10Best.Guide

Maybelline Eye Shadow

Top Picks

Last Updated: September, 2023
Pros
  • Inexpensive
  • Great color quartet
  • Rich color with great coverage
  • Gold and cream colors are beautiful
  • Eyeshadow arrived in perfect condition
Cons
  • Product was returned
  • Smudged eyeshadow
Bottom Line
This eyeshadow product is a good option for those on a budget and looking for a compact and durable option for travel. However, some shades may lack pigment and the packaging may arrive dusty or with a wax crayon smell. Buyers should be aware of misleading pictures and names and inspect the product upon arrival.
Pros
  • Beautiful linen color
  • Good for changing makeup routine
  • Sage color is stunning and lasts well
  • Good for wet brush application
  • Reliable and good for hazel eyes
Cons
  • Arrived broken during shipping
  • Specks of color fall onto other areas
Bottom Line
This product has beautiful colors that are good for changing up your makeup routine, but be aware of potential shipping issues and color discrepancies. It is a good value for the price and works well for wet brush application.
Pros
  • Great color selection
  • Easy to use stick format
  • Good staying power
  • Can be used as eyeliner
  • Good for mature eyes
Cons
  • Inconsistent product quality
  • Packaging is lacking
Bottom Line
Maybelline Color Tattoo Eyeshadow is a convenient and easy-to-use stick eyeshadow that comes in a variety of colors. While it has good staying power and can be used as eyeliner, the product quality can be inconsistent and the packaging is lacking. It is also relatively expensive for a drugstore brand.
Pros
  • Inexpensive
  • Good color selection
  • Great coverage
  • Long-lasting
  • Compact and good for travel
Cons
  • Applicators are low quality
  • Colors may not match the picture
Bottom Line
Maybelline New York Expert Wear Eyeshadow Quads are a good choice for those looking for an affordable and long-lasting eyeshadow. However, the quality of the applicators is low, and the colors may not match the picture. The limited color selection may not be suitable for all skin tones.
Pros
  • Inexpensive
  • Lovely color quartet
  • Rich color with great coverage
  • Gold and cream colors are nice highlights
  • Great for eyebrows
Cons
  • Product was returned
  • Smudge of shadow on arrival
Bottom Line
This eyeshadow is a good value for the price and has some nice colors, but there are some quality issues and the colors may not work for everyone.

The Ultimate Buying Guide for Maybelline Eye Shadow: Tips, Types, and Reviews

Overview

Maybelline is a popular drugstore makeup brand that offers a wide range of eye shadow options. With so many choices available, it can be challenging to find the perfect eye shadow that suits your needs. This buying guide will help you navigate the different types of Maybelline eye shadow and provide you with key considerations, features, prices, tips, and FAQs to help you make an informed purchasing decision.

Types

Maybelline offers several types of eye shadow, including:

1. Matte Eye Shadow: This type of eye shadow has no shimmer or glitter and provides a smooth, velvety finish.

2. Shimmer Eye Shadow: Shimmer eye shadow contains tiny particles that reflect light, giving your eyes a subtle sparkle.

3. Metallic Eye Shadow: Metallic eye shadow has a high-shine finish and is perfect for creating bold, dramatic looks.

4. Cream Eye Shadow: Cream eye shadow has a creamy texture that is easy to apply and blend. It's perfect for creating a natural, everyday look.

5. Powder Eye Shadow: Powder eye shadow is easy to apply and blend, making it a popular choice for beginners. It comes in both matte and shimmer finishes.

Key Considerations

When choosing a Maybelline eye shadow, consider the following:

1. Skin Tone: Choose an eye shadow that complements your skin tone. For example, warm-toned eye shadows look best on warm skin tones, while cool-toned eye shadows look best on cool skin tones.

2. Eye Color: Consider your eye color when choosing an eye shadow. Certain shades can enhance your eye color and make them pop.

