a damp brush to intensify the color payoff.

- Blend, blend, blend! Matte eye shadow can look harsh if not blended properly.

FAQs

Q: Can I use matte eye shadow on my eyebrows?

A: Yes! Matte eye shadow can be used to fill in and shape your eyebrows.

Q: Can I wear matte eye shadow if I have oily eyelids?

A: Yes, but make sure to use a primer to prevent creasing.

Q: Can I wear matte eye shadow if I have sensitive eyes?

A: Yes, but look for formulas that are free of harsh chemicals and fragrances.

Q: How do I remove matte eye shadow?

A: Use a gentle eye makeup remover or micellar water to remove matte eye shadow.

Runner-Ups

Pros
  • Affordable price
  • Neutral colors
  • Matte finish
  • Good for natural look
  • Subtle color payoff
Cons
  • Colors not as advertised
  • Hard to open
Bottom Line
This product is a good option for those looking for an affordable, neutral, and matte eyeshadow palette. However, the color payoff may be too subtle for some, and the colors may not be as advertised.
Pros
  • Colors are nearly identical to the pic online.
  • Palette is great for a natural look.
  • Pigmented and creamy.
  • Matte and neutral.
  • Good product at an affordable price.
Cons
  • Fallout.
  • Powder falls on the face.
Bottom Line
This palette is a good option for those who want a natural, matte look at an affordable price. The colors are pigmented and blendable, but there may be some fallout and issues with the packaging.
Pros
  • Nice selection of matte, skin tone colors
  • Lasting and functional set of good colors
  • Perfect for everyday wear and work
  • Subtle and buildable colors
  • Helps make eyes look more youthful
Cons
  • Not much variation between colors
  • Not very dark or visible
Bottom Line
W7 Mighty Matte Neutral Nude shadows are a great choice for those who prefer matte, skin tone colors for everyday wear and work. The colors are subtle and buildable, and the palette is pigmented and durable. However, it may not work for fair skin, and the top may come unhinged. It is also not hypoallergenic and may not look as good as more expensive palettes.
Pros
  • Goes on smoothly and stays on
  • Reasonably priced
  • Perfect color for skin tone
  • Easy to use
  • Great quality eyeshadow
Cons
  • Small size
  • No applicator included
Bottom Line
This eyeshadow is a great quality product that goes on smoothly and stays on, with a reasonable price. However, it has a small size and no applicator included, and some shades may have a chalky and chunky texture. It is important to be aware of the misleading color shown and the fragile packaging.
Pros
  • Good color selection
  • Lasts a decently long time
  • Flatters the eye with a bit of shimmer
  • Neutral colors
  • Good value
Cons
  • Colors received were not as represented
  • Random shade received
Bottom Line
Covergirl eyeshadows offer a good color selection, decent longevity, and a bit of shimmer. However, be aware that the colors received may not match the representation, and some shades may have too much shimmer or not be as dark as expected. Overall, a good value for the price.
Please add more products to compare
You can compare up to four products at once
{{compareData.brand}}