3. Finish: Decide what type of finish you want, whether it's matte, shimmer, or metallic.

Features

Maybelline eye shadow offers the following features:

1. Long-lasting: Maybelline eye shadow is formulated to last all day without smudging or fading.

2. Pigmented: Maybelline eye shadow is highly pigmented, meaning you get intense color payoff with just one swipe.

3. Blendable: Maybelline eye shadow is easy to blend, making it perfect for creating a seamless, natural look.

Prices

Maybelline eye shadow is an affordable option compared to high-end brands. Prices range from $5 to $15, depending on the type of eye shadow and the retailer.

Tips

Here are some tips for using Maybelline eye shadow:

1. Use a primer: To make your eye shadow last longer, apply a primer to your eyelids before applying your eye shadow.

2. Use the right brush: Use a flat brush to apply your eye shadow and a fluffy brush to blend it out.

3. Experiment with different shades: Don't be afraid to try different shades to find the perfect eye shadow for you.

FAQs

Q: Is Maybelline eye shadow good quality?

A: Yes, Maybelline eye shadow is known for its high quality and affordability.

Q: Can Maybelline eye shadow be used as eyeliner?

A: Yes, you can use Maybelline eye shadow as eyeliner by applying it with an angled brush.

Q: How do I remove Maybelline eye shadow?

A: Use a makeup remover or micellar water to remove Maybelline eye shadow.

Conclusion:

Maybelline eye shadow is a great option for those looking for affordable, high-quality eye shadow. By considering your skin tone, eye color, and finish preferences, you can find the perfect Maybelline eye shadow to enhance your eyes and complete your makeup look.

Runner-Ups

Pros
  • Inexpensive
  • Lovely color quartet
  • Rich color with great coverage
  • Gold and cream colors are nice highlights
  • Great for eyebrows
Cons
  • Product was returned
  • Smudged eyeshadow
Bottom Line
This eyeshadow product is a good choice for those looking for an inexpensive option with lovely colors and good coverage. However, some shades may lack pigment and the packaging may be dusty or misleading.
Pros
  • Beautiful linen color
  • Great alternative to black eyeliner
  • Khaki Camo shade brings out green eyes
  • Sage color is stunning and lasts well
  • Good highlight for eyes
Cons
  • Arrived broken and crumbly
  • Specks of color fall onto other areas
Bottom Line
This product has beautiful shades that are great for highlighting and bringing out eye colors. However, there are issues with packaging and color accuracy that may be a concern for some buyers.
Pros
  • Beautiful linen color
  • Great alternative to black eyeliner
  • Khaki Camo shade is stunning
  • Sage color is stunning and lasts well
  • Great highlight for eyes
Cons
  • Arrived broken and crumbly
  • Specks of color in places where it wasn't applied
Bottom Line
This eye shadow has a variety of beautiful shades that are reliable and long-lasting. However, some shades may not appear as advertised and there have been issues with packaging and skin irritation.
Pros
  • Affordable
  • Nice range of shades
  • Good for everyday wear
  • Can be used for filling in brows
  • Suitable for fair skin and nude/earthy tones
Cons
  • Some colors are sheer
  • Some colors are not pigmented
Bottom Line
The Maybelline New York Nudes Eyeshadow Palette is an affordable option for those looking for a range of nude shades. While some colors may require a primer or water to get the desired color transfer, the palette is versatile and can be used for everyday wear and filling in brows. However, some colors are sheer and not pigmented, and the eyeshadow may not last all day.
Pros
  • Nice range of shades
  • Affordable
  • Good for everyday wear
  • Can be used for filling in brows
  • Can be used for all seasons
Cons
  • Some colors are sheer
  • Some colors are not as pigmented as others
Bottom Line
The Maybelline New York Nudes Eyeshadow Palette is an affordable option for those who prefer nude and earthy tones. The eyeshadows are pigmented, but some colors may require a primer or water to get the desired color transfer. The palette has a nice mix of shiny and matte shades and can be used for filling in brows. However, some colors are sheer, not as pigmented as others, and may not show up on tan or dark skin tones. The eyeshadows have a powdery texture and may not last all day.
Please add more products to compare
You can compare up to four products at once
{{compareData.brand}